Jack Farrell debuted on October 27, 1874, playing for the Hartford Dark Blues at Hartford Ball Club Grounds; he played his final game on October 30, 1874, playing for the Hartford Dark Blues at Hartford Ball Club Grounds.

Fancy O'Neil debuted on October 23, 1874, playing for the Hartford Dark Blues at Hartford Ball Club Grounds; he played his final game on October 23, 1874, playing for the Hartford Dark Blues at Hartford Ball Club Grounds.

Everett Mills debuted on May 5, 1871, playing for the Washington Olympics at Olympics Grounds; he played his final game on October 17, 1876, playing for the Hartford Dark Blues at Hartford Ball Club Grounds.

Orator Shafer debuted on May 23, 1874, playing for the Hartford Dark Blues at Hartford Ball Club Grounds; he played his final game on September 13, 1890, playing for the Philadelphia Athletics at Jefferson Street Grounds.

Steve Brady debuted on July 23, 1874, playing for the Hartford Dark Blues at Hartford Ball Club Grounds; he played his final game on October 5, 1886, playing for the New York Metropolitans at St. George Cricket Grounds.