Damascus steel

This section is written like a personal reflection or essay and may require cleanup. Please help improve it by rewriting it in an encyclopedic style. (December 2007)

This article may require copy-editing for grammar, style, cohesion, tone or spelling. You can assist by editing it. (April 2008)

This article appears to contradict the article Wootz steel. Please see discussion on the linked talk page. Please do not remove this message until the contradictions are resolved.

Damascus steel is a hot-forged steel used in Middle Eastern swordmaking from about 1100 to 1700 AD. Damascus swords were of legendary sharpness and strength, and were apocryphally claimed to be able to cut through lesser quality swords and even rock. The technique used to create original Damascus steel is now a matter of historical conjecture. Many raw materials and the metalsmiths' recipes are no longer available. The foundation for Damascus Steel is Wootz Steel, which originated in India and Sri Lanka^[1] and later spread to Persia.^[2] From the 3rd century to 17th century, India was shipping steel ingots to the Middle East for use in Damascus steel.^[3]

The general term "Damascus" refers to metal with a visible grain pattern, sometimes with a texture. Modern Damascus is a lamination of folded steels selected with cosmetic qualities, with grinding and polishing specifically to expose the layers. True Damascus patterns are formed when carbon trace elements form visible swirls in the steel mix.^{[citation needed]} These elements change properties when the steel is work hardened (forged), creating the patterns.^{[citation needed]}

History

Drawing of corn harvesting knife of twisted cable or pattern welding

Several other steelmaking techniques, such as wootz steel also result in patterned surfaces and have often been sold as Damascus steel, Damascened steel and sometimes watered steel. The most common technique today for producing these materials is pattern welding, which is widely used for custom knife making. Modern Damascus steel is usually made by pattern welding two tool steels, one with high nickel content, appearing bright, the other appearing more grey so that alternating steels produce light-dark stripes. Treating or pickling the steel with dilute acid after polishing enhances the pattern by darkening one of the steels more than the other.^{[citation needed]} Folding and twisting while hammer forging controls the striped pattern, and the method used is often trademarked. Skilled swordsmiths can manipulate the layered patterns to mimic the complex designs found in the surface of the original, medieval Damascus steel. Some knife artists begin with stacking steel wires and through folding can produce repeating images along a blade, such as a crossed U.S. flags.^{[citation needed]} Stacking wires is a speciality of the Cable Damascus technique, a new age development. The advent of steel wire rope (1830's) provided mid-west blacksmiths a way to make corn harvester's machetes (cable knives).

One explanation of the legendary properties of Damascus steel is that the pattern consists of alternating bands of very hard, but brittle iron carbide or cementite and softer more flexible iron. Another possibility is that the steel contains a small amount of vanadium, which would theoretically strengthen the blade ^[4]. The legendary steel may have been a happy accident by way of the limited production methods. Original Damascus steel billet was formed from a small disk that was hammer folded/forged into its final shape. Unlike northern European methods, the ferro-smelting technique in Persia during the Middle Ages involved small bowl-type crucibles with lids, baked in a mound-type oven often used for bread. Controlling the air contact to the melt, as well as trace elements found locally, all combined to produce a steel blade noticeably better than its contemporaries.^{[citation needed]}

Carbon nanotubes and nanowires were found in a sample of a 17th century sword forged from Damascus steel. The complex process of forging and annealing is thought to have accounted for the nano-scale structures.^[5]

The origins of the name Damascus remains somewhat controversial. Damascus steel was originally made using ore with a certain chemical composition from a mine that is now exhausted^{[citation needed]}, so attempts at reproduction are difficult at best.

It would seem obvious that the name Damascus refers to swords forged in Damascus, but there are several other possible sources of the name. One is the name of the swordsmith himself: the author al-Beruni refers to swords made by a man he names Damashqi. Another author, al-Kindi, refers to swords made in Damascus as Damascene. This word has often been employed as an epithet in various Eastern European legends (Sabya Damaskinya or Sablja Dimiskija meaning "Damascene saber"), of which perhaps the best known are the Serbian legends of Prince Marko, a historical figure of the late 14th century in what is now the Republic of Macedonia.

Manufacture

This article appears to contain speculation and unjustified claims. Information must be verifiable and based on reliable published sources. Please remove speculation from the article.

The original Damascus steel swords may have been made in the vicinity of Damascus, Syria, in the period from 900 AD to as late as 1750 AD. Damascus steel is a type of steel alloy that is both hard and flexible, a combination that made it ideal for the building of swords. It is said that when Damascus-made swords were first encountered by Crusaders during the Crusades, it garnered an almost mythical reputation—a Damascus steel blade was said to be able to cut a piece of silk in half as it fell to the ground, as well as being able to chop through normal blades, or even rock, without losing its sharp edge. Recent metallurgical experiments, based on microscopic studies of preserved Damascus-steel blades, have claimed to reproduce a very similar steel via possible reconstructions of the historical process^[6].

When forming a batch of steel, impurities are added to control the properties of the resulting alloy. In general, notably during the era of Damascus steel, one could produce an alloy that was hard yet brittle at one extreme by adding up to 2% carbon, or a higher level of toughness yet ductile and malleable at the other, with about 0.5% carbon. The problem for a swordsmith is to create a steel which strikes the perfect balance between hard and tough — hard, so as to hold an edge once sharpened, but tough so it would not shatter when hitting other metal in combat. This was not possible with normal processes.

Metalsmiths in India and Sri Lanka perhaps as early as 300 AD developed a new technique known as wootz steel that produced a high-carbon steel of unusually high purity. Glass was added to a mixture of iron and charcoal and then heated. The glass would act as a flux and bind to other impurities in the mixture, allowing them to rise to the surface and leave a more nearly pure steel when the mixture cooled. Thousands of steel making sites were found in Samanalawewa area in Sri Lanka that made high carbon steel as early as 300 BC. (Juleff, 1996). These steel making furnaces were built facing western monsoon winds and wind turbulence and suction was used to create a forced draft in the furnace, increasing the heat available. Steel making sites in Sri Lanka have been dated to 300 BC using carbon dating technology. The technique propagated very slowly through the world, reaching modern-day Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan around 900 AD, and then the Middle East circa 1000 AD.

This process was further refined in the Middle East using locally produced steels. The exact process remains unknown, but allowed carbides to precipitate out as micro particles arranged in sheets or bands within the body of a blade. The carbides are far harder than the surrounding low carbon steel, allowing the swordsmith to make an edge which would cut hard materials with the precipitated carbides, while the bands of softer steel allowed the sword as a whole to remain tough and flexible.

The banded carbide precipitates appear in the blade as a swirling pattern. By manipulating the ingot of steel in a certain way during forging, various intentional patterns could be induced in the steel. The most common of these was a pattern of lateral bands, often called 'Muhammad's Ladder', most likely formed by cutting or forging notches into the surface of the ingot, then forging it into the blade shape (this is the method Pendray (below) used to reproduce the pattern).

A team of researchers based at the Technical University of Dresden that uses x-rays and electron microscopy to examine Damascus steel discovered the presence of cementite nanowires^[7] and carbon nanotubes.^[8] Peter Paufler, a member of the Dresden team, says that these nanostructures give Damascus steel its distinctive properties^[9] and are a result of the forging process.^[5][9]

Lefever Grade G shotgun with Pattern welded "Damascened steel" Barrels

Prior to the early 20th century, all shotgun barrels were forged by heating narrow strips of iron and steel and shaping them around a mandrel.^[10][11] This was process was referred to as "laminating" or "Damascus" and these barrels were found on inexpensive shotguns that sold for $12.^[10][11] These types of barrels earned a reputation for weakness and were never meant to be used with modern smokeless powder, often resulting in catastrophic failure.^[11] Because of the appearance to Damascus steel, higher-end barrels were made by Belgian and British gun makers.^[10][11] These barrels are proof marked and meant to be used with light pressure loads.^[10] Modern gun manufacturers such as Caspian Arms make slide assemblies and small parts such as triggers and safties for Colt M1911 pistols from powdered Swedish steel resulting in a swirling two toned effect, these parts are often referred to as "Stainless Damascus".^[12]

Loss of the technique

This article appears to contain speculation and unjustified claims. Information must be verifiable and based on reliable published sources. Please remove speculation from the article.

The process was lost to the middle-eastern metalsmiths circa 1750 AD, possibly because sources of ores containing trace amounts of tungsten and/or vanadium needed for its production were depleted. Numerous attempts have been made to recreate the process with varying success, and the original process remains speculative.

One argument holds that the raw material for Damascus steel swords was actually imported from India, because India was the only known commercial center of crucible-fired steels like wootz. Contradictory evidence was found in the form of furnaces in Turkmenistan,^{[citation needed]} indicating that some techniques were transferred out of India, although no remains of the distinctive wootz furnaces have appeared and it is presently unknown whether wootz was ever fired in these furnaces. The work of Verhoeven et al. supports the hypothesis that the wootz used was from India, as Damascus steel contains several key impurities consistent with ores only known to have been available in India.

The Russian bulat steel contains many similar properties, albeit they are achieved by a different process. Recently various groups have claimed to have recreated steel with properties consistent with true Damascus blades through experimental archaeology, although these acknowledge that the original process remains uncertain. Verhoeven et al. (1998)^[13] argued that the keys are ores with certain trace elements, controlled thermal cycling after the initial forging, and a grinding process to reveal the final damask pattern. A somewhat different technique was proposed by Wadsworth and Sherby.^[14]

The recent discovery of carbon nanotubes in the steel's composition^[15] by Peter Paufler has resulted in another hypothesis to explain the loss of the technique. Large quantities of carbon nanotubes can be combined to form an extremely strong and stiff material. While nanotubes occur randomly in nature, volumes sufficient to alter the structural properties of a material requires high-tech, high-energy production methods to be obtained. Ancient smiths are not known to have access to any process technology that could control the formation of nanometer-scale carbon structures. Thus, according to the hypothesis, some chance combination of techniques or materials (i.e. related to forging, alloy composition, heat treatment, smelting process, environmental particularities, etc.) may have contributed to the formation of these structures, explaining both the mythology of Damascus steel and the inability of modern experimenters to replicate the process. If the hypothesis is true, Damascus swords, once manufactured, underwent a process of testing, and the small percentage that possessed the coveted combination of extreme hardness and high malleability were selected for delivery.

Reproduction attempts

Pattern welded "Damascened steel" sheath knife

From the very start, the superior capabilities of Damascus swords attracted significant attention, and many attempts were made to reproduce either the performance or the appearance of the Damascus blades. Since pattern welding was a widespread technique, and produced surface patterns similar to those found on Damascus blades, many people believed that Damascus blades were made using a pattern welding technique. This belief was challenged in the 1990s when J. D. Verhoeven and A. H. Pendray published an article on their experiments on reproducing the elemental, structural, and visual characteristics of Damascus steel.

Verhoeven and Pendray started with a cake of steel that matched the properties of the original wootz steel from India, which also matched a number of original Damascus swords they had access to. The wootz was in a soft, annealed state, with a large grain structure, and many beads of pure iron carbide which were the result of the hypereutectoid state of the wootz. They had already determined that the grains on the surface of the steel were grains of iron carbide, so their question was how to reproduce the fine iron carbide patterns they saw in the Damascus blades from the large grains in the wootz.

Although such material could be worked at low temperatures to produce the striated Damascene pattern of intermixed ferrite and cementite bands (in a manner identical to pattern-welded Damascus steel), any heat treatment sufficient to dissolve the carbides would destroy the pattern permanently. However, Verhoeven and Pendray discovered that in samples of true Damascus steel the Damascene pattern could be recovered by aging at a moderate temperature. Their investigations found that certain carbide forming elements (chief of which was vanadium), which in the wootz were concentrated in the carbide regions and were formed into a striated pattern during forging just as the iron carbide itself, did not disperse until higher temperatures than those needed to dissolve the carbides. Therefore, though a high heat treatment could remove the visible evidence of patterning associated with carbides it did not remove the underlying patterning of the carbide forming elements, and a subsequent lower temperature heat treatment (at a temperature at which the carbides were again stable) could recover the identical structure by the binding of carbon by those elements.

Pattern welded "Damascened" steel

The most popular theory of Damascus steel was premised on pattern welding because the layering revealed by etching a pattern-welded blade in acid is similar to that of Damascus steel. Hence, pattern welded steel is commonly sold today as "Damascus steel" even though recent research suggests the original Damascus steel was created with a different technique.

Pattern welded Damascus is made from several types of steel and iron slices, which are then welded together to form a billet. The patterns vary depending on how the smith works the billet. The billet is drawn out and folded until the desired number of layers are formed. The end result can bear a strong resemblance to the surface appearance of a true Damascus blade although the internal structure is dissimilar.

See also

• Japanese sword making
• Experimental archaeology
• Tungsten carbide, which is often bonded to steel to form tools that are tough, and have a hard, durable cutting surface.

References

Further reading

• Eric M. Taleff, Bruce L. Bramfitt, Chol K. Syn, Donald R. Lesuer, Jeffrey Wadsworth, and Oleg D. Sherby, "Processing, structure, and properties of a rolled ultrahigh-carbon steel plate exhibiting a damask pattern," Materials Characterization 46 (1), 11-18 (2001).
• J. D. Verhoeven, "A review of microsegregation induced banding phenomena in steels", J. Materials Engineering and Performance 9 (3), 286-296 (2000).

External links

• Exeter University recreation of Sri Lankan Steel Furnaces
• "Damascus steel's lost secret found"
• "Damascene Technique in Metal Working" Detailed historical and scientific discussion with many pictures
• "Secret's out for Saracen sabres" News of the discovery of nanotubes and nanowires, from issue 2578 of New Scientist magazine, 15 November 2006, page 20, citing Nature, vol 444, p 286
• "Damascus Gun Barrels" Devoted to understanding the technology, people and art that created Forge Welded Damascus Shotgun Barrels. Many pictures. Time line, etc.
• Damascus Steel: Archaeology