but

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Email
(bŭt; bət ) pronunciation
conj.
  1. On the contrary: the plan caused not prosperity but ruin.
  2. Contrary to expectation; yet: She organized her work but accomplished very little. He is tired but happy.
  3. Usage Problem. Used to indicate an exception: No one but she saw the prowler.
  4. With the exception that; except that. Often used with that: would have joined the band but he couldn't spare the time; would have resisted but that they lacked courage.
  5. Informal. Without the result that: It never rains but it pours.
  6. Informal. That. Often used after a negative: There is no doubt but right will prevail.
  7. That . . . not. Used after a negative or question: There never is a tax law presented but someone will oppose it.
  8. If not; unless: "Ten to one but the police have got them" (Charlotte M. Yonge).
  9. Informal. Than: They had no sooner arrived but they turned around and left.
prep.
Usage Problem. Except.

adv.
  1. Merely; just; only: hopes that lasted but a moment.
  2. Used as an intensive: Get out of here but fast!
idiom:

but for

  1. Were it not for: except for: We would have reached the summit but for the weather.

[Middle English, from Old English būtan.]

USAGE NOTE   Traditional grammarians have worried over what form the pronoun ought to take when but is used to indicate an exception in sentences such as No one but I (or No one but me) has read it. Some have argued that but is a conjunction in these sentences and therefore should be followed by the nominative form I. However, many of these grammarians have gone on to argue somewhat inconsistently that the accusative form me is appropriate when the but phrase occurs at the end of a sentence, as in No one has read it but me. While this treatment of the construction has a considerable weight of precedent on its side and cannot be regarded as incorrect, a strong case can be made on grammatical grounds for treating this use of but as a preposition. For one thing, if but were truly a conjunction here, we would expect the verb to agree in person and number with the noun or pronoun following but; we would then say No one but the students have read it. What is more, if but were a true conjunction here we would not expect that it could be moved to the end of a clause, as in No one has read it but the students. Note that we cannot use the conjunction and in a similar way, saying John left and everyone else in the class in place of John and everyone else in the class left. These observations suggest that but is best considered as a preposition here and followed by accusative forms such as me and them in all positions: No one but me has read it. No one has read it but me. These recommendations are supported by 73 percent of the Usage Panel when the but phrase precedes the verb and by 93 percent when the but phrase follows the verb. • But is redundant when used together with however, as in But the army, however, went on with its plans; one or the other word should be eliminated. • But is generally not followed by a comma. Correct written style requires Kim wanted to go, but we stayed, not Kim wanted to go, but, we stayed.But may be used to begin a sentence at all levels of style. See Usage Notes at and, cannot, doubt, however, I1.



1.
general.
But is a preposition and conjunction, and is used contrastively: (preposition) Everyone seems to know but me / (conjunction) Everyone seems to know but I don't. In more modern usage, as the Old English (up to 1150)D and Fowler (1926) have both recognized, the roles of but as a conjunction and preposition have become inextricably confused, and this fact gives rise to some vexed problems of usage. These are described in the following paragraphs, each headed by a typical example of the problem.

2. Everyone but she [or her?] can see the answer. Fowler explored this problem in some depth, and concluded that but in this meaning is more a conjunction than a preposition, and therefore the case of a following pronoun is variable. When the phrase introduced by but is associated with the subject of the sentence, the pronoun should be treated as subjective (i.e. No one saw him but I) and when the phrase is associated with the object, the pronoun should be treated as objective (i.e. I saw no one but him). When the association is not as clear-cut as this, the case of the pronoun is determined by the position of the but-phrase in the sentence: when the but-phrase is in the subject area, the pronoun should be treated as subjective (i.e. Everyone but she can see the answer) and when the but-phrase is in the object area it should be treated as objective (i.e. Everyone can see the answer but her). Usage is unstable when the verb is intransitive: Everyone knows but her is somewhat more natural than Everyone knows but she).

3. I disagree. But what do you think? The widespread public belief that but should not begin a sentence seems to be unshakeable. But it has no foundation in grammar or idiom, and examples are frequent in good literature:
All animals have sense. But a dog is an animal.—Locke, 1690
But this rough magic I here abjure—Shakespeare, Tempest, 1610
Of course they loved her, the two remaining ones, they hugged her, they had mingled their tears. But they could not converse with her—Iris Murdoch, 1993.
The initial position of but, as with and, is a matter not of grammar but of style.

4. Who knows but that the whole course of history might [or might not?] have been different? When this construction is used with a negative or (especially) in a question, there is always a temptation to make the second part of the sentence negative. It is usually better to rephrase: Who knows: the whole course of history might have been different?

5. But your answer, moreover, is unacceptable. A further contrasting word, such as however, nonetheless, moreover, etc., should not be used in a clause introduced by but. If the second word is needed (i.e. if moreover is the right word to use), omit but: Your answer, moreover, is unacceptable. Note, however, that but still is a standard idiom, especially informally: It's late but still you did want me to stay.

6. He is not upset but he is relieved. The repetition of he is, when this is the same person as at the first mention, is normally redundant: He is not upset but relieved. However, it is often added in conversation, with rhetorical emphasis on the second is.

7.
idioms.
But is used in a number of fixed idioms:
  • all but. By the end of the war this attitude had all but disappeared—P. Wright, 1987.
  • cannot (help) but. The insertion of help is not attested before the late 19th century but is now common: The frailty of man without thee cannot but fallBook of Common Prayer, 1549 / She could not help but plague the lad—H. Caine, 1894 / She could not help but follow him into the big department store—B. Rubens, 1987.
  • but what. It's no telling but what I might have gone on to school like my own children have—Lee Smith, 1983 (US). This use is now old-fashioned, and limited to informal and non-standard uses.
  • rhetorical use. Ah, but who built it, that we tiny creatures can walk in its arcades?—Margaret Drabble, 1987. This use is not normally found in everyday English.

Previous:business, busyness, bus, burnt, burned
Next:by prep, by, by-, bye, bête noire

adverb

    To the exclusion of anyone or anything else: alone, entirely, exclusively, only, solely. See include/exclude.

Top
pronunciation

IN BRIEF: adv. - And nothing more.

pronunciation We've learned how to destroy, but not to create; how to waste, but not to build; how to kill men, but not how to save them; how to die, but seldom how to live. — Omar Nelson Bradley

Tutor's tip: The group on the "butte" (small steep mountain with a flat top) made him the "butt" (laughing stock) of their jokes, "but" (except that) he did not laugh.

LearnThatWord.com is a free vocabulary and spelling program where you only pay for results!

sign description: The index fingers begin crossed in front of the chest and then seperate lifting up to two fingers standing straight up.




Random House Word Menu:

categories related to 'but'

Top
Random House Word Menu by Stephen Glazier
For a list of words related to but, see:

  See crossword solutions for the clue But.
Top

Dansk (Danish)
prep. - undtagen, bortset fra
conj. - men
adv. - kun, blot
n. - men

idioms:

  • but for    havde det ikke været for
  • no buts    ikke noget men

Nederlands (Dutch)
maar, behalve, echter, slechts, helemaal, die/dat niet, bezwaar(maken)

Français (French)
prep. - excepté, sauf, sinon
conj. - mais, cependant
adv. - si seulement, juste, seulement, ne que
n. - mais (qui tienne)

idioms:

  • but for    mais à propos de, sans (cela)
  • no buts    il n'y a pas de mais qui tienne

Deutsch (German)
prep. - außer
conj. - aber, sondern, ohne daß
adv. - nur, erst
n. - Aber

idioms:

  • but for    wenn nicht... gewesen wäre, dann..., bis auf
  • no buts    keine Widerrede

Ελληνική (Greek)
prep. - εκτός (από), πλην (του)
conj. - αλλά (όμως), μα, μόνο (και μόνο), εκτός αν
adv. - παρά, μα
n. - (το) αλλά, ο λόγος εναντίωσης

idioms:

  • but for    έτσι κι έλειπε ο, ας μην ήταν ο
  • no buts    δεν θέλω αντιρρήσεις

Italiano (Italian)
tranne, fuorché, ma, però

idioms:

  • but for    salvo per
  • ifs and buts    obiezioni, ostacoli
  • no buts    senza ma

Português (Portuguese)
prep. - exceto
conj. - mas
adv. - somente
n. - objeção (f)

idioms:

  • but for    sem
  • ifs and buts    desculpas (gír.)
  • no buts    não há dúvidas

Русский (Russian)
но, однако

idioms:

  • but for    если бы не
  • ifs and buts    оговорки
  • no buts    никаких "но"

Español (Spanish)
prep. - excepto, sino, sino que, fuera de, menos, más que
conj. - pero, empero, más, que no, sin que, menos de, dejar de
adv. - sólo, no más que, solamente
n. - pero

idioms:

  • but for    a no ser por
  • no buts    no hay peros que valgan

Svenska (Swedish)
prep. - utom, mer än, annat än
conj. - men, utan, dock
adv. - bara, blott, endast
n. - men, aber

中文(简体)(Chinese (Simplified))
除...以外, 但是, 可是, 然而, 而是, 只, 才, 仅仅, 肯定地, 绝对地, 异议

idioms:

  • but for    要不是
  • no buts    别说"但是但是"了

中文(繁體)(Chinese (Traditional))
prep. - 除...以外
conj. - 但是, 可是, 然而, 而是
adv. - 只, 才, 僅僅, 肯定地, 絕對地
n. - 但是, 異議

idioms:

  • but for    要不是
  • no buts    別說"但是但是"了

한국어 (Korean)
prep. - ~을 제외하고
conj. - 그러나, ~을 제외하고는, ~이 아닌 것 같은
adv. - 겨우
n. - 그러나

idioms:

  • but for    ~이 없다면

日本語 (Japanese)
adv. - ほんの
prep. - …以外は
n. - 異議
conj. - だが, しかし, 必ず…する, 除いて, …でない

idioms:

  • all but    ほとんど, 除いて皆
  • but for    …がなかったなら, 別にすれば
  • in all but name    事実上
  • no buts    言い訳しない
  • none but    ~以外は誰も~ない, ただ~だけ
  • shaken but not stirred    振るだけでかき混ぜないマティーニ
  • slowly but surely    ゆっくり確実に

العربيه (Arabic)
‏(حرف جر) ما عدا, سوى (حرف عطف) لكن, و لكن, غير ان, انما (ظرف) لو ان (الاسم) احتجاج‏

עברית (Hebrew)
prep. - ‮חוץ מ-, רק‬
conj. - ‮אבל, אך, אלא, כי-אם, בלא ש-, מבלי ש-, ברם, חוץ מ-, שלא-, להפך, פרט ל-, למרות ש-, עם זאת‬
adv. - ‮חוץ מ-, למרות ש-‬
n. - ‮חדר חיצון, סתירה, ניגוד‬


Post a question - any question - to the WikiAnswers community:

Copyrights: