Ham Allen debuted on April 27, 1872, playing for the Middletown Mansfields at Mansfield Club Grounds; he played his final game on August 9, 1872, playing for the Middletown Mansfields at Mansfield Club Grounds.

Billy Arnold debuted on April 26, 1872, playing for the Middletown Mansfields at Mansfield Club Grounds; he played his final game on May 2, 1872, playing for the Middletown Mansfields at Mansfield Club Grounds.

Cy Bentley debuted on April 26, 1872, playing for the Middletown Mansfields at Mansfield Club Grounds; he played his final game on August 9, 1872, playing for the Middletown Mansfields at Mansfield Club Grounds.

Frank McCarton debuted on April 26, 1872, playing for the Middletown Mansfields at Mansfield Club Grounds; he played his final game on August 5, 1872, playing for the Middletown Mansfields at Mansfield Club Grounds.

George Fields debuted on May 2, 1872, playing for the Middletown Mansfields at Mansfield Club Grounds; he played his final game on August 9, 1872, playing for the Middletown Mansfields at Mansfield Club Grounds.