quietism

View more Literature & Language videos

A tendency within mystical theology that commends the soul's self-abandoning acceptance of whatever God sends (‘pure love’), and values silent contemplation above petitionary prayer. Discernible in the Renaissance Spanish mystics and elaborated by Miguel Molinos (1640-96), its promotion by Madame Guyon led to a famous quarrel between Fénelon, who defended her, and Bossuet, who feared its potential for moral indifference and passive emotionalism. The effect of its condemnation by the papal brief Cum alias (1699) was to render all forms of mysticism suspect in the 18th-c. French Church; but German Pietism and British Methodism were to some extent its spiritual heirs.

[Peter Bayley]

In theology, a doctrine condemning all human effort and involvement with the world, in favour of passive devotional contemplation. In philosophy, the doctrine associated with Wittgenstein that there is no standpoint from which to achieve the traditional philosophical goal of a theory about some concept or another (e.g. truth, experience). See minimalism.

Quietism is a form of spirituality that emphasizes a direct relationship with God in a state of quietness of the soul (Latin quies). The ideas behind Quietism are to be found in many religions of the world. In the West, they influenced the mysticism of the Christian Middle Ages, notably that of the devotio moderna (modern devotion) movement. Quietist ideas reappeared during the sixteenth century in the alumbrados (illuminism) movement, which greatly worried the Spanish authorities. These notions reemerged in Italy in the 1680s when religious groups, self-proclaimed quietisti, promoted transformation in God and total spiritual passivity. The famous Spanish theologian Miguel de Molinos (1628–1696) encouraged these ideas in La guia espiritual (1675; The spiritual guide), ideas that were soon condemned because they seemed not only to call into question the hierarchy, authority, and dogma of the Roman Catholic Church but also to tolerate a dangerous moral bent toward sin—for committing sin could not trouble Quietism's intimate relationship with God. Molinos was tried by the Holy Office in 1685, and his teachings were condemned in 1687 by Pope Innocent XI for their Quietist negation of human powers and for what were regarded as their injurious theological and moral consequences. In Italy, works suspected of Quietism were included in the Index of Prohibited Books, and many trials followed. The hunt for Quietisti soon expanded all over Europe and contributed to the eighteenth-century waning of the mystical movement in France, Italy, and Spain.

In France, opponents of mysticism used the Roman condemnation to fight leading mystical figures such as Jeanne-Marie Bouvier de la Motte Guyon (Madame Guyon du Chesnoy; 1648–1717), the Barnabite preacher known as Father La Combe (1640–1715), and François de Salignac de La Mothe Fénelon, archbishop of Cambrai (1651–1715). They were all accused of suspicious links with the Italian Quietisti, of doubtful morality, and of disturbing theological concepts. First, La Combe was charged and imprisoned, then Guyon was condemned. Influenced by the Spanish mystic John of the Cross (1542–1591), Guyon actively promoted a mysticism based on the annihilation of the soul in Les torrents spirituels (1682; Spiritual torrents) and in Moyen court et très facile pour l'oraison (1685; Short and easy method to pray). Appealing at first to Parisian dévot circles and to the Marquise de Maintenon, the second wife of Louis XIV, she saw her writings condemned for their Quietism and found herself imprisoned many times between 1688 and 1703. Nevertheless, her ideas influenced various European audiences: Catholics and deists from France, Protestants from England, Scotland, and Switzerland, German Pietists, as well as the founder of Methodism, John Wesley (1703–1791), all claimed to be her disciples. The charges against Madame Guyon served also to put on trial Archbishop Fénelon to the point that his doctrine of Pure Love was equated with Quietism (he was on trial not only for being associated with Madame Guyon but also for political reasons). Fénelon promoted an unconditional love for God, so detached from any expectation of reward that one freely accepts to love God, even though convinced of one's own damnation. Fénelon, who had taken not only the side of Madame Guyon against her detractors, but also a political stand against Louis XIV's absolutism, was in turn accused of Quietism. Fénelon's formidable opponent, Bishop Jacques-Bénigne Bossuet, openly accused him of Quietist views and bad morality, leading to his condemnation and silencing in 1699. But, as French historian Jacques Le Brun notes, nothing was farther from Fénelon's austere doctrine of Pure Love and perfect charity than the accusation of total passivity.

Bibliography

Armogathe, Jean-Robert. Le quiétisme. Paris, 1973.

Beaude, Joseph, et al. Madame Guyon. Grenoble, 1997.

Cognet, Louis. Crépuscule des mystiques: Bossuet–Fénelon. Paris-Tournai, 1991.

Gondal, Marie-Louise. Madame Guyon (1648–1717): Un nouveau visage. Paris, 1989.

Laude, Patrick D. Approches du quiétisme: Deux études suivies du Moyen court et très facile pour l'oraison de Madame Guyon (texte de l'édition de 1685). Paris, Seattle, and Tübingen, 1991.

Le Brun, Jacques. Le pur amour de Platon à Lacan. Paris, 2002.

Lehmann, Hartmut, et al. Jansenismus, Quietismus, Pietismus/im Auftrag der Historischen Kommission zur Erforschung des Pietismus. Göttingen, 2002.

Meyer, Jean. Bossuet. Paris, 1993.

Richardt, Aimé. Fénelon. Ozoir-la-Ferrière, France, 1993.

Thompson, Phyllis. Madame Guyon, Martyr of the Holy Spirit. London, 1986.

—DOMINIQUE DESLANDRES

• Religious States and Experiences - quietism: type of religious mysticism marked by attainment of perfection through systematic contemplation; Molinism
• Mystical States and Experiences - quietism: passive, withdrawn posture toward worldly matters

Dansk (Danish)
n. - sindsro, passivitet

Nederlands (Dutch)
quiëtisme, berusting

Français (French)
n. - quiétisme

Deutsch (German)
n. - Quietismus (myst. Lehre)

Ελληνική (Greek)
n. - ησυχασμός

Italiano (Italian)
quietismo

Português (Portuguese)
n. - quietismo (m)

Русский (Russian)
квиетизм

Español (Spanish)
n. - quietismo, doctrina teológica cristiana, inacción

Svenska (Swedish)
n. - kvietism, sinnesro, passivitet

中文（简体）(Chinese (Simplified))
寂静主义, 精神的平静

中文（繁體）(Chinese (Traditional))
n. - 寂靜主義, 精神的平靜

한국어 (Korean)
n. - 정적주의, 평화, 무저항주의

日本語 (Japanese)
n. - 静寂主義, 静観主義, 平和, 静止

العربيه (Arabic)
‏(الاسم) الصامتون نوع من العبادة‏

עברית (Hebrew)
n. - ‮שתקנות, קבלת דברים בדומייה, שאננות, רגיעה, עקרון אי-ההתנגדות, גישה של סבילות לחיים, עם זניחת הרצון, כצורה של מיסטיקה דתית‬

If you are unable to view some languages clearly, click here.