The use of drugs that act on the mind is as old as the recorded history of man. Alcohol in the form of fermented beverages such as mead was probably already popular in the palaeolithic age, about 8000 bc, and grape wine from about 400–300 bc.
Opium is referred to in Sumerian tablets of around 4000 bc, and marijuana was known in China at 2737 bc. The hallucinogenic properties of the magic mushroom (teonanacatl) were known from 1000 bc in Mexico, while in northern Europe and Asia the inebriant properties of the fly agaric mushroom, Amanita muscaria, feature in Norse legends. The concept that drugs can be used medically to restore mental health is, in contrast, the result of a very recent revolution in pharmacology, following the discovery in the 1950s of new classes of drugs, the tranquillizers and antidepressants, and their widespread use in the treatment of mental illness.
Staggering quantities of psychoactive drugs are now consumed for medical purposes. About half of the female population of the United Kingdom over the age of 60 regularly uses sedative drugs to put them to sleep each night. Benzodiazepines in the form of Valium (diazepam) and related substances by day, and Mogadon (nitrazepam) and Dalmane (flurazepam) for night sedation, have largely replaced barbiturate sedatives and hypnotics. The success of these 'tranquillizers' can be gauged by the astonishing quantity consumed, amounting to tens of billions of doses throughout the world each year. These substances have a definite although mild calming effect, they relieve anxiety and diminish aggression, and they are relatively safe — in contrast to the barbiturates, which all too commonly lead to death from overdose. Because these newer drugs are relatively safe, and since almost all of us feel anxious from time to time, the extravagant success of the benzodiazepines during the 1960s and 1970s is not hard to understand. More recently, with the recognition that prolonged use of benzodiazepines can lead to addiction, there has been a growing reaction to their widespread use.
The most remarkable modern development in this field, however, is the discovery of drugs that are successful in the treatment of some of the fundamental symptoms of psychosis and depression. The first drug found to have such effects in schizophrenic patients was chlorpromazine (Largactil, Thorazine), and from this a large number of other so-called 'major tranquillizers' with similar effects have been developed. Since the first favourable reports on chlorpromazine appeared in France in 1952, such drugs have been adopted widely for the treatment of schizophrenia. More than 100 million schizophrenic patients have been treated with chlorpromazine since 1953. The major tranquillizers have definite beneficial effects on some of the most fundamental symptoms of schizophrenia: patients show less disordered thinking, suffer from fewer delusions and hallucinations, exhibit more appropriate emotional behaviour. They are not simply quietened or sedated, and indeed other sedative drugs such as the 'minor' tranquillizers (benzodiazepines) do not exhibit these effects. It is not surprising that the massive use of chlorpromazine and similar drugs has had an enormous impact on the treatment of schizophrenia. (For further discussion, see
schizophrenia: evidence for a neurochemical basis.) The mental institutions have been transformed from sombre places with a largely custodial function to hospitals with open doors in which community therapy and rehabilitation techniques have been introduced. The number of patients so severely ill as to need more or less permanent hospitalization has also diminished strikingly — to the extent that separate psychiatric hospitals may no longer be necessary in future.
Other groups of drugs have been discovered to have beneficial effects in treating the melancholia of depressed patients. Two major classes of antidepressants have been introduced since the late 1950s — one derived from the substance iproniazid and the other from imipramine. Both groups of compounds have beneficial effects in depression, although these actions are usually less dramatic than those seen with the antipsychotic drugs. A remarkable discovery, made by Dr John Cade in Australia in 1949, has been that the symptoms of mania can often be treated very effectively by administration of small doses of an inorganic salt — lithium carbonate. Continued treatment with lithium carbonate reduces the frequency of recurrence of manic episodes in individuals who would otherwise show a regular cycle of such illness.
The problems of madness have not been solved by the drugs — we still do not understand what causes schizophrenia or depression, or even the nature of these illnesses. The idea that abnormalities in brain chemistry may underlie mental illness has, however, derived strong support from the finding that psychosis can be treated with simple chemicals. Much research effort is currently directed towards discovering precisely how the antipsychotic and antidepressant drugs alter brain chemistry. It is now widely accepted that antipsychotic drugs act by blocking the effects of one of the chemical transmitter substances used by brain cells to transmit signals to one another. The transmitter blocked by chlorpromazine and related drugs is dopamine, and this finding has suggested the possibility that in schizophrenia excessive amounts of dopamine secreted in the brain might represent an immediate causative factor for the psychotic state. (See
dopamine neurons in the brain.) On the other hand, antidepressant drugs seem to act by enhancing the effects of other chemical transmitter substances, noradrenaline (norepinephrine) and serotonin, in the brain — suggesting that these chemicals may be available in abnormally low amounts in the brains of depressed people.
In general, however, our knowledge of the mode of action of many psychoactive drugs is limited. This applies particularly to nicotine, cannabis, and the hallucinogens, but both barbiturates and alcohol act as central nervous system depressants. With respect to barbiturates and benzodiazepines it is likely that their depressant effects on neural activity are mediated by the
neurotransmitter gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA), but other neurotransmitters may also be involved. Rather surprisingly, less is known about the precise mode of action of alcohol on the brain beyond the fact that it appears to depress synaptic transmission.
The fact that simple chemical substances can have such profound influences on the state of the mind, as between madness and sanity, between depression and euphoria, between normal perception and the vivid hallucinations induced by lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD), has obvious philosophical implications for the relation between the mind and the chemistry of the brain. It is clear that subtle changes in brain chemistry can have profound effects on the state of consciousness, and it behoves us to understand more of such subtleties.
Drugs are also consumed very widely for non-medical reasons. Of these alcohol, nicotine, and caffeine are relatively universal — others, whose use is strictly controlled by legislation, such as the hallucinogens, barbiturates, amphetamines, marijuana, phencyclidine, cocaine, and opiates, are, nevertheless, also quite widely taken. These compounds have a bewildering variety of different psychic effects. Alcohol and barbiturates are depressants, leading to a feeling of relaxation, loss of inhibition, and to inebriation and sleep. Others are stimulants, such as nicotine and the more powerful amphetamines; these are performance-enhancing drugs. LSD, mescaline, phencyclidine, and the many other hallucinogens are in a class apart because these compounds can produce bizarre changes in perception — they replace the present world with another that is equally real but different, often with vivid sensory hallucinations. There are other drugs whose actions are primarily euphoriant, notably cocaine, morphine, heroin and other opiate drugs, and — in a milder form — marijuana. They replace the present world with one in which the individual experiences no problems, and often intense pleasure. The most powerful euphoriants, the opiates and cocaine, are medically dangerous drugs — largely because their continued use leads inevitably to tolerance and
addiction, i.e. larger and larger doses become necessary to achieve the desired effects, and the organism becomes physically dependent on continued drug use, so that stopping the drug may precipitate very unpleasant withdrawal symptoms. It should be remembered, however, that morphine and related opiates still have important medical uses in the control of pain. Opium has long been regarded as a sovereign remedy for the relief of pain and other symptoms. As Thomas
Sydenham, the English physician, wrote at the end of the 17th century, 'I cannot forbear mentioning with gratitude the goodness of the Supreme Being who has supplied afflicted mankind with opiates for their relief'. Almost certainly it is the insanitary habits and unsterile modes of use as well as the actions of the drugs as such that make opiates such a hazard to the life and health of the addict today.
We may one day discover how to eliminate the problem of addiction, and we will then be faced with the difficult decision as to whether 'safe' euphoriant drugs should be allowed widespread availability and use. Several millennia of experience with alcohol suggests that strict control of the availability of such substances would inevitably be needed. The 'soma' of Aldous Huxley's
Brave New World may be nearer than is generally realized. There is little doubt that legislation controlling the use of marijuana will gradually become less prohibitive, and that modern plant breeding could work wonders with the Indian hemp plant to produce 'super-pot'. It is also clear that society has not yet decided what its attitudes should be to the general availability of chemically induced pleasure.
(Published 1987)— Les Iverson
Bibliography- Iversen, L. L., Iversen, S. D., and Snyder, S. H. (eds.) (1975–84). Handbook of Psychopharmacology, vols. i–xviii.
- Iversen, S. D., and Iversen, L. L. (1981). Behavioral Pharmacology (2nd edn.).
- Ray, O. S. (1972). Drugs, Society and Human Behavior.