Ashvakas
| Articles related to Kambojas |
|---|
| Location |
| Language and ethnicity |
| Etymology |
| in Indian Literature |
| Kamboja Migration |
| Horsemen |
| Ashvakas |
| Kambojas of Panini |
| Kambojas and Manusmriti |
| Parama Kamboja |
The Ashvakas or Ashvakans (Paninian Ashvakayans) are very ancient people of north-east Afghanistan (Nuristan), modern Pakistan , including the Chitral-Valley and north-west India (Punjab). They are/were a sub-group of the Greater Kambojas/Kamboyajes and partitioned in eastern, western and southern Ashvakas. They find mention in the Puranas, Mahabharata and other ancient Sanskrit and Pali literature. Today their descends are mostly heterogeneous people.
Sanskrit term ashva , Iranian aspa and Prakrit assa means horse. The name Ashvaka/Ashvakan or Assaka is said to be derived from Sanskrit Ashva or Prakrit Assa and it literally denotes someone connected with the horses---hence: a horseman, or a cavalryman. The Ashvakas were especially engaged in the occupation of breeding, raising and training war horses, as also in providing expert cavalry services to outside nations, hence they also constituted the kshatriya class of warriors.
Panini notes the Aspas and the Ashvakas of modern Nuristan or as well known as Kafirland, Gandhara valleys, Punjab and as Ashvakans/Ashvakayana respectively.[1]
Geographical location
The Ashvakas were resident in the eastern parts of modern Afghanistan (Nuristan) and their population reached up to the Indus-River and to parts of Punjab. Their metropolitan areas were in the area of Swat and Kunar-River, including the southern Pakistani provinces of Sindh and Balochistan .
Ancient Sanskrit literature also refers to another clan called Ashmaka or Assaka which represented an Indo-Aryan Janapada located on river Godavari in south-west India. Ashmaka literally means land of stone.
Ashvakas: a branch of Kambojas
Buddhist Texts evidence
Aruppa-Niddesa of Visuddhimagga by Buddhaghosa describes the Kamboja land as the base of horses.[6]
Buddhist texts like Manorathapurni, Kunala Jataka and Samangalavilasini speak of Kamboja land as the land of horses e.g:
- Kambojo assa.nam ayata.nam...[7].
- Translation:
- Kamboja, the land of horses (assa).
The cluster assa in the above expression of Sumangavilasini means horse, which on adding suffix -ka gives the Prakrit Assaka which term when considered in the context of the above expression denotes the following:
- Assaka = The Kambojas connected with horses; horsemen; cavalry.
- Assaka = The Kamboja land or Janapada.
Similarly, the Sanskrit Ashvaka can be derived from Sanskrit Ashva which, likewise, denote the following:
- Ashvaka = The Kambojas connected with horses; horsemen; cavalry.
- Ashvaka = The Kamboja land or Janapada.
From the above statement, it is very obvious that term Assaka or Ashvaka stood for the Kamboja land, Kamboja people, Kamboja horsemen or the Kamboja cavalry..
Mahabharata evidence
In the Anushasnaparava section of Mahabharata, the Kambojas are specifically designated as ashava.yuddha.kushalah (expert cavalry).[8]
Commenting on the above verse of Mahabharta, noted scholars like Dr K. P. Jayswal observe that "Since the Kambojas were famous for their horses (ashva) and as a cavalry-men (Ashva-yudhah kushalah), hence the Ashvakas i.e. horsemen was the term popularly applied to them".[9]
Vishnudharmotra Purana evidence
Vishnudharmotra Purana too specifically attests that the Kambojas and Gandharas were proficient in cavalry warfare i.e. in Ashva-Yuddha.[10]
Ashvaka coins and Arthashastra evidence
The coins of Ashsvakas refer to themselves as vatasvaka (vata.asvaka), which in Sanskrit, equals varta-ashvaka i.e Ashvakas engaged in varta profession.[11]
The use of prikritic vata (Sanskrit varta) appellation by the Ashvakas in their coins reminds one of the Varta.shastr.opajivin descriptions of the Kambojas as attested by Kautiliya in his Arthashastra.[12]
The above view is further reinforced by Brahtsamhita of Varaha Mihira which also says that the Kambojas lived by shastr and varta.[13]
The Asvayanas (Kambojas) have been attested to be good cattle breeders and agricuturists by classical writers. This is clear from big number of the bullocks, 230,000 according to Arrian, of a size and shape superior to what the Macedonians had not known, which Alexander captured from them and decided to send them to Macedonia for agriculture.[14]
The Ashvaka Kambojas are also attested to have fielded 30,000 strong cavalry, 30 elephants and 20,000 infantry against Alexander.[15]
These above staggering figures about agricultural cattle and the war horses of the Ashvakas sufficiently prove the correctness of Kautiliya's statement on the Kambojas which portrays the Kambojas as living both by warfare (shastr.opajivin) as well as by agriculture/cattle-culture (varta.opajivin).
The above facts, when viewed in the light of time and space propinquity, evidently connect the Ashvakas with the varta.shastr.opajivin Kambojas of the Arthashastra.[16]
More opinions from scholars
Sir Thomas H. Holdich, in the his classic book, The Gates of India, writes that
the Aspasians (Aspasios) represent the modern Kafirs.[17] But the modern Kafirs, especially the
French scholars like Dr E. Lamotte have identified the Ashvakas with the Kambojas of ancient Sanskrit literature.[18] [19]
Dr L. M. Joshi and Dr Fauja Singh like Dr E. Lamotte, also identify the Assakenoi and Aspasios of classical writings as the clans of the Kambojas.[20]
J. W. McCrindle says that the modern Afghanistan -- the Kaofue (Kambu) of Hiun Tsang was ancient Kamboja, and further says that the name Afghan evidently derives from the Ashavakan, the Assakenoi of Arrian. Thus it can be seen that Dr McCrindle clearly identifies the classical Assakenoi/Aspasio with the Sanskrit Kambojas.[21]
Dr H. C. Raychayudhury, Dr B. N. Mukerjee write: "With the expression Assa.nam Ayata.nam---land of horses
used by Pali texts in reference to the Kambojas, may be compared the names
Aspasios and Assakenoi given by
Istituto italiano per il Medio ed Estremo Oriente has also identified the Aspasios-Asvayanas, Assakenoi-Asvakayanas with the Kambojas of Eastern Afghanistan, who were noted for their horses [23].
Dr S. M. Ali has identified the ancient Kambojas of the Puranic literature with the inhabitants of the Kafir valleys,[24] who, as we know from classical writings, were none else than the Aspasio off-shoot of the Ashvakan Kambojas.
Dr R. C. Majumdar, Romila Thappar, noted historians of India also take the Ashvakas as same people as the Kambojas and they connect them with the people of Kafirstan.
Dr Buddha Parkash notes: "The Macedonian conqueror made short shrifts of the arrangements of
Darius and over-running
These Ashvayana and Ashvakayana clans had fought the invader to a man. When worst came to worst, even the Ashvakayana Kamboj women had taken up arms and joined their fighting husbands, thus preferring "a glorious death to a life of dishonor".[26] Diodorus gives a detailed graphic picture as to how the Ashvakayanas (Kambojs) had conducted themselves when faced with the sudden treacherous onslaught from Alexander.[27]
Commenting on the heroic resistance and courage displayed by the Ashvakayanas (Kambojas) in the face of treacerous onslaught of Alexander, Dr Buddha Prakash remarks: "Hardly could any Thermopylae be more glorious !"[28]
Afghan and Ashvakan relationship
Numerous scholars of note now believe that the name Afghan has been derived from Sanskrit Ashvaka or Ashvakan
(q.v), the Assakenoi of Arrian[29]. This view was propounded by scholars like
The Afghans should correspondingly have belonged to the southern Ashvakans of modern Pashtunwa and parts of Baluchistan (and maybe as well of Sindh) who migrated in the second Millennium A.D to north- and eastward to north India until Bengal. In Peshawar and it's surrounding regions and valleys they replaced the indigenous population of Gakhars (hinduized Persians and Parsis) slowly but for certain and their settled areas Babur mentioned in his Baburnamah as Afghanistan and the people as Afghans. The Afghans started their career in the 13. century as slaves of the Persian Ghurids and ruled after the death of the Persian Ghurid general Aybak the Indo-Ghurid Empire further as Slave-Dynasty of Delhi as well known as Mamluk dynasty of Delhi, see on Lody-Dynasty and the Khilji-Dynasty .
Kamboja Cavalry in ancient wars
The Kambojas were basically a republican people. They were constituted into military Sanghas and Corporations to manage their affairs, as Kautiliya and Mahabharata amply attest for us. They are also attested to be living as Ayuddha-jivi or Shastr-opajivis, which means that the Kamboja cavalry offered its military services to other nations as well. There are numerous references to Kambojas being requistioned as cavalry troopers in ancient wars by outside nations.
A few illustrative references from ancient literature are presented below to prove this point.
Military supporters of Haihaya Yadavas
According to numerous Puranas, the military Corporations of the Shakas, Yavanas, Kambojas, Pahlavas and Paradas, known as five hordes (pānca-ganah), had militarily supported the Haihaya and Talajunga Kshatriyas in depriving Ikshvaku king Bahu (the 7th king in descent from Harishchandra), of his Ayodhya kingdom.
A generation later, Bahu's son, Sagara recaptured Ayodhya after totally destroying the Haihaya and Talajangha Kshatriyas in the battle. Story goes that king Sagara had punished these foreign hordes by changing their hair-styles and turning them into degraded Kshatriyas.[39]
Military supporters of king Jarasandha of Magadha
Bhagavata Purana refers to a war between Jarasandha and Yadavas led by Sri Krshna. The Kambojas came as military allies of Jarasandha, king of Magadha. There is reference to the siege of Gomant Parvata where the Kamboja army was positioned on its east flank.[40] Bhagavata Purana[41] speaks of the Kamboja General as a powerfully armed mighty warrior (samiti-salina atta-capah Kamboja).
Military supporters of Kurus in Mahabharta war
General Sudakshina of the Kambojas was invited by Duryodhana, the Kuru king of Hastinapura to help him in the Mahabharata war against the Pandavas. Sudakshina Kamboj came to his side with one Akshauhini powerful army of ferocious Central Asian warriors which also included the Shakas and Yavanas, besides the Kambojas.[42] Of the ten distinguished Generals appointed by Duryodhana to efficiently manage his vast host of army, Sudakshina Kamboja was one such distinguished General.[43]
Military supporters of Vashishtha against Vishwamitra
Bala Kanda of Valmiki Ramayana refers to a battle between sage Vasishtha and king Vishwamitra of Kanauj. Sage Visishtha had sought the military assistance of the Kambojas, Shakas, Yavanas, Pahlavas, Kiratas and other Mlechchas from the north-west. King Vishwamitra had lost all his sons in the battle. In remorse, he renounced the world and turned into an ascetic after the war.[44]
In the armies of Persians against Greeks
Herodotus attests that the Gandarian mercenaries (Gandharans/Kambojans) from the twentieth strapy of the
Similarly, the men of the Mountain Land (Akaufaka), from north of Kabol-River equivalent to medieval Kohistan (Pakistan), figure in the army of Darius III against Alexander at Arbela with a cavalry and fifteen elephants.[46]
These mercenaries were the well known parvatiya Ayuddhajivins of Panini's Ashtadhyayi[47] located on either side of the Hindukush and who belonged to Kamboja/Gandhara group of a warrior caste.[48]
Military supporters of Chandra Gupta Maurya
The Buddhist drama Mudra-rakashas by Visakha Dutta and the Jaina work Parisishtaparvan refer to Chandragupta's alliance with Himalayan king Parvataka. The Himalayan alliance gave Chandragupta a formidable composite army made up of the Shakas, Yavanas, Kambojas, Kiratas, Parasikas and Bahlikas as attested by Mudra-Rakashas (Mudra-Rakshasa 2).[49]
With the help of these frontier martial tribes from Central Asia, Chandragupta was able to defeat the Greek successors of Alexander the Great and the Nanda/Nandin rulers of Magadha so as to found the powerful Maurya empire in northern India, at least for a short time till the Kushans and other ruler conquered north-west India.
Military supporters of king Brihadratha Maurya
The Kalika Purana, one of the eighteen Upa-Puranas of the Hindus, refers to a war between Brahmanical king Kalika (supposed to be Pusyamitra Sunga) and Buddhist king Kali (supposed to be Maurya king Brihadratha (187-180 BCE)) and notes the Shakas, Kambojas, Khasas etc as a powerful military allies of king Kali. The Purana further notes these Barbarians as taking orders from their women,[50] which culture was typical of tribes located on Oxus/north-west.
Yavana and Kamboja cavalry invades Mid India
Patanjali around 150 BCE and Yuga Purana chapter of Gargi-Samhita refer to
second century BCE Yavana attack on Saketa, Panchala,
Mathura and
Saka, Kamboja, Pahlava cavalry invades north-west India
The evidence suggests that the second century BCE Saka invasion of western India was probably carried out jointly by the Sakas, Pahlavas, Kambojas, Paradas, Rishikas and other allied tribes from the north-west. As a result sections of Kambojas, Pahlavas, Rishikas etc had also settled into south-west and southern India as is attested by numerous Sanskrit literature of the post-Christian period [4].
Kamboja cavalry in the army of Palas of Bengal
The Palas employed mercenary forces and certainly recruited horses from Kambojas as is clear from their own Inscriptions.[52] According to Dr N. G. Majumdar, if horses could be brought from Kamboja, it is also perfectly reasonable to suppose that for trade and other purposes, some adventurers (from Kamboja) could also have found their way into that province.[53] Scholars like Dr R. C. Majumdar observe that the armed forces of Pala Dynasty of Bengal had included foreigners like the Khasas, Hunas, Kambojas, Kulitas, Karnatas, Latas and Malavas etc. Writes Dr R. C. Majumdar: "Mercenary soldiers (Specially cavalry) might have been recruited from the Kambojas and some of them might have been influential chiefs". According Dr Majumdar and many other scholars, some courageous military General of the Kambojas had later captured north-western parts of Bengal from the Palas and founded the Kamboja dynasty in Bengal.[54]
Kamboja cavalry in the army of Gurjara-Pratiharas
Scholars also state that the Kamboja cavalry had also formed part of the Gurjara-Pratihara armed forces in 8th/10th centuries AD. They had come to Bengal with the Pratiharas when the latter conquered part of the province.[55][56][57][58][59][60] In fact, there is stated to have been a separate regiment of the Kambojas in the army of the Pratiharas which was given the responsibility to defend the northern-eastern parts of their empire adjoining with the Palas of Bengal. When the fortunes of the Palas sagged low after the death of Narayanapala in early tenth century, these Kambojas, the military associates of the Pratiharas had seized Gauda from Pala king Rajyapala and laid the foundation of the Kamboja empire in north-west Bengal.[61][62]
And so forth and so on
References
- ^ Ashtadshyayi: Sutra IV-1, 110; Nadadi gana IV-1, 99.
- ^ Historie du Bouddhisme Indien, p 110, E. Lamotte; East and West, 1950, pp 28, 157-58, Istituto italiano per il Medio ed Estremo Oriente, Editor, Prof Giuseppe Tucci, Co-editors Prof Mario Bussagli, Prof Lionello Lanciotti; Panjab Past and Present, pp 9-10, Dr Buddha Parkash; Hindu Polity, A Contitutional History of India in Hindu Times, 1978, p 140, Dr K. P. Jayswal; Political History of Ancient India, 1996, p 133 fn 6, pp 216-20, (Also Commentary, op. cit., p 576, fn 22), Dr H. C. Raychaudhury, Dr B. N. Mukerjee; Raja Poros, 1990, Publication Buareau, Punjabi University, Patiala; History of Panjab, Vol I, (Editors): Dr Fauja Singh, Dr L. M. Josh, Publication Bureau, Panjabi University, Patiala; History of Poros, 1967, pp 12,39, Dr Buddha Prakash; Ancient Kamboja, People and country, 1981, pp 271-72, 278, Dr J. L. Kamboj; These Kamboj People, 1979, pp 119, 192; Kambojas, Through the Ages, 2005, pp 129, 218-19, S Kirpal Singh etc.
- ^ Mahabharata 6.90.3-4.
- ^ Arthashastra 2.30.29.
- ^ Journal of American Oriental society, 1889, p 257, American Oriental Society; Mahabharata 10.18.13.
- ^ Aruppa-Niddesa 10.28.
- ^ Samangalavilasini, Vol I, p 124.
- ^
- Sanskrit:
- tatha Yavana Kamboja Mathuram.abhitash cha ye |
- ete 'ashava.yuddha.kushalahdasinatyasi charminah || 5 ||
- (MBH 12.101.5, Kumbhakonam Ed).
- ^ Hindu Polity, 1978, pp 121, 140, Dr K. P. Jayswal.
- ^ Vishnudharmotra Purana, Part II, Ch 118; also see: Military Wisdom in the Puranas, 1969, p 64, Prof Sen Sarma.
- ^ Journal of Royal Asiatic Society, pp 98-100: History and Culture of Indian People, the Age of Imperial Unity, Vol II, p 45, Dr A. D. Pusalkar, Dr R. C. Majumdar, Dr Munshi etc.
- ^ Arthashastra 11.1.4.
- ^ Brhatsamhita, 5.35
- ^ History of Panjab, Vol I, p 226, Dr L. M. Joshi, Dr Fauja Singh; Ancient Kamboja, People and the Country, 1981, p 247, Dr J. L. Kamboj; cf: A Historical Dictionary of Indian Food (Oxford India Paperbacks), p 91, K. T. Achaya February 2001.
- ^ Ancient India, 2000, p 261, Dr V. D. Mahajan.
- ^ Ancient Kamboja, People and the Country, 1981, p 11, 226.
- ^ The Gates of India, p 102-03.
- ^ Historie du Bouddhisme Indien, p 110, E. Lamotte.
- ^ See also: East and West, 1950, pp 28, 157-58, Istituto italiano per il Medio ed Estremo Oriente, Editor, Prof Giuseppe Tucci, Co-editors Prof Mario Bussagli, Prof Lionello Lanciotti.
- ^ History of Panjab, Vol I, (Editors): Dr Fauja Singh, Dr L. M. Josh, Publication Bureau, Panjabi University, Patiala; see also Ancient Kamboja, People and country, 1981, pp 271-72, 278, Dr J. L. Kamboj; These Kamboj People, 1979, pp 119, 192, K. S. Dardi.
- ^ Alexandra's Invasion of India, p 38; Megasthenes and Arrian, p 180, J. McCrindle.
- ^ Political History of Ancient India, 1996, p 133, p 216 ffn 2, p 576; Commentary Dr B. N. Mukerjee; cf: MBH VI.90.3.
- ^ East and West, 1950, pp 28, 149/158, Istituto italiano per il Medio ed Estremo Oriente, Editor, Prof Giuseppe Tucci, Co-editors Prof Mario Bussagli, Prof Lionello Lanciotti.
- ^ Geography of the Puranas p 143.
- ^ Panjab Past and Present, pp 9-10, Dr Buddha Parkash; See also: History of Porus, pp 12, 38.
- ^ Diodorus in McCrindle, p 270.
- ^ Writes Diodorus: "Undismayed by the greatness of their danger, the Ashvakayanas (Kambojas) drew their ranks together in the form of a ring within which they placed their women and children to guard them on all sides against their assailants. As they had now become desperate, and by their audacity and feats of valour, made the conflict in which they closed, hot work for the enemy--great was the astonishment and alarm which the peril of the crisis had created. For, as the combatants were locked together fighting hand-to-hand, death and wounds were dealt round in every variety of form. While many were thus wounded, and not a few killed, the women, taking the arms of the fallen, fought side by side with their men. Accordingly, some of them who had supplied themselves with arms, did their best to cover their husbands with their shields, while the others, who were without arms, did much to impede the enemy by flinging themselves upon them and catching hold of their shields. The defenders, however, after fighting desperately along with their wives, were at last overpowered by superior numbers, and thus met a glorious death which they would have disdained to exchange for the life of dishonour" (See: Diodorus in McCrindle, p 269/270; History of Punjab, 1997, p 229, Editors: Dr Fauja Singh, Dr L. M. Joshi; Classical Accounts of India, p 112-113; Ancient Kamboja, People and the Country, 1981, p 283-286, Dr J. L. Kamboj; The Kambojas Through the Ages, 2005, p 134, Kirpal Singh).
- ^ History of Punjab, Vol I, 1997, p 229.
- ^ Arrian writes them Assakenoi. Strabo also calls them Assakanoi, but Curtius calls them Assacani.
- ^ Indische Alterthumskunde, Vol I, fn 6; also Vol II, p 129, et al.
- ^ "The name Afghan has been derived from Asvakan, the Assakenoi of Arrian... " (Megasthenes and Arrian, p 180. See also: Alexander's Invasion of India, p 38; J. W. McCrindle).
- ^ Etude Sur la Geog Grecque & c, pp 39-47, M. V. de Saint Martin.
- ^ This includes Dr H. H. Wilson, L. Bishop, W. Crooke, H. K. Kakar, J. C. Vidyalnar, Chandra Chakravorty, Dr M. R. Singh, P. Smith, N. L. Dey, Henry Yule, A. C. Burnell, Dr J. L. Kamboj, S. Kirpal Singh and several others. http://books.google.com/books?vid=LCCN01005366&id=GJQn7XA6Cz4C&pg=RA12-PA156&lpg=RA12-PA156&dq=Ashvaka
- ^ Literary History of Ancient India in Relation to Its Racial and Linguistic Affiliations, 1970, p 17, Chandra Chakraberty.
- ^ Shi jie jian wen, 1980, p 68, Shi jie zhi shi chu ban she.
- ^ Ref: Sva, 1915, p 113, Christopher Molesworth Birdwood.
- ^ Al-Hind, The Making of Indo-Islamic World, 2002, p 84, Andre Wink; Journal of Indian History Golden Jubilee Volume, 1973, p 470, University of Kerala, Department of History.
- ^ Historical Geography of Madhya Pradesh, From Early Records, 1977, p 3, Dr P. K. Bhattacharya; Proceedings of the World of Sanskrit Conference. 1985, p 783, Intrnational association of Sanskrit.
- ^ Harivamsa 14.1-19
- ^ Bhagvata Purana, 10.52.22.
- ^ Bhagavata Purana 2.7.35.
- ^ MBH 5.19.21-23.
- ^ MBH 5.155.30-33.
- ^ Ramayana, 1.54, 1.55.
- ^ Herodotus, IV.65-66.
- ^ History of Persian Empire, p 232, Dr A. M. Olmstead; Arrian's Anabasis III, 8.3-6; Political History of Ancient India, 1996, p 216, Dr Raychaudhury.
- ^ Ashtadhyayi Sutra IV.3.91.
- ^ India as Known to Panini, pp 49, 437, Dr V. S. Aggarwala.
- ^
- Sanskrit:
- asti tava Shaka-Yavana-Kirata-Kamboja-Parasika-Bahlika parbhutibhih
- Chankyamatipragrahittaishcha Chandergupta Parvateshvara
- balairudidhibhiriva parchalitsalilaih samantaad uprudham Kusumpurama
- (Mudra-Rakshasa 2).
- ^ Kalika Purana, III (6), 22-40.
- ^ MBH 3.188.34-36.
- ^ Munghyr Inscriptions B.8, V.13; See also: Epigraphia Indica, Vol XVIII, 1926-27, p 305; Ancient Kamboja, People and the Country, 1981, p 9-10, Dr J. L. Kamboj.
- ^ Epigraphia Indica, XXII.153.
- ^ History of Ancient Bengal, 1971, p 127, Dr R. C. Majumdar; The Dacca University Studies, Vol I, No 2, April 1936, p 132; Also: Indian Historical Quarterly, XV-4, Dec. 1939, p 511, Dr H. C. Ray; The Kambojas Through the Ages, 2005, pp 216, 228, S Kirpal Singh; Ancient Kamboja, People and the Country, 1981, pp 330-332.
- ^ Indian Historical Quarterly, XV-4, Dec, 1939, p 511 Dr H. C. Ray.
- ^ History of Ancient Bengal, 1971, pp 182-83, Dr R. C. Majumdar.
- ^ Indian Historical Quarterly, 1963, p 625.
- ^ Dynastic History of Magadha, 1977, p 208.
- ^ Epigraphia Indiaca, XVIII, p 304ff.
- ^ The Dynamics of Santal Traditions in Present Society, 2003, p 208 etc; Journal of Oriental studies, 1954, p 381, University of Hong Kong, Institute of Oriental Studies (Also see refs quoted by the authors)
- ^ The Dynastic History of the Northern India, p 311, fn.1, Dr H. C. Raychaudhury.
- ^ The Kambojas Through the Ages, 2005, pp 216, 228, S Kirpal Singh; Ancient Kamboja, People and the Country, 1981, pp 330-332, Dr Kamboj.
See also
Books and Articles
- Geographical Data in Early Puranas, A Critical Study, 1972, p 179 Dr M. R. Singh
- Dictionary of Greek & Roman Geography, Vol-I, 1966, William Smith, Phillip Smith
- Geographical Dictionary of ancient and Medieval India, Dr Nundo Lal Dey
- Itihaas Parvesh (Hindi), 1948, Dr Jaychandra Vidyalankar
- Ancient India as Described in Megasthenes and Arrian, 1960, J. W. McCrindle
- The Invasion of India by Alexander the Great, 1896, J. W. McCrindle
- The Gates of India, Sir Thomas H. Holdich
- Ancient Kamboja, People and the Country, 1981, Dr J. L. Kamboj
- The Geographical Data in Early Purana, 1972, Dr M. R. Singh
- Hindu Polity, Part I & II, 1978, Dr K. P. Jayswal
- Panjab Past and Present, Dr Buddha Parkash
- Journal of Bihar and Orissa Research Society, Vol XX
- Journal of Royal Asiatic Society, 1900
- History and Culture of Indian People, Age of Imperial Unity, Vol II, Dr A. D. Pusalkar, Dr R. C. Majumdar
- History of Panjab, Vol I, Dr Fauja Singh, Dr L. M. Joshi.
- The Kambojas Through the Ages, 2005, Kirpal Singh.
This entry is from Wikipedia, the leading user-contributed encyclopedia. It may not have been reviewed by professional editors (see full disclaimer)
