(Heb.
bet keneset). The central religious institution of Judaism, the center for public
Prayer and for other religious and community activities; the prototype for analogous institutions in
Christianity and
Islam.
Origins
Although sources (Josephus, Philo, the New Testament, the Talmud, and archaeology) confirm the existence of the synagogue as an established institution already in the first century CE, its origin is unclear. A number of relatively late sources, e.g., the Midrash (Yad. Ex. 408), the New Testament (Acts 15:21), and Josephus (Contra Apionem 2:175), ascribed its establishment to Moses. However, this was a homiletical attempt to predate its actual origin. Many authorities feel that the events culminating in the emergence of the synagogue are to be dated to the Babylonian Exile (after 586 BCE). Scholarly speculation is that the exiles met from time to time, perhaps every Sabbath, to seek consolation over the loss of their land, to study Scripture, and perhaps to pray. Some prayers may even have been written at this time. As evidence, passages in Ezekiel, prophet of the exiles, are cited to indicate meetings of elders (Ezek. 8:1, 14:1, 20:1). The Talmud (Meg. 29a) finds a direct reference to the synagogues of Babylonia in Ezekiel 11:16: "Thus said the Lord God: I have indeed removed them far among the nations, and I have scattered them among the countries, and I have become to them a small sanctuary in the countries to which they have gone." The phrase "small sanctuary" was in the course of time often applied to a synagogue. Other theories have dated the origin of the synagogue to First Temple times, to the Hellenistic age, and to the Hasmonean period.
Ancient Period
With the return of the exiles from Babylonia and the rededication of the Temple, synagogues, or proto-synagogues, probably developed in Erets Israel. The Mishnah tells of a synagogue on the Temple Mount, beside the Temple itself (Sot. 7:7-8; Yoma 7:1). The Jerusalem Talmud (Meg. 3:1) claims that there were some 400 synagogues in Jerusalem at the time of the destruction of the Second Temple, a figure that may be exaggerated but points to their multiplicity. Nevertheless, development of the synagogue in the Diaspora may have outpaced its development in Erets Israel. The first concrete evidence of synagogue building comes from Egypt in the third century BCE. Philo (1st cent. CE), mentions the synagogues of Rome, the existence of which has been confirmed by archeology; the Book of Acts mentions Paul as preaching in synagogues in Damascus, Asia Minor, and Cyprus; and the Talmud refers to the magnificent Diaspora synagogue in Alexandria (destroyed in the Diaspora revolt, 115-117 CE). Early synagogues are known to have existed in various Mediterranean communities. By the end of the first century CE, wherever Jews lived they had their synagogues, and this was to prove vital to the people's success in surviving the destruction of the Temple and reconstructing Jewish life.
With the destruction of the Temple, the central role of the synagogue in Jewish life became firmly established. Certain Temple rituals were transferred to the synagogue for the sake of continuity, while others were specifically prohibited to emphasize the distinction between the two institutions. Prayer was considered a replacement for sacrifice, and prayer services were fixed to correspond to the regular communal offerings that could no longer be brought to the Temple. The forms and procedures of synagogue service established at that time have remained constant to this day. Unlike the Temple, where the ritual was carried out inside the Sanctuary by the priests, the only requirement for a synagogue service was a quorum (Minyan) of ten men, while any layman could lead the service. Thus the shift from Temple to synagogue represented a historic transformation in the role of the individual in the ritual. The phenomenology of man's relationship with God became more personalized, and less a matter of participation in the collective, although the element of communal worship in the synagogue prevented the complete individualization of the ritual. Inasmuch as Jewishness has ethnic, communal, and cultural dimensions not directly rooted in the liturgy, the synagogue, from its inception, assumed additional roles. Throughout history, it has continued to do so with varying emphases in different ages.
Both Halakhah and Aggadah ascribed unique importance to the synagogue. All synagogues are considered to partake of the holiness of the Temple. They were seen as extraterritorial parts of Erets Israel, and it was believed that at the End of Days all would be miraculously transported to the Holy Land (Meg. 29a). The halakhah circumscribed this holiness with specific regulations. Frivolity, gossip, and idle chatter were prohibited. One could not eat or sleep in the synagogue, although one could eat and sleep in a Bet Midrash (study hall). Thus synagogues were sometimes built with the intent of giving them the status of study halls in order to allow for these activities. Even in communities where men did not cover their heads at all times, it became customary to cover one's head in the synagogue (see Covering the Head). The holiness of the synagogue remains in force even when it is no longer in use, even when it is in ruin. The sale of a synagogue is permitted only under specific circumstances and generally requires consultation with a competent halakhic authority.
The oldest extant structures thought to have served as synagogues are located in Erets Israel, discovered in archeological investigations. They are found at Masada, in the Judean Desert, at Herodion to the south of Jerusalem, and at Gamla in the Golan Heights. They all predate the destruction of the Temple in 70 CE.
After the destruction of the Temple, synagogue construction was prohibited by the Romans. Subsequently, however, such activity resumed at an impressive pace. Over 100 synagogues dating from the third to the eighth century CE have been identified so far in Israel. The Jewish population had shifted largely to Galilee in the north, where the earliest concentration of structures is to be found. These adhere to several different prototypes. Most common is the basilica form, consisting of a long hall divided by two rows of pillars into a central nave and two aisles. Benches line the internal walls and the pillars probably supported a gallery; all are oriented towards Jerusalem. There is no definite evidence of separate sections for women in the synagogues of this period. Exteriors tend to be impressively constructed and ornamented, making the synagogue by far the most imposing structure in the settlement and whenever possible situated at the town's highest point or close to a water source. Interiors tend to be plain and unornamented, presumably to avoid distracting worshipers from the service. Among the finest examples of this type of synagogue are those at Baram in central Galilee and at Capernaum on the shores of the Sea of Galilee. At a particular stage, mosaic floors were introduced, first with only geometrical designs but later with representations of human and animal figures, depictions of Bible stories, the fruit of Erets Israel, Temple implements, signs of the Zodiac, and mythological figures borrowed from the general culture of the time. An impressive example of a mosaic floor is the synagogue discovered at Bet Alpha in the Jezreel Valley.
Remains of synagogues from this period have also been discovered in the Diaspora. Some of the earliest are located in Greece and Asia Minor. Among the most impressive are the synagogue at Sardis in western Turkey, a basilica some 400 feet long accommodating 1,000 worshipers; at Dura Europos, Syria (completed 244 CE), with four walls covered with 58 depictions of biblical scenes; and the synagogue in Hammam-Lif, Tunisia, whose central mosaic is now on display at the Brooklyn Museum in New York.
Middle Ages During the Middle Ages, the synagogue was the center of Jewish life, and Jews tried to live as close to one as possible. In many communities, it was constructed so as to be inconspicuous (in conformance with the regulations imposed on the community) in the heart of the Jewish quarter of the city. The synagogue was in use at all hours, many men attended services three times a day, and almost all of them came on Sabbaths and holidays. The atmosphere differed from the solemn decorum of the contemporary church. Prayers, with the exception of the silent Amidah, were recited in a loud voice, conversation, though not sanctioned, was not uncommon, children were given a fair amount of freedom. Worshipers felt that they were indeed carrying on a dialogue with the Creator, with whom their relationship was close and familiar. Relative to the surrounding society, the synagogue was a democratic institution. All were counted for the quorum, and being called to the Reading of the Law or leading the service was not conditional on any particular qualifications or status. Any congregant with a significant grievance could stop the service during the Sabbath Reading of the Law and prevent its resumption until satisfaction was obtained. All types of communal activity were pursued in the synagogue; the local rabbinical court might convene there, classes were conducted in the sanctuary or in an annex, solemn oaths and bans of Excommunication were pronounced there. Communal offices, the ritual bath (Mikveh), a library, ovens for the baking of unleavened bread, a hospice for travelers, a social hall, the Genizah, etc., might be located in synagogue rooms or adjacent structures.
Throughout the Middle Ages synagogue architecture continued to reflect prevalent styles, particularly influential being the Romanesque and Gothic. In this period, the use of representational art diminished. Special sections for women became standard. The reader's platform (Bimah) at the center of the synagogue took on greater significance and, together with the Ark on the wall facing Jerusalem, constituted the architectural and artistic focus. In Ashkenazi communities seating arrangements changed: the surrounding benches in the style of the ancient synagogues were abandoned for the more capacious arrangement of parallel seating facing forward. Since synagogues were not permitted to be taller than neighboring churches, many synagogues in Europe were constructed with floors below street level to obtain maximal internal height. Impressive synagogue structures were built by Spanish Jewry, showing the influence of Moorish architecture. With the expulsion of the Jews in 1492, all Spanish synagogues were confiscated and many were turned into churches. In Italy, from the 16th century, the building of synagogues was limited when the Jews were restricted to ghettoes. However, within their somber surroundings, magnificent synagogues, reflecting the achievements of the Renaissance, were constructed, as, for example, in Venice. In Rome, where 14 communities originally existed, the Jews were allowed only one synagogue building in the ghetto, but overcame the problem by constructing five synagogues within the structure.
A unique phenomenon in synagogue architecture was the wooden synagogues of Poland. These developed from the mid-17th century on and spread all over Eastern Europe. The interior decorations, covering every inch of wall and ceiling space, were a unique expression of Jewish folk art. Another special type of synagogue was the "fortress" building, enabling the Jews to defend themselves in the event of attack.
The synagogues of the Ḥasidic movement (from the 18th century) were small and informal (see Shtibl). There are generally no salaried positions in Ḥasidic synagogues; worshipers see to their administration and lead the services.
In Muslim lands, Jews had to face discriminatory laws ranging from periods of destruction of synagogues to the ordinance that they should not be higher than the lowest mosque in the town. Generally, the Jews built modest structures in the hope that their worship would not be disturbed, although regulations were sometimes circumvented and imposing synagogues were built (e.g., in Aleppo, Egypt, Djerba in Tunisia, and Baghdad). Multiple arks were a special feature of Oriental synagogues; triple arks were usual but sometimes there were even more, as synagogues often had many Scrolls of the Law. In some places, under the influence of Muslim customs, Jews removed their shoes before entering the prayer hall.
Modern Period
In the 19th century, major innovations were introduced by the Reform movement. Partially influenced by contemporary churches, Reform synagogues were usually large, imposing buildings, impressively equipped and furnished. They were referred to as temples. Organs were introduced and the women's section was abolished as men and women were seated together. Decorum and esthetic values were emphasized. Covering the head for both men and women was not required in most Reform congregations. The reader's platform was no longer in the center of the building, but contained within the space in front of the Ark (a change adopted in many Orthodox congregations).
In their turn, Orthodox congregations in Western countries also started to place more emphasis on decorum and esthetic considerations, and to construct more imposing synagogues. The design of these, however, was limited by the strictures of halakhah, such as the need to separate men and women. In Western countries, especially in North America, most synagogues today have reassumed the role of social community center as in the Middle Ages. They often have social halls for the celebrations of weddings, bar mitzvahs, etc.; religious schools, including Sunday and sometimes weekday afternoon classes; men's clubs and women's clubs (often called sisterhoods); and sponsor a wide range of educational, social, and recreational activities. Design of the buildings and their appurtenances is innovative and outstanding architects and artists, Jewish and non-Jewish, have been commissioned to beautify the synagogue. Recent developments include the founding of ḥavurot, or small groups who work together on developing their own ritual (see Havurah), and the participation of Women in all levels of synagogue activity in the non-Orthodox congregations.
In the Diaspora, synagogue membership is one of the chief means of Jewish identification and many Jews join synagogues even if they do not attend the services regularly. In Israel, on the other hand, Jewish identification may be achieved in numerous other ways and therefore the synagogue's role as a community center is minimal, and it is almost exclusively a place for prayer and religious study.