Emil Brunner

This article does not cite any references or sources. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. (November 2006)

Heinrich Emil Brunner (December 23, 1889 – April 6, 1966) was a Swiss Protestant (Reformed) theologian. Along with Karl Barth (see Relationship with Karl Barth), he is commonly associated with neo-orthodoxy or the dialectical theology movement.

Biography

Emil Brunner was born in Winterthur, near Zurich, Switzerland.

He studied at the universities of Zurich and Berlin, receiving his doctorate in theology from Zurich in 1913, with a dissertation on The Symbolic Element in Religious Knowledge. Brunner served as pastor from 1916 to 1924 in the mountain village of Obstalden in the Swiss Canton of Glarus. In 1919–1920 he spent a year in the United States studying at Union Theological Seminary in New York.

In 1921 Brunner published his Habilitationsschrift (a post-doctoral dissertation traditionally required in many countries in order to attain the position of a fully tenured professor) on Experience, Knowledge and Faith and in 1922 was appointed a Privatdozent at the University of Zurich. Soon after, another book followed: Mysticism and the Word (1924), which was a devastating critique of the liberal theology of Friedrich Schleiermacher. Brunner was rewarded for his literary efforts with his appointment in 1924 as Professor of Systematic and Practical Theology at the University of Zurich, a post which he held until his retirement in 1953. Following this appointment Brunner's reputation as a theologian continued to increase, particularly after the publication of two further important works in 1927, the first being The Philosophy of Religion from the Standpoint of Protestant Theology and second The Mediator.

After accepting various invitations to deliver lectures across Europe and the United States, in 1930 Brunner published God and Man and in 1932 The Divine Imperative. Brunner continued his theological output with Man in Revolt and Truth as Encounter in 1937. In the same year he was a substantial contributor to the World Conference on Church, Community, and State in Oxford, a position which was reflected in his continued involvement in the ecumenical movement. In 1937–1938 he returned to the United States for a year as a visiting professor at Princeton Theological Seminary.

Brunner's ecclesiastical positions varied at differing points in his career. Much like Barth, he rejected infant baptism entirely, but later changed his mind. He claimed to have found the real church in the Oxford Group Movement, until Frank Buchman allowed it to lose its Christological basis, at which time Brunner withdrew. He gave much time to the Y.M.C.A. and, at John R. Mott's invitation, became its theological adviser. Traveling to Japan, he rejoiced to find his ecclesiological thesis virtually incarnated (which means the church dis-incarnated) in the Mukyokai, or No-Church Movement of Christians. Before the outbreak of the war Brunner returned to Europe with the young Scottish theologian Thomas Torrance who had studied under Karl Barth in Basel and who had been teaching at Auburn Theological Seminary, New York (and who would subsequently go on to distinguish himself as a professor at the University of Edinburgh). Following the war, Brunner delivered the prestigious Gifford Lectures at the University of St Andrews, Scotland in 1946–1947 on Christianity and Civilisation. In 1953 he retired from his post at the University of Zurich and took up a position of Visiting Professor at the recently founded International Christian University in Tokyo, Japan (1953–1955) , but not before the publication of the first two volumes of his three volume magnum opus Dogmatics (volume one: The Christian Doctrine of God (1946), volume two: The Christian Doctrine of Creation and Redemption (1950), and volume three: The Christian Doctrine of the Church, Faith, and Consummation (1960)). While returning to Europe from Japan, Brunner suffered a cerebral haemorrhage and was physically impaired, weakening his ability to work. Though there were times when his condition would improve, he suffered further strokes, finally succumbing to death in 1966.

Brunner undoubtedly holds a place of prominence in Protestant theology in the 20th century and was one of the four or five leading systematicians.

Theology

Brunner rejected liberal theology's (in particular European liberal theology's) portrait of Jesus as merely a highly-respected human being. Instead, Brunner insisted that Jesus was God incarnate and central to salvation.

Some observers claim that Brunner also attempted to find a middle position within the ongoing Arminian and Calvinist debate, stating that Christ stood between God's sovereign approach to humankind and free human acceptance of God's gift of salvation. However, Brunner was a Protestant theologian from German-speaking Europe (a heritage which did not lay nearly as much weight on the Calvinist-Arminian controversy as Dutch- or English-speaking theology). Thus, it may be more accurate to describe his viewpoint as a melding together of Lutheran and Reformed perspectives of soteriology; the Lutheran accent in particular was dominant in Brunner's affirmation of single predestination over against both the double predestination of Calvin and the liberal insistence on universal salvation, a view he charged Barth with holding.

In any event, Brunner and his compatriots in the neo-orthodox movement rejected in toto Pelagian concepts of human cooperation with God in the act of salvation, which were prominent in other humanist conceptions of Christianity in the late 19th century. Instead, they embraced Augustine's views, especially as refracted through Martin Luther.

Although Brunner re-emphasized the centrality of Christ, evangelical and fundamentalist theologians, mainly those from America and Great Britain, have usually rejected Brunner's other teachings, including his dismissal of certain "miraculous" elements within the Scriptures and his questioning of the usefulness of the doctrine of the inspiration of the Bible. This is in accord with the treatment that conservatives have afforded others in the movement such as Barth and Paul Tillich; most conservatives have viewed neo-orthodox theology as simply a more moderate form of liberalism, rejecting its claims as a legitimate expression of the Protestant tradition.

Relationship with Karl Barth

Brunner and Barth, though friends and colleagues, had a tendentious and rocky relationship differing sometimes dramatically in their theological views. Barth once described their relationship as similar to that of a whale and an elephant. Long before Barth's name was known in the U.S., Brunner was considered to be the chief proponent of the new theology, at least in America (from the 1930s to early 1950s) since his books were translated into English much sooner than Barth's. Considered by many to be the minor partner in the uneasy relationship, Brunner once acknowledged that the only theological genius of the 20th century was Barth.

Selected Works by Brunner (in English)

• The Divine Imperative (1st German edition 1932; English translation 1937) - link to 2002 Ed.
• Man in Revolt. A Christian Anthropology (1st German edition 1937; English translation 1939)
• Dogmatics (German: 1946, 1950 and 1960; English translation 1949, 1952 and 1962) - link to 2003 Ed.
• Revelation and Reason. The Christian Doctrine of Faith and Knowledge, (1st German edition 1941, English translation 1946)
• Christianity and Civilisation (1949)
• Dogmatics. Volume I: The Christian Doctrine of God, James Clarke & Co, Cambridge 2003
• Dogmatics. Volume II: The Christian Doctrine of Creation and Redemption, James Clarke & Co, Cambridge 2003
• Dogmatics. Volume III: The Christian Doctrine of the the Church, Faith and the Consummation, James Clarke & Co, Cambridge 2003
• The Divine Imperative: A Study in Christian Ethics, The Lutterworth Press, Cambridge 2003
• The Great Invitation Zurich Sermons, The Lutterworth Press, Cambridge 2003
• I Believe in the Living God. Sermons on the Apostles' Creed, The Lutterworth Press, Cambridge 2004
• Justice and Social Order, The Lutterworth Press, Cambridge 2003
• The Letter to the Romans, The Lutterworth Press, Cambridge 2003
• Man in Revolt. A Christian Anthropology, The Lutterworth Press, Cambridge 2003
• The Mediator, The Lutterworth Press, Cambridge 2003
• The Misunderstanding of the Church, The Lutterworth Press, Cambridge 2003
• Christianity and Civilisation. Gifford Lectures Delivered at the University of St Andrews, James Clarke & Co, Cambridge 2009

Selected works on Brunner

• Politics and Protestant theology : an interpretation of Tillich, Barth, Bonhoeffer, and Brunner, René de Visme Williamson (2005), ISBN 0-9711-9190-5
• Emil Brunner, J. Edward Humphrey (1976)

External links

• Emil Brunner in German, French and Italian in the online Historical Dictionary of Switzerland.
• Entry in Biographisch-Bibliographisches Kirchenlexikon (German)