This question is ill posed.
Lumen is a unit of measure for how much light comes from the
lamp
Watt is a unit of measure for how much energy is used by the
lamp
If the question were; "Which is brighter, a 2000 lumen bulb or a
1500 lumen bulb?" then the answer would be: The 2000 lumen
bulb.
I think the relation ship between lumen and watt is something
like:
Incandecent bulbs are 15w/lumen
Flourecent bulbs use 40w/lumen
LED bulbs are 70w/lumen
The way to show the watt and lumen relationship is usually
lumens (amount of light) per watt (energy consumption). This is
like gas in your car (Miles or KM per Gallon or Liter).
Incandescent bulbs have a maximum luminosity of 52
lumens/watt.
Fluorescent bulbs range from 46 lumens/watt (CFL) to 100
lumens/watt (T5 and T8 tubes)
LED bulbs range from 29 lumens/watt (older, low efficiency) to
100+ (XCree) and they are getting better.