1. Before 1700
The word comédie can be misleading in French. In the 17th c. it was used of all kinds of play; ‘aller à la comédie’ meant to go to the theatre, and comédien still means simply an actor in the 20th c. Even when used more technically, comédie did not necessarily imply laughter or amusement; Pierre Corneille gave to some of his serious plays with happy endings the label ‘comédie héroïque’.
If one were to judge by the use of the word, comedy did not exist in France before the 16th c., when its arrival was heralded in Du Bellay's Défense et illustration, with its call for the re-creation of comedy alongside other ancient forms such as ode or tragedy. But of course much drama in the Middle Ages (not to speak of other genres) is essentially comic [see Medieval Theatre]. Comic elements existed within the liturgical plays, the liturgy was shadowed by the parodic ‘fête des fous’, and the jongleurs maintained a tradition of open-air popular entertainment. As for the comic theatre proper, we still have the 13th-c. ‘jeux’ of Bodel and Adam de la Halle in Arras, and the numerous didactic or satirical soties, morality plays, or farces performed in the 15th and 16th c. by such groups as the Enfants sans Souci or the Basoche. Patelin is the best-known example of this entertaining popular theatre.
The mid-16th c. saw the humanists attempting to create a more literary type of comedy. Rejecting native farce, they looked for models to the Latin New Comedy (Plautus, Terence) and more directly to the Italians. Classical French comedy is above all Italian in origin. The theories adumbrated by Peletier du Mans, Larivey, and others anticipated 17th-c. doctrine, and plays such as Jodelle's Eugène (still close to the medieval farce in some respects), Grévin's Les Ébahis and La Trésorière, and the skilfully written comedies of Larivey suggested future directions for the comic theatre. They failed, however, to find a real theatrical public [see Theatres And Audiences].
Throughout the ancien régime farce and other forms of popular theatre continued to attract crowds. The trio of farceurs at the Hôtel de Bourgogne [see Farce], Tabarin on the Pont-Neuf, Bruscambille, and the white-faced Jodelet all performed amusing short pieces. Companies from Italy played commedia dell'arte, at first in their own language, but eventually in French, with an ample element of slapstick [see Comédie-Italienne]. And from the late 17th c. the théâtres de la foire attracted mixed audiences to varied entertainments in which farce mingled with music and spectacular effects. Some of these currents flowed together in the 18th c. to create the genre of opéra-comique.
Meanwhile a more literary form of comedy established itself on the Parisian stage during the first third of the 17th c. The Italian pastoral plays, imitated by Hardy, Racan, and Mairet, were a formative influence. Du Ryer, Rotrou, and Desmarets among others made significant contributions, but the essential figure was Pierre Corneille, whose early comedies transfer the pastoral love intrigue to a nicely observed contemporary urban reality. His Illusion comique is an exceptional tour de force.
The years between 1640 and 1660 saw the consolidation of ‘la grande comédie’, literary comedy of manners and intrigue in five acts and in verse. Although less discussed by theorists than tragedy, it was shaped according to similar precepts to those governing its more serious elder sister. From about 1640 Spanish theatre exerted a powerful influence, seen notably in Pierre Corneille's Le Menteur and the plays of Rotrou, Scarron, and Thomas Corneille.
Many new comedies were written in the years after 1660 by authors including Quinault, Donneau de Visé, Racine (Les Plaideurs), and Hauteroche, but the comic stage at this time was dominated by Molière. Supported by the king, the ‘premier farceur de France’ combined elements from popular and learned theatre, together with court spectaculars (comédies-ballets) in an unparalleled creation which appealed equally to la cour and la ville, to the honnêtes gens and the ordinary people. Molière became the standard model proposed to subsequent comic playwrights. Unfortunately, however, critics from Boileau on tended to concentrate on a small number of Molière's more ‘serious’ comedies ( Le Misanthrope, Le Tartuffe, Les Femmes savantes, etc.), neglecting the more lively elements in the name of literary decorum, and making of him the champion of ‘la comédie de caractère’.
2. After 1700
The century following Molière's death was a golden age for comedy, which occupied a central position in the French literary culture of the time. Before and after 1700 Regnard, Dancourt, Dufresny, Lesage, and others produced witty, cynical comedies of intrigue and social observation. Of these, Turcaret is the finest example. Marivaux, working mainly for the Comédie-Italienne, developed a brilliantly original type of comedy, founded on the elegant and subtle exploration of amorous feeling. Some of his later plays show a tendency to a more moralizing or sentimental strain, which can be seen equally in the work of Voltaire (L'Enfant prodigue and Nanine), Gresset (Le Méchant), Piron (La Métromanie), and above all Destouches, whose plays (notably Le Glorieux) combine fashionable sensibility and comic verve. This line was further developed in the comédie larmoyante of La Chaussée and the drame of Diderot or Sedaine; here comedy takes second place to emotion and instruction.
A more light-hearted comedy persisted, not only in the popular theatre but in the ‘théâtres de société’, private theatricals which enjoyed a great vogue in the 18th c. Here the proverbes dramatiques of Carmontelle or the plays of Collé were performed, together with parades, of which Gueullette made a speciality [see Farce, 2]. Beaumarchais too wrote parades, as well as drames, and elements of both combine with comedy of intrigue and socio-political satire in Le Barbier de Séville and Le Mariage de Figaro. These two plays were the great events of French comic theatre in the last quarter of the 18th c.
Comedy continued to be performed in France during the Revolutionary, Napoleonic, and Restoration years. It was largely based on existing models (Fabre d'Églantine, Pigault-Lebrun, L.-B. Picard (1769-1828), Delavigne, etc.). This period also saw the remarkable rise of the quintessentially French vaudeville, the most popular form of theatre throughout the 19th c. After 1820 the comic theatre was dominated by two figures, Scribe and Musset. The tightly crafted if shallow comédies-vaudevilles of the former provided a model of the well-made play for successors such as Sardou (and Ibsen). Musset's far more interesting plays, on the other hand, are full of charm, variety, and poetic fantasy; some execute variations on the proverbe dramatique, others, such as Les Caprices de Marianne or On ne badine pas avec l'amour, come close to the world of tragedy or drame.
There is indeed a growing tendency, from the early 19th c. onwards, for the once-separate theatrical genres to merge. Tragedy no longer exists in a recognizable form; comedy, the more flexible form, combines with tragedy and drame in many different ways, from the comédie sérieuse of Dumas fils, Augier, and Becque to the 20th-c. comédie poétique of Giraudoux, Anouilh, or Schéhadé [see Drama In France Since 1789].
On the other hand, a relatively pure comic tradition does persist, notably in the farces or vaudevilles of Labiche, Feydeau, Courteline, or Romains (Knock, 1923), the comic operettas of Meilhac and Halévy, the sharp social observation of Porto-Riche and Jules Renard, and the 20th-c. Boulevard comedies of writers such as Aymé, Achard, Pagnol, Sacha Guitry, and André Roussin (b. 1911, the great supplier of the post-World War II Boulevard).
In a quite different vein, following Jarry's Uburoi, the avant-garde theatre contains a strong element of grotesque comedy or farce; this is evident in the work of Cocteau, Apollinaire, Vitrac, and the Belgians Crommelynck and Ghelderode. It culminates in the far from light-hearted comedy of Ionesco and other writers associated with the Theatre of the Absurd.
[Peter France]
Bibliography
- P. Voltz, La Comédie (1964)