William Ashley Sunday (November 19 1862 –
November 6 1935) was an American athlete and religious figure who, after
being a popular outfielder in baseball's National
League during the 1880s, became the most celebrated and influential American evangelist during the first two decades of the 20th century.
Born into poverty, Sunday spent some years in an orphanage before taking a series of odd
jobs in several small Iowa towns as he demonstrated his prowess in amateur athletics. His
exceptional speed provided him the opportunity to play baseball in the major
leagues for eight years. He was known for his daring base-running and dramatic outfield play, but he was only an average
hitter.
Converted to evangelical Christianity in the
1880s, Sunday left baseball for the Christian ministry. He gradually developed his skills as a pulpit evangelist in the
Midwest and then, during the early 20th century, he became the nation's most
famous evangelist with his colloquial sermons and frenetic delivery.
Sunday held heavily reported campaigns in America's largest cities, made a great deal of money, and was welcomed into the
homes of the wealthy and influential. Perhaps more than a million people came forward at his invitations, and he may have
personally preached the gospel of Jesus Christ to more people than any other person in history up
to that time. Sunday was a strong supporter of Prohibition, and his
preaching almost certainly played a significant role in the adoption of the Eighteenth Amendment in 1919.
Despite questions about his income, no scandal ever touched Sunday. He was sincerely devoted to his wife, who also managed his
campaigns. But his three sons disappointed him, and his audiences grew smaller during the 1920s as Sunday grew older and
alternate sources of entertainment preoccupied his countrymen. Nevertheless, he continued to preach and remained a stalwart
bolster of conservative Christianity until his death.
Early life
Billy Sunday was born near Ames, Iowa. His father, William Sunday, was a Union soldier during the Civil War who had enlisted in the Iowa
Twenty-Third Volunteer Infantry and died of disease at Patterson, Missouri, five
weeks after the birth of his youngest son. When Sunday was ten years old, his impoverished mother was forced to send him and his
older brother to the Soldiers' Orphans Home in Glenwood, Iowa. At the orphanage, Sunday
gained orderly habits, a decent primary education, and the realization that he had exceptional athletic ability.[1]
By fourteen, Sunday was shifting for himself. In Nevada, Iowa, he worked for Colonel
John Scott, a former lieutenant governor, tending Shetland ponies and doing other farm
chores. The Scotts provided Sunday a loving home and the opportunity to attend Nevada High School, which had a fine local
reputation.[2] Although Sunday never received a high school
diploma, by 1880 he was better educated than the typical American of his day.[3]
In 1880, Sunday moved to Marshalltown, Iowa, where, because of his athleticism, he
had been recruited for a fire brigade team. In Marshalltown, Sunday worked at odd jobs, competed in fire brigade tournaments, and
played for the town baseball team. In 1882, with Sunday in left field, the Marshalltown
team defeated the state champion Des Moines team 13-4.[4]
Professional baseball player
Sunday's professional baseball career was launched by Adrian "Cap" Anson, a Marshalltown
native and future Hall of Famer, after his aunt, an avid fan
of the Marshalltown team, gave him an enthusiastic account of Sunday's prowess. In 1883, on Anson's recommendation,
A.G. Spalding, president of the Chicago White
Stockings, signed Sunday to the defending National League champions.[5]
Sunday struck out four times in his first game, and there were seven more strikeouts and
three more games before he got a hit. During his first four seasons with Chicago, he was
a part-time player, taking superstar Mike "King" Kelly's place in right field when Kelly served as catcher.[6]
Sunday's speed was his greatest asset, and he displayed it on the basepaths and in the outfield. In 1885, the White Stockings
arranged a race between Sunday and Arlie Latham, the fastest runner in the American Association. Sunday won the hundred-yard dash by ten feet.[7]
Sunday's personality, demeanor, and athleticism made him popular with the fans, as well as with his teammates. Manager Cap
Anson considered Sunday reliable enough to make him the team's business manager, which included such routine duties as making
travel arrangements and carrying thousands of dollars of team cash.[8]
In 1887, when Kelly was sold to another team, Sunday became Chicago's regular right fielder, but an injury limited his playing
time to fifty games. During the following winter Sunday was sold to the Pittsburgh
Alleghenies for the 1888 season. He was their starting center fielder, playing a
full season for the first time in his career. The crowds in Pittsburgh took to Sunday immediately; one reporter wrote that "the
whole town is wild over Sunday." One reason why Pittsburgh fans supported a losing team during the 1888 and 1889 seasons was that
Sunday performed well in center field as well as being among the league leaders in stolen
bases.[9]
In 1890, a labor dispute led to the formation of a new league, composed of most of the
better players from the National League. Although he was invited to join the competing league, Sunday's conscience would not
allow him to break his contract with Pittsburgh. Sunday was named team captain, and he was their star player, but the team
suffered one of the worst seasons in baseball history. By August the team had no money to meet its payroll, and Sunday was traded
to the Philadelphia Phillies for two players and $1,000 in cash.[10]
The Philadelphia team had an opportunity to win the National League pennant, and the owners hoped that adding Sunday to the
roster would improve their chances. Although Sunday played brilliantly in his thirty-one games with Philadelphia, the team
finished in third place.[11]
In March 1891, Sunday requested and was granted a release from his contract with the Philadelphia ball club. Over his career,
Sunday was never much of a hitter: his batting average was .248 over 499 games, about
the median for the 1880s. In his best season, in 1887, Sunday hit .291, ranking 17th in the league. He was an exciting but
inconsistent fielder. In the days before outfielders wore gloves, Sunday was noted for brilliant catches featuring long sprints
and athletic dives, but he also committed a great many errors. Sunday was best known as
an exceptionally fast runner, regarded by his peers as one of the best in the game, even though he never placed better than third
in the National League in stolen bases.[12]
Sunday remained a prominent baseball fan throughout his life. He gave interviews and opinions about baseball to the popular
press;[13] he frequently umpired minor league and amateur games in the cities where he held revivals; and he attended baseball
games whenever he could, including a 1935 World Series game two months before he
died.
Conversion
On a Sunday afternoon during either the 1886 or 1887 baseball season, Sunday and his teammates had drunk a few beers and were
wandering the streets of Chicago on their day off. At one corner they stopped to listen to a
street preaching team from the Pacific Garden Mission. Sunday was attracted to
the old gospel songs that he had heard his mother sing, and he began attending services at the mission. A former society matron
who worked there finally convinced Sunday that he must accept Christ, and after some struggle, he did so. The effect was
immediate. Sunday stopped drinking and began faithfully attending the fashionable Jefferson Park Presbyterian Church, a congregation handy to both the ball park and his rented room.[14]
Even before his conversion, Sunday's lifestyle seems to have been less boisterous than that of the average contemporary
baseball player. Nevertheless, after his conversion, his changed behavior was recognized by both teammates and fans. Sunday
shortly thereafter began speaking in churches and at YMCAs.[15]
Marriage
In 1886, Sunday was introduced at Jefferson Park Presbyterian Church to Helen Amelia
"Nell" Thompson, daughter of the owner of one of Chicago's largest dairy products businesses. Although Sunday was
immediately smitten with her, both had serious on-going relationships that bordered on engagements.[16] Furthermore, Miss Thompson had grown to maturity in a much more privileged
environment than had Sunday, and her father strongly discouraged the courtship, viewing all professional baseball players as
"transient ne'er-do-wells who were unstable and destined to be misfits once they were too old to play." Nevertheless, Sunday
pursued her with the same tenacity that he pursued baseball and the Gospel. On several occasions, Sunday said, "She was a
Presbyterian, so I am a Presbyterian. Had she been a Catholic, I would have been a
Catholic—because I was hot on the trail of Nell." Mrs. Thompson had liked Sunday from the start and weighed in on his side, and
Mr. Thompson finally relented. The couple was married on September 5 1888.[17]
Apprenticeship for evangelism
In the spring of 1891, Sunday turned down a $400 per month baseball contract in order to accept a position with the Chicago
YMCA at $83 per month. Sunday's job title at the YMCA was Assistant Secretary, but the position involved a great deal of
ministerial work. It proved to be good preparation for his later evangelistic career. For three years, Sunday visited the sick,
prayed with the troubled, counseled the suicidal, and visited saloons to invite patrons to evangelistic meetings.[18]
In 1893, Sunday became the full-time assistant to J. Wilbur Chapman, one of the
best known evangelists in the United States at the time. Chapman was well educated and was a meticulous dresser, suave and
urbane. Personally shy, like Sunday, Chapman commanded respect in the pulpit both because of his strong voice and his
sophisticated demeanor. Sunday's job as Chapman's advance man was to precede the evangelist to cities in which he was scheduled
to preach, organize prayer meetings and choirs, and in general take care of necessary details. When tents were used, Sunday would
often help erect them.
By listening to Chapman preach night after night, Sunday received a valuable course in homiletics. Chapman also critiqued Sunday's own attempts at evangelistic preaching and showed him how to put
a good sermon together. Further, Chapman encouraged Sunday's theological development, especially by emphasizing the importance of
prayer and by helping to "reinforce Billy's commitment to conservative biblical Christianity."[19]
Popular evangelist
Kerosene Circuit
When Chapman unexpectedly returned to the pastorate in 1896, Sunday struck out on his own, beginning with meetings in tiny
Garner, Iowa. For the next twelve years Sunday preached in approximately seventy
communities, most of them in Iowa and Illinois. Sunday referred to these towns as the “Kerosene
Circuit” because, unlike Chicago, most were not yet electrified. Towns often booked Sunday meetings informally, sometimes by
sending a delegation to hear him preach and then telegraphing him while he was holding services somewhere else.
Sunday also took advantage of his reputation as a baseball player to generate advertising for his meetings. In 1907 in
Fairfield, Iowa, Sunday organized local businesses into two baseball teams and scheduled
a game between them. Sunday came dressed in his professional uniform and played on both sides. Although baseball was his primary
means of publicity, Sunday also once hired a circus giant to serve as an usher.[20]
When Sunday began to attract crowds larger than could be accommodated in rural churches or town halls, he pitched rented
canvas tents. Again, Sunday did much of the physical work of putting them up, manipulating ropes during storms, and seeing to
their security by sleeping in them at night. Not until 1905 was he well enough off to hire his own advance man.[21]
In 1906, an October snowstorm in Salida, Colorado, destroyed Sunday's tent—a special
disaster because revivalists were typically paid with a freewill offering at the end of their
meetings. Thereafter he insisted that towns build him temporary wooden tabernacles at their expense. The tabernacles were
comparatively costly to build (although most of the lumber could be salvaged and resold at the end of the meetings), and
obviously, locals had to put up the money for them in advance. This change in Sunday's operation began to push the finances of
the campaign to the fore. At least at first, raising tabernacles provided good public relations for the coming meetings as
townspeople joined together in what was effectively a giant barnraising. Sunday built rapport by participating in the process,
and the tabernacles were also a status symbol, because they had previously been built only for major evangelists such as
Chapman.[22]
Under the administration of Nell
Eleven years into Sunday's evangelistic career, both he and his wife had been pushed to their emotional limits. Long
separations had exacerbated his natural feelings of inadequacy and insecurity. As a product of a childhood that could well be
described as a series of losses, he was extremely dependent on his wife's love and encouragement. Nell Sunday, for her part,
found it increasingly difficult to handle household responsibilities, the needs of four children (including a newborn), and the
long-distance emotional welfare of her husband. His ministry was also expanding, and he needed an administrator, a job for which
his wife was ideally suited. In 1908, the Sundays decided to entrust their children to a nanny so that Nell Sunday could manage
the revival campaigns.[23]
Mrs. Sunday transformed her husband's out-of-the-back-pocket organization into a “nationally renowned phenomenon.” New
personnel were hired, and by the New York campaign of 1917, the Sundays had a paid staff of
twenty-six. There were musicians, custodians, and advance men, of course; but the Sundays also hired Bible teachers of both
sexes, who among other responsibilities, held daytime meetings at schools and shops and encouraged their audiences to attend the
main tabernacle services in the evenings. The most significant of these new staff members were Homer Rodeheaver, an exceptional song leader and music director who worked with the Sundays for almost
twenty years, and Virginia Healey Asher, who (besides regularly singing duets with
Rodeheaver) directed the women's ministries, especially the evangelization of young working women.[24]
Campaign platform
With his wife administering the campaign organization, Sunday was free to do what he did best: compose and deliver colloquial
sermons. Typically, Homer Rodeheaver would first warm up the crowd with congregational singing that alternated with both numbers
from gigantic choirs and music performed by the staff. When Sunday felt the moment right, he would launch into his message.
Sunday gyrated, stood on the pulpit, ran from one end of the platform to the other, and dove across the stage, pretending to
slide into home plate. Sometimes he even smashed chairs to emphasize his points. His sermon notes had to be printed in large
letters so that he could catch a glimpse of them as he raced by the pulpit. In messages attacking sexual sin to groups of men
only, Sunday could be graphic for the era.[25] Some
religious and social leaders criticized Sunday's exaggerated gestures as well as the slang and colloquialisms that filled his
sermons, but audiences clearly enjoyed them.[26]
In 1907, journalist Lindsay Denison complained that Sunday preached “the old, old doctrine of damnation,” getting results by
"inspiring fear and gloom in the hearts of sinners.”[27]
But Sunday himself told reporters "with ill-concealed annoyance," that his revivals had "no emotionalism." Certainly contemporary
comparisons to the extravagances of mid-nineteenth-century camp meetings—as in the famous drawing by George Bellows—were overdrawn.[28] Sunday told one reporter that he believed that people could "be converted without any
fuss,"[29] and, at Sunday's meetings, "instances of
spasm, shakes, or fainting fits caused by hysteria were few and far between."[30]
Crowd noise, especially coughing and crying babies, was a significant impediment to Sunday's preaching because the wooden
tabernacles were so acoustically live. During his preliminaries, Rodeheaver often instructed audiences about how to muffle their
coughs. Nurseries were always provided, infants forbidden, and Sunday sometimes appeared rude in his haste to rid the hall of
noisy children who had slipped through the ushers. Tabernacle floors were covered with sawdust to dampen the noise of shuffling
feet (as well as for its pleasant smell and its ability to hold down the dust of dirt floors), and coming forward during the
invitation became known as “hitting the sawdust trail.”[31]
By 1910, Sunday began to conduct meetings (usually longer than a month) in small cities like Youngstown, Wilkes-Barre, South Bend, and Denver, and then finally, between 1915 and
1917, the major cities of Philadelphia, Syracuse, Kansas City, Detroit, Boston, Buffalo, and New York City. During the 1910s, Sunday was front
page news in the cities where he held campaigns. Newspapers often printed his sermons in full, and during World War I, local
coverage of his campaigns often surpassed that of the war. Sunday was the subject of over sixty articles in major periodicals,
and he was a staple of the religious press regardless of denomination.[32]
Over the course of his career, Sunday probably preached to more than one hundred million people face-to-face—and, to the great
majority, without electronic amplification. The vast numbers who "hit the sawdust trail" are also remarkable. Although the usual
total given for those who came forward at invitations is an even million, one modern historian estimates the true figure to be
closer to 1,250,000.[33] Of course Sunday did not preach
to hundred million different individuals but to many of the same people repeatedly during the course of a campaign. Before his
death, Sunday estimated that he had preached nearly 20,000 sermons, an average of 42 per month from 1896 to 1935. During his
heyday, when he was preaching more than twenty times each week, his crowds were often huge. Even in 1923, well into the period of
his decline, 479,300 people attended the 79 meetings of the six-week 1923 Columbia,
South Carolina, campaign. That number was 23 times the white population of Columbia. Nevertheless,"trail hitters" were not
necessarily conversions (or even "reconsecrations") to Christianity. Sometimes whole groups of club members came forward en masse
at Sunday's prodding. Undoubtedly some audience members simply wanted to shake Sunday's hand. By 1927, Rodeheaver was complaining
that Sunday's invitations had become so general that they were meaningless.[34]
Wages of success
Large crowds and an efficient organization meant that Sunday, the former resident of an orphan home, was soon netting hefty
offerings. The first questions about Sunday's income were apparently raised during the Columbus,
Ohio, campaign at the turn of 1912-13. During the Pittsburgh campaign a year later, Sunday spoke four times per day and
effectively made $217 per sermon or $870 a day at a time when the average gainfully employed worker made $836 per year.
The major cities of Chicago, Philadelphia, Baltimore, Boston, and New York City gave
Sunday even larger love offerings. Sunday donated Chicago's offering of $58,000 to Pacific Garden Mission and the $120,500 New
York offering to war charities. Nevertheless, between 1908 and 1920, the Sundays earned over a million dollars; an average worker
during the same period earned less than $14,000.[35]
Sunday was welcomed into the circle of the social, economic, and political elite. He counted among his neighbors and
acquaintances several prominent businessmen. Sunday dined with numerous politicians, including Presidents Theodore Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson, and counted both
Herbert Hoover and John D. Rockefeller,
Jr. as friends.[36] During and after the 1917
Los Angeles campaign, the Sundays visited with Hollywood stars, and members of Sunday's organization played a charity baseball game
against a team of show business personalities that included Douglas Fairbanks.[37]
The Sundays enjoyed dressing well and dressing their children well; the family sported expensive but tasteful coats, boots,
and jewelry. Mrs. Sunday also bought land as an investment. A fruit orchard farm and rustic cabin at Hood River, Oregon, caught the attention of reporters, who called it a "ranch." Sunday was a soft
touch with money and gave away much of his earnings.[38]
Neither of the Sundays were extravagant spenders. Although Sunday enjoyed driving, the couple never owned a car. Their
American Craftsman-style bungalow at Winona
Lake, Indiana, where the Sundays had moved their legal residence in 1911, was furnished in the popular Arts and Crafts style and had two safes, but the house had only nine rooms, 2,500-square-feet
of living space, and no garage.[39]
Religious views
Billy Sunday was a conservative evangelical who accepted fundamentalist doctrines. He affirmed and preached the inerrancy of the Bible, the virgin birth of Christ,
the doctrine of substitutionary atonement, the bodily resurrection of Jesus, a literal devil and
hell, and the imminent return of Jesus Christ. At the turn
of the 20th century, most Protestant church members, regardless of denomination, gave
assent to these doctrines (except, perhaps, for the imminent return of Christ). Sunday refused to hold meetings in cities where
he was not welcomed by the vast majority of the Protestant churches and their clergy. (Dissenting clergymen found it politic to
limit their objections to Sunday's theology while he was adding new members to their congregations.)[40]
Nevertheless, Sunday was not a separationist as were most orthodox Protestants of his era. He went out of his way to avoid
criticizing the Roman Catholic Church and even met with Cardinal Gibbons during his 1916
Baltimore campaign. Also, cards filled out by "trail hitters" were faithfully returned to the church or denomination that the
writers had indicated as their choice—including Catholic and Unitarian.[41]
Although Sunday was ordained by the Presbyterian Church in 1903, his
ministry was nondenominational, and he was not a strict Calvinist. He preached that
individuals were, at least in part, responsible for their own salvation. “Trail hitters” were
given a four-page tract that stated, “if you have done your part (i.e. believe that Christ died in your place, and receive
Him as your Saviour and Master) God has done HIS part and imparted to you His own nature.”[42]
Sunday was neither a theologian nor an intellectual, but he had a thorough knowledge of the Bible, and he was well read on
religious and social issues of his day. His surviving Winona Lake library of six hundred books gives evidence of heavy use,
including underscoring and reader's notes in his characteristic all-caps printing. Some of Sunday's books were even those of
religious opponents. In fact, he was later charged, probably correctly, with plagiarizing a
Decoration Day speech given by the noted agnostic Robert Ingersoll.[43]
Social and political views
Sunday was a lifelong Republican, and he espoused the mainstream
political and social views of his native Midwest: individualism, competitiveness, personal discipline, and opposition to
government regulation.[44] Writers such as
Upton Sinclair[45] and John Reed attacked Sunday as a tool of big
business, and poet Carl Sandburg also crudely accused him of being a money-grubbing
charlatan.[46] Nevertheless, Sunday sided with
Progressives on some issues. For example, he denounced child labor[47] and supported urban
reform and women's suffrage.[48] Sunday condemned capitalists "whose private lives are good, but whose public lives are very bad,"
as well as those "who would not pick the pockets of one man with the fingers of their hand" but who would "without hesitation
pick the pockets of eighty million people with fingers of their monopoly or commercial advantage."[49] He never lost his sympathy for the poor, and he sincerely tried to bridge the
gulf between the races during the nadir of the Jim Crow era,[50] although on at least two occasions in the mid-1920s Sunday received
contributions from the Ku Klux Klan.[51]
Sunday was a passionate supporter of World War I. In 1918 he said, "I tell you it is [Kaiser] Bill against Woodrow, Germany
against America, Hell against Heaven." Sunday raised large amounts of money for the troops, sold war bonds, and stumped for
recruitment.[52]
Sunday had been an ardent champion of temperance from his earliest days as an
evangelist, and his ministry at the Chicago YMCA had given him first-hand experience with the destructive potential of alcohol.
Sunday's most famous sermon was "Get on the Water Wagon," which he preached on countless occasions with both histrionic emotion
and a "mountain of economic and moral evidence." Sunday said, "I am the sworn, eternal and uncompromising enemy of the Liquor
Traffic. I have been, and will go on, fighting that damnable, dirty, rotten business with all the power at my command."[53] Sunday played a significant role in arousing public interest
in Prohibition and in the passage of the Eighteenth Amendment in 1919. When the
tide of public opinion turned against Prohibition, he continued to support it. After its repeal in 1933, Sunday called for its
reintroduction.[54]
Sunday also opposed eugenics, recent immigration from southern and eastern Europe,[55] and the teaching of evolution.[56] Further, he criticized such popular middle-class amusements as dancing,[57] playing cards, attending the theater, and reading novels.[58] However, he believed baseball was a healthy and even patriotic form of
recreation, so long as it was not played on Sundays.[59]
Decline
Sunday's popularity waned after World War I when radio and movie theaters became his competitors for the public's leisure
time. The Sundays' health also declined even as they continued to drive themselves through rounds of revivals—smaller of course,
but also with ever fewer staff members to assist them.[60]
Worse, the Sundays were disgraced by the behavior of their three sons who engaged in all the activities Billy preached
against. In the end, the Sundays were effectively forced to pay blackmail to several women to
keep the scandals relatively quiet.[61] In 1930, their
housekeeper and nanny, who had become a virtual member of the family, died. Then Sunday's daughter, the only child actually
raised by Nell, died in 1932 of what seems to have been multiple sclerosis. Rescued
from financial ruin by the Sundays, their oldest son George committed suicide in 1933.[62]
Nevertheless, even as the crowds declined during the last fifteen years of his life, Sunday soldiered on, accepting preaching
invitations and speaking with effect. In early 1935, he had a mild heart attack, and his doctor advised him to stay out of the
pulpit. Sunday ignored the advice. He died on November 6, a week after preaching his last
sermon on the text "What must I do to be saved?"[63]
Notes
- ^ Dorsett, 8-10, 13.
- ^ The 4-H baseball field in Nevada is named
Billy Sunday Field.
- ^ Dorsett, 14; Bruns, 29.
- ^ Dorsett, 15; Knickerbocker, 26-7.
- ^ Anson's aunt, Emily Haviland attended Marshalltown games with her husband
Marshall, who was the official team scorer in 1871. In 1916, Anson recalled that
his aunt "finally induced me to give Billy a chance in Chicago. She was what you call a dyed-in-the-wool fan and never missed a
game the Marshalltown club ever played." In 1921, Sunday told veteran writer William Phelon Jr., "It was owing to the fact that
Capt. Anson of the Chicago team had an aunt in Marshalltown that I became a big leaguer." Cap "had Aunt Emma there and she was
greatly interested in seeing me progress in baseball. She praised my playing to Anson, told him I was about the fastest fielder
on earth and insisted that he give me a chance with Chicago and he agreed." Rosenberg, 132.
- ^ Cap Anson, Sunday's manager, said in his 1900 autbiography that Sunday
struck out his first thirteen times at bat. However, contemporary newspaper accounts report eleven strikeouts at most, with two
of his other at-bats reported simply as outs, probably not made by striking out. Sunday's verifiable strikeouts-in-a-row are
four. Knickerbocker, 31-32.
- ^ Interestingly, even before his conversion, Sunday was uncomfortable with
this race and tried to withdraw. He was persuaded to run because a great deal of money had been bet on the outcome, some of it
put up by his teammates. In later years he regretted having been involved in a gambling event. Knickerbocker, 45-47;
Firstenberger, 18.
- ^ Sunday later said, "That was my first experience at bookkeeping and I was
never shy a dollar." Bruns, 39-40; Knickerbocker, 37.
- ^ Knickerbocker, 73-75, 97, 109, 120; Bruns, 51; Dorsett, 36-39.
- ^ Knickerbocker, 125-131.
- ^ Knickerbocker,131-133; Bruns, 51; Dorsett, 36-39.
- ^ Fans reportedly said, "Billy is fast enough, but he can't steal first
base." Knickerbocker, 135-137, 2-3.
- ^ For example, in 1917 Baseball Magazine published his opinions on
baseball's patriotic value and the game's importance to the nation in wartime.
- ^ Knickerbocker, 80-89; Dorsett, 24-28. Sunday could never remember the
date of this experience, although he made repeated reference to it. The oft-told conversion story poses a number of chronological
difficulties. The best explication of the problems and their partial solutions is Knickerbocker, 59-63, 79-89.
- ^ Dorsett, 29.
- ^ Firstenberger, 7.
- ^ Dorsett, 32-34; Frankenberg, 62; Martin, 34. Some of the difficulty about
remembering the exact date of Sunday's conversion may have been the result of Nell and Billy having met and fallen in love before
Billy had become a Christian, a circumstance that might later have been embarrassing because evangelicals would have condemned
such a courtship.
- ^ Dorsett, 39-43, 48. Sunday's father-in-law became unhappy that Sunday had
exchanged the promise of $3,500 for seven weeks of work for a six-day-a-week job that paid $1,000 per year.
- ^ Dorsett, 49-57.
- ^ Knickerbocker, 145-146; McLaughlin, 11. One newspaper reporting on the
Garner revival "to be conducted by W.A. Sunday" noted that "this must be 'Billy' Sunday who used to play ball for Anson with the
Chicago White Stockings. 'Billy' is as true a Christian gentleman as he was a rattling ball player, and that is saying a good
deal."
- ^ Dorsett, 61-64.
- ^ Dorsett, 64-65; Firstenberger, 46.
- ^ Dorsett, 81-84; Firstenberger, 45, 98-100. In 1911, Nell Sunday met Nora
Lynn at the Erie, Pennsylvania campaign and persuaded her to become the Sundays' live-in housekeeper. Lynn was employed by the
Sundays for twenty years; she effectively became a member of the Sunday family and died in their house.
- ^ Dorsett, 86, 100-104; Firstenberger, 124-126. Firstenberger has
documented more than seventy individuals who were members of the Sunday evangelistic team through the years of Billy Sunday's
ministry. Virginia Asher and her husband William had known the Sundays since the 1890s and had previously worked for
Dwight L. Moody and other evangelists. Both were friends of J. Wilbur Chapman, and both
had cottages at Winona Lake, Indiana. Asher organized permanent, post-campaign "Virginia Asher Councils" to continue work among
those who, during that period, were called "businesswomen."
- ^ A theological opponent, Universalist minister Frederick William Betts,
wrote, "Many of the things said and done bordered upon things prohibited in decent society. The sermon on amusements was preached
three times, to mixed audience of men and women, boys and girls. If the sermons to women had been preached to married women, if
the sermons to men had been preached to mature men, if the sermon on amusements had been preached to grown folks, there might
have been an excuse for them, and perhaps good from them. But an experienced newspaper reported told me that the sermon on
amusements was "the rawest thing ever put over in Syracuse." I can not, must not, quote from this sermon...Betts, Frederick William (1916). Billy Sunday, the Man and Method. Murray
Press.
p. 30, "rawest
thing;" p. 43, "fainted under that awful definition;" p. 36, "if you do not 'hit the trail' then watch out for the fireworks")...[a friend] says that Mr. Sunday's sermon
on the sex question was raw and disgusting. He also heard the famous sermons on amusements and booze. [He] says that all in all
they were the ugliest, nastiest, most disgusting addresses he ever listened to from a religious platform or a preacher of
religion. He saw people carried out who had fainted under that awful definition of sensuality and depravity. Homer Rodeheaver
said that "One of these sermons, until he tempered it down a little, had one ten-minute period in it where from two to twelve men
fainted and had to be carried out every time I heard him preach it."Martin, Robert
Francis (2002). Hero of the Heartland: Billy Sunday and the Transformation of American Society, 1862-1935. Indiana
University Press. ISBN 0253341299. ,
p. 87
- ^ Firstenberger, 36-39. Fundamentalist leader Bob Jones, Jr., who knew Sunday as a teenager, admitted in his memoirs that he was "repelled by the
roughness" of Sunday's performance and noted that Sunday's messages seemed "studied and stage-managed"—which of course, they
were. Bob Jones [Jr.], Cornbread and Caviar: Reminiscences and Reflections (Greenville, SC: Bob Jones University Press,
1985), 89.
- ^ "In spite of his conviction that the truly religious man should take his
religion joyfully, he gets his results by inspiring fear and gloom in the hearts of sinners. The fear of death, with torment
beyond it—intensified by examples of the frightful deathbeds of those who have carelessly or obdurately put off salvation until
it is too late—it is with this mighty menace that he drives sinners into the fold. name=denison>Denison, Lindsay (1907), "The
Rev. Billy Sunday and His War On the Devil," The American Magazine, September, 1907, 64(5), p.
461
- ^ McLoughlin, 127.
- ^ Rocky Mountain News, September 7, 1914, 1, in McLoughlin,
128.
- ^ McLoughlin, 128.
- ^ Firstenberger, 37; McLoughlin, 97; Dorsett, 91-92. The term was first
used in a Sunday campaign in Bellingham, Washington, in 1910. Apparently,
"hitting the sawdust trail" had first been used by loggers in the Pacific Northwest to describe following home a trail of
previously dropped sawdust through an uncut forest—a metaphor for coming from, in Nell Sunday's words, "a lost condition to a
saved condition."
- ^ Dorsett, 92-93. "Scores of newborn boys were named 'Billy Sunday' in his
honor, and in Fulton County, Illinois, a recipe for 'Billy Sunday Pudding' was
formulated by local residents. The puddingwas designed to bake in the oven during his sermon and be ready when the family came
home from the meeting." Firstenberger, 39.
- ^ Dorsett, 93; Firstenberger, 39, 120-123; Lyle W. Dorsett, "Billy Sunday,"
American National Biography, 21: 150-52; Bernard A. Weisberger, They Gathered at the River: The Story of the Great
Revivalists and Their Impact upon Religion in America (Boston: Little, Brown and Company, 1958), 254.
- ^ Dorsett, 136.
- ^ Dorsett, 90-91.
- ^ Dorsett, 93-94, 134, 149-50.
- ^ Dorsett, 93, 95; Knickerbocker, 156. The movie stars won, 1-0, and Sunday
jokingly complained that his team could not get a break from the umpires, Mary Pickford
and Charlie Chaplin.
- ^ In 1913, Sunday's mentor, J. Wilbur Chapman, wrote that he could not
think of a time that Sunday had "had opportunity for conversation" that he had not asked, "Do you need any money?" Frankenburg,
"Forward."
- ^ Dorsett,95-96; Firstenberger, 80-92. In her will, Nell Sunday donated the
house and its collection of artifacts as a museum.
- ^ Firstenberger, 26-29. Although preached in colloquialisms, Sunday's
theology was fairly sophisticated and "orthodox in its basic ingredients." See Daniel LaRoy Anderson, "The Gospel According to
Sunday," Th.D. dissertation, Dallas Theological Seminary, 199.
- ^ Dorsett, 80-81; Firstenberger, 30. A short but striking first-person
account of Sunday's 1915 Syracuse campaign by a Universalist clergyman is Frederick W. Betts, Billy Sunday: The Man and the
Method (Boston: Murray Press, 1916.) Betts was clearly disgusted by Sunday but awestruck by the power of his personality and
sermons over even his educated acquaintances.
- ^ Weisberger, 253.
- ^ Dorsett, 77; Firstenberger, 32, 63. Sunday's library included a copy of
Thomas W. Hanford, Ingersollia: Gems of Thought from the Lectures, Speeches and Conversations of the Late Col. Robert G.
Ingersoll(1899) with underlined text and marginal notes.
- ^ Martin, 126-127.
- ^ Sinclair Lewis' novel
Babbitt includes a character named Mike Monday, "the distinguished evangelist, the best-known
Protestant pontiff in America...As a prize-fighter he gained nothing but his crooked nose, his celebrated vocabulary, and his
stage-presence. The service of the Lord had been more profitable." In his novel, a visit by Monday is opposed by "certain
Episcopalian and Congregationalist ministers," whom Monday calls "a bunch of gospel-pushers with dish-water instead of blood, a
gang of squealers that need more dust on the knees of their pants and more hair on their skinny old chests." Lewis's
Elmer Gantry is a novel about an evangelist with more than a passing resemblance to Sunday.
(Sunday in turn referred to Lewis as a member of "Satan's cohort.")Elmer Gantry study guide,
bookrags.com.
- ^ McLoughlin, 223. John Reed, "Back of Sunday," Metropolitan
Magazine (May 1915), 10. Carl Sandburg, "To Billy Sunday", 1915. Sandburg wrote, "You come along squirting words at us, shaking your fist and calling us all
dam fools so fierce the froth slobbers over your lips...always blabbing we’re all going to hell straight off and you know all
about it...Go ahead and bust all the chairs you want to. Smash a whole wagon load of furniture at every performance. Turn sixty
somersaults and stand on your nutty head. If it wasn’t for the way you scare the women and kids I’d feel sorry for you and pass
the hat. I like to watch a good four-flusher work, but not when he starts people puking and calling for the doctors." Sunday also
appears in some modern fiction, both as an historical touchstone and as a metaphorical figure. For example, John Jakes inserts a mention of Sunday in Homeland, his historical novel about Chicago; and Sunday's life is employed metaphorically in
Rod Jones' novel Billy Sunday.
- ^ "Men who will gladly draw their check for $10,000 and give it a child's
hospital see nothing ridiculous in the fact that the $10,000 for the child's hospital came of out of $200,000 made from a system
of child labor which crushes more children in one year than the hospital will heal in ten." Quoted in McLoughlin, 145.
- ^ Firstenberger, 66-68; McLoughlin, 140-143.
- ^ Quoted in McLoughlin, 144-45.
- ^ Dorsett, 96-97, 152-154.
- ^ Firstenberger, 29-30. Sunday apparently never either praised the Klan nor
denounced it (McLoughlin, 274-275). According to Larson, Sunday's Memphis campaign of
February 1925 featured both a special night for African Americans and an "unofficial Klan night." (Larson 1997, p. 55).
- ^ McLoughlin, 257-259; Firstenberger, 60-62; Dorsett, 113-114.
- ^ Dorsett, 112-113; Firstenberger, 69; McLaughlin, 180-184. Sunday preached
that "whiskey and beer are all right in their place, but their place is in hell."(Compare Christianity and alcohol.)
- ^ McLoughlin, 232-234; Firstenberger, 72. During Prohibition, Sunday's
revival theme song, "Brighten the Corner Where You Are," is said to have become a drinking song in the blind pigs. A line in the popular Frank Sinatra song "Chicago," written by Fred Fisher in the 1920s, refers
to Chicago as "the town that Billy Sunday couldn't shut down."
- ^ McLoughlin, 146-48.
- ^ Although Sunday was a firm creationist, he believed that the seven days
of creation were indeterminate periods and not literal 24-hour days. As proof Sunday quoted 2 Peter 3:8 that "one day is with the
Lord as a thousand years, and a thousand years as one day." "Nuts for Skeptics to Crack," (sermon) May 24, 1917, Papers of
William and Helen Sunday, Reel 11. William Jennings Bryan asked Sunday to
participate in the Scopes Trial. Although Sunday assured Bryan that "all the believing
world is back of you in your defense of Christ and the Bible," Sunday declined to come to Dayton. Sunday to Bryan, July 4, 1925, William Jennings Bryan Papers, Library of Congress, Box
47.
- ^ "Sunday said that "three-fourths of all the fallen women fell as a result
of the dance" Quoted in McLoughlin, 132.
- ^ McLoughlin, 132-135; Firstenberger, 65-66.
- ^ Knickerbocker, 156-157.
- ^ Dorsett, 148."Sabbath church attendance was not greatly affected by the
rapid rise of the entertainment industry, but revivals conducted in big tents and tabernacles night after night for several weeks
running were definitely undercut when the public found new competitors for their time."
- ^ Dorsett, 129. In a 1929 letter to his wife, Sunday wrote that "all we
have earned in the last 5 years has gone to Millie," Billy, Jr.'s ex-wife. BS to HTS, Box 4, Folder 32, The Papers of William
and Helen Sunday [microfilm] (Wheaton, Illinois: Billy Graham Center, 1978).
- ^ All three of Sunday's sons died violently: George from a "fall" from a
hotel window; Billy, Jr. in an automobile crash after a night of partying; and Paul in an airplane crash. Although Sunday's four
children contracted nine marriages, Billy and Nell Sunday had only three grandchildren. The grandchildren, in turn, contracted
five marriages that resulted in only one great-grandchild, who apparently died childless. The great-grandchild, Marquis Ashley
Sunday, was killed by his lover in San Francisco on March 22 1982. Therefore, fifty years after his death, Sunday had no known living
descendants. Dorsett, 126-130. Firstenberger, 136-137, gives the genealogical details.
- ^ Dorsett, 141-143.
References
- Anderson, Daniel LaRoy. "The Gospel According to Sunday," Th.D. dissertation, Dallas Theological Seminary, 1979.
- Bruns, Roger. Preacher: Billy Sunday
and Big-Time American Evangelism. New York: W.W. Norton, 1992.
- Dorsett, Lyle W. Billy Sunday and the
Redemption of Urban America. Grand Rapids, MI: W.B. Eerdmans, 1991.
- Ellis, William T. Billy Sunday: His Life and Message. Philadelphia, PA: John C. Winston Co., 1914.
- Firstenberger, William A. In Rare
Form: A Pictorial History of Baseball Evangelist Billy Sunday. Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 2005.
- Frankenberg, Theodore Thomas. Billy Sunday: His Tabernacles and Sawdust Trails. Columbus, Ohio: F.J. Heer Printing
Company, 1917.
- Knickerbocker, Wendy. Sunday at the Ballpark: Billy Sunday's Professional Baseball Career 1883-1890. Lanham,
MD: Scarecrow Press, 2000.
- Larson, Edward J. (1997), Summer for the Gods: The Scopes Trial and America's Continuing Debate over Science and Religion,
BasicBooks a subsidiary of Perseus Books, ISBN 0-679-64288-9 0-465-07509-6
- Larson, Edward J. (2004), Evolution, Modern
Library, ISBN 0-679-64288-9
- Martin, Robert F. Hero of the
Heartland: Billy Sunday and the Transformation of American Society, 1862-1935. Bloomington: Indiana University Press,
2002.
- McLoughlin, William G. Billy Sunday Was His Real Name. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1955.
- Nevada Community Historical Society Inc. (2003). Voices from the Past: The Story of Nevada, Iowa, Its Community and
Families. Unknown press (Nevada Community Historical Society, Inc., PO Box 213, Nevada, Iowa 50201-0213; 515-382-6684)
- Rosenberg, Howard W. Cap Anson
4: Bigger Than Babe Ruth: Captain Anson of Chicago. Arlington, Va.: Tile Books, 2006.
- Sunday, Billy. The Sawdust Trail:
Billy Sunday in His Own Words. Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 2005.
External links
This entry is from Wikipedia, the leading user-contributed encyclopedia. It may not have been reviewed by professional editors (see full disclaimer)