Thorstein Veblen

Thorstein Veblen

Institutional economics
Thorstein Bunde Veblen (1857-1929)
Born	July 30, 1857(1857-07-30) Cato, Wisconsin
Died	August 3, 1929(1929-08-03) (aged 72) Sand Hill Road, Menlo Park, California
Nationality	Norwegian-American
Field	evolutionary economics; sociology
Opposed	Karl Marx, Neoclassical economics, German historical school
Influences	Herbert Spencer,[1] William Graham Sumner, Lester F. Ward, William James, William McDougall, Georges Vacher de Lapouge,
Influenced	Wesley Clair Mitchell, Clarence Edwin Ayres, John Kenneth Galbraith, C. Wright Mills, Robert A. Brady, Harold Adams Innis, Edith Penrose, Jonathan Nitzan
Contributions	conspicuous consumption, penalty of taking the lead, ceremonial / instrumental dichotomy

Thorstein Bunde Veblen, born Torsten Bunde Veblen (July 30, 1857 – August 3, 1929) was an American economist and sociologist, and a leader of the so-called institutional economics movement. Besides his technical work he was a popular and witty critic of capitalism, as shown by his best known book The Theory of the Leisure Class (1899).

Veblen is famous in the history of economic thought for combining a Darwinian evolutionary perspective with his new institutionalist approach to economic analysis. He combined sociology with economics in his masterpiece, The Theory of the Leisure Class (1899), arguing there was a basic distinction between the productiveness of "industry," run by engineers, which manufactures goods, and the parasitism of "business," which exists only to make profits for a leisure class. The chief activity of the leisure class was "conspicuous consumption", and their economic contribution is "waste," activity that contributes nothing to productivity. The American economy was therefore made inefficient and corrupt by the businessmen, though he never made that claim explicit. Veblen believed that technological advances were the driving force behind cultural change, but, unlike many contemporaries, he refused to connect change with progress.

Although Veblen was sympathetic to state ownership of industry, he had a low opinion of workers and the labor movement and there is disagreement about the extent to which his views are compatible with Marxism 1. As a leading intellectual of the Progressive Era, his sweeping attack on production for profit and his stress on the wasteful role of consumption for status greatly influenced socialist thinkers and engineers seeking a non-Marxist critique of capitalism. Fine (1994) reports that economists at the time complained that his ideas, while brilliantly presented, were crude, gross, fuzzy, and imprecise; others complained he was a wacky eccentric. Scholars continue to debate exactly what he meant in his convoluted, ironic and satiric essays; he made heavy use of examples of primitive societies, but many examples were pure invention.^[2]

Biography

Veblen was born in Cato, Wisconsin, of Norwegian American parents who had immigrated from Norway. He spent the majority of his youth on his family farm in Nerstrand, Minnesota; the farmstead is now a National Historic Landmark. Although Norwegian was his first language, he learned English from both neighbors and at school, which he began at the age of 5.^[3] His family was highly successful and placed great emphasis on education and hard work, all of which undoubtedly contributed to his later scorn for what he termed “conspicuous consumption” and waste of the gilded age.^[4] These settlements were little Norways, oriented around the religious and cultural traditions of the old country . He broke away by attending a Yankee school, Carleton College Academy (now Carleton College) in Northfield, Minnesota; he was lucky to study with young John Bates Clark (1847–1938), who later became the nation's foremost economist and was a leader in the new field of neoclassical economics.

Veblen did graduate work at Johns Hopkins University under Charles Sanders Peirce, the founder of the pragmatist school in philosophy; he took his Ph.D. in 1884 at Yale University with a dissertation on "Ethical Grounds of a Doctrine of Retribution." He was a student of philosopher Noah Porter (1811–1892) and economist/sociologist William Graham Sumner (1840–1910). Perhaps the most important intellectual influences on Veblen were Charles Darwin and Herbert Spencer, whose work in the last half of the 19th century sparked an enormous interest in the evolutionary perspective on human societies.^[5]

Veblen married fellow Cornellian Ellen Rolfe in 1888; it was a very unhappy marriage that finally ended in divorce in 1911.^[6] He married secondly, Ann Bradley, in 1914. Veblen became the step father to her two girls, Becky and Ann. After his wife's death in 1920, Veblen became very active in the care of the girls. Becky went with him when he moved to California, and looked after him there. She was with him at his death in 1929.

Academic career

Upon graduation from Yale, Veblen was unable to obtain an academic job, partly due to prejudice against Norwegians,^[7] and partly because most universities considered him insufficiently educated in Christianity—most academics at the time held divinity degrees.^[8] Veblen returned to his family farm—ostensibly to recover from malaria—and spent six years there reading voluminously.^[9] In 1891 he left the farm, to study economics as a graduate student at Cornell University under James Laurence Laughlin.^[4]

He obtained his first academic appointment at the new University of Chicago, which overnight had become a world class university in many fields. He was promoted to assistant professor in 1900 and edited the prestigious Journal of Political Economy, while conversing with such intellectuals as John Dewey, Jane Addams and Franz Boas. He published two of his best known books, The Theory of the Leisure Class (1899), and The Theory of Business Enterprise (1904). The books made him famous overnight for their ridicule of businessmen. In 1906, he moved to Stanford University. He soon left, perhaps because of adultery, or because the faculty and administration distrusted a man they saw as a poor teacher, a nasty colleague and a political radical.^[10]

Veblen reflected many of his views in his personal habits. Veblen's house was often a mess, with unmade beds and dirty dishes; his clothes were often in disarray; he was an agnostic; and he tended to be blunt and rude while dealing with other people.^[11]

In 1911, Veblen joined the faculty of the University of Missouri, where he had support from Herbert Davenport, the head of the economics department. Veblen disliked the local town but remained until in 1918 he moved to New York to begin work as an editor of The Dial. In 1919, along with Charles A. Beard, James Harvey Robinson and John Dewey, he helped found the New School for Social Research (known today as The New School). From 1919 through 1926 Veblen continued to write and be involved in activities at The New School.^[4] The Engineers and the Price System was written during this period.^[12]

Veblen proposed a soviet of engineers in one chapter in The Engineers and the Price System.^[13] According to Yngve Ramstad,^[14] this work's view that engineers, not workers, would overthrow capitalism was a "novel view". Veblen invited Guido Marx to the New School to teach and to help organize a movement of engineers, by such as Morris Cooke; Henry Laurence Gantt, who had died shortly before; and Howard Scott. Cooke and Gantt were followers of Taylor's Scientific Management. Scott, who listed Veblen as on the temporary organizing committee of the Technical Alliance, perhaps without consulting Veblen or other listed members, later helped found the Technocracy movement.^[15][16] Veblen had a penchant for socialism and believed that technological developments would eventually lead toward a socialistic organization of economic affairs. However, his views regarding socialism and the nature of the evolutionary process of economics differed sharply from that of Karl Marx; while Marx saw socialism as the ultimate goal for civilization and saw the working-class as the group that would establish it, Veblen saw socialism as one intermediate phase in an ongoing evolutionary process in society that would be brought about by the natural decay of the business enterprise system and by the inventiveness of engineers.^[17] Daniel Bell sees an affinity between Veblen and the Technocracy movement.^[18] Janet Knoedler and Anne Mayhew^[19] demonstrate the significance of Veblen's association with these engineers, while arguing that his book was more a continuation of his previous ideas than the advocacy others see in it.

In 1927 Veblen returned to the property that he still owned in Palo Alto and died there in 1929.^[4] His death came less than three months before the momentous crash of the U.S. stock market, which heralded the Great Depression.

Veblen’s economics

Veblen and other American institutionalists were indebted to the German Historical School, especially Gustav von Schmoller, for the emphasis on historical fact, their empiricism and especially a broad, evolutionary framework of study.^[20][21] Veblen admired Schmoller but criticized some other leaders of the German school because of their over-reliance on descriptions, long displays of numerical data and narratives of industrial development came with no underlying economic theory. Veblen tried to use the same approach with his own theory added.^[22]

Veblen developed a 20th century evolutionary economics based upon Darwinian principles and new ideas emerging from anthropology, sociology, and psychology. Unlike the neoclassical economics that was emerging at the same time, Veblen described economic behavior as socially determined and saw economic organization as a process of ongoing evolution. Veblen strongly rejected any theory based on individual action or any theory highlighting any factor of an inner personal motivation. Such theories were according to him "unscientific." This evolution was driven by the human instincts of emulation, predation, workmanship, parental bent, and idle curiosity. Veblen wanted economists to grasp the effects of social and cultural change on economic changes. In The Theory of the Leisure Class, the instincts of emulation and predation play a major role. People, rich and poor alike, attempt to impress others and seek to gain advantage through what Veblen coined "conspicuous consumption" and the ability to engage in “conspicuous leisure.” In this work Veblen argued that consumption is used as a way to gain and signal status. Through "conspicuous consumption" often came "conspicuous waste," which Veblen detested.

In The Theory of Business Enterprise, which was published in 1904 during the height of American concern with the growth of business combinations and trusts, Veblen employed his evolutionary analysis to explain these new forms. He saw them as a consequence of the growth of industrial processes in a context of small business firms that had evolved earlier to organize craft production. The new industrial processes impelled integration and provided lucrative opportunities for those who managed it. What resulted was, as Veblen saw it, a conflict between businessmen and engineers, with businessmen representing the older order and engineers as the innovators of new ways of doing things. In combination with the tendencies described in The Theory of the Leisure Class, this conflict resulted in waste and “predation” that served to enhance the social status of those who could benefit from predatory claims to goods and services.

Veblen generalized the conflict between businessmen and engineers by saying that human society would always involve conflict between existing norms with vested interests and new norms developed out of an innate human tendency to manipulate and learn about the physical world in which we exist. He also generalized his model to include his theory of instincts, processes of evolution as absorbed from Sumner, as enhanced by his own reading of evolutionary science, and Pragmatic philosophy first learned from Peirce. The instinct of idle curiosity led humans to manipulate nature in new ways and this led to changes in what he called the material means of life. Because, as per the Pragmatists, our ideas about the world are a human construct rather than mirrors of reality, changing ways of manipulating nature lead to changing constructs and to changing notions of truth and authority as well as patterns of behavior (institutions). Societies and economies evolve as a consequence, but do so via a process of conflict between vested interests and older forms and the new. Veblen never wrote with any confidence that the new ways were better ways, but he was sure in the last three decades of his life that the American economy could have, in the absence of vested interests, produced more for more people. In the years just after World War I he looked to engineers to make the American economy more efficient.

In addition to The Theory of the Leisure Class and The Theory of Business Enterprise, Veblen’s monograph "Imperial Germany and the Industrial Revolution", and his many essays, including “Why is Economics Not an Evolutionary Science,” and “The Place of Science in Modern Civilization,” remain influential.

Veblen’s intellectual legacy

In spite of difficulties of sometimes archaic language, caused in large part by Veblen’s struggles with the terminology of unilinear evolution and of biological determination of social variation^{[citation needed]} that still dominated social thought when he began to write, Veblen’s work remains relevant, and not simply for the phrase “conspicuous consumption”. His evolutionary approach to the study of economic systems is once again in vogue and his model of recurring conflict between the existing order and new ways can be of great value in understanding the new global economy.

The handicap principle of evolutionary sexual selection is often compared to Veblen's “conspicuous consumption”.^[23]

Veblen, as noted, is regarded as one of the co-founders (with John R. Commons, Wesley C. Mitchell, and others) of the American school of institutional economics. Present-day practitioners who adhere to this school organise themselves in the Association for Evolutionary Economics (AFEE) and the Association for Institutional Economics (AFIT). AFEE gives an annual Veblen-Commons (see John R. Commons) award for work in Institutional Economics and publishes the Journal of Economic Issues. Some unaligned practitioners include theorists of the concept of "differential accumulation".^[24]

Veblen is cited in works of feminist economists.^[25]

Veblen’s work has also often been cited in treatments of American literature.^[26]

One of Veblen's Ph.D. students was George W. Stocking, Sr., a pioneer in the emerging field of industrial organization economics.

See also

• Affluenza
• Anti-consumerism
• Conspicuous consumption
• Downshifting
• Evolutionary economics
• Frugality
• Institutional economics
• Mottainai
• Over-consumption
• Simple living
• Technocracy Movement
• The Theory of the Leisure Class
• Thorstein Veblen Farmstead
• Veblen dichotomy
• Veblen good

Notes

Major works of Thorstein Veblen

Books

• full text of books and articles by Veblen, from McMaster University's Archive for the History of Economic Thought
• Theory of Business Enterprise, 1904.^{[dead link]}
• Theory of the Leisure Class: A Theory of Institutions excerpt and text search ; online edition complete
• The Theory of Business Enterprise excerpt and text search
• The Instincts of Worksmanship and the State of the Industrial Arts, 1914.
• The Engineers and the Price System excerpt and text search
• Imperial Germany and the Industrial Revolution, 1915.
• An Inquiry Into The Nature Of Peace And The Terms Of Its Perpetuation by Veblen at Project Gutenberg, pdf
• The Higher Learning In America: A Memorandum On the Conduct of Universities By Business Men , 1918.
• The Vested Interests and the Common Man, 1919., pdf
• The Instinct of Workmanship: And the State of the Industrial Arts (1922) complete text online
• What Veblen Taught: Selected Writings of Thorstein Veblen edited by Wesley C. Mitchell; (1936) online edition
• The Engineers and the Price System, 1921.^{[dead link]}
• Absentee Ownership and Business Enterprise in Recent Times: the case of America, 1923.
• Essays in Our Changing Order, 1927.

Articles

• "Kant's Critique of Judgement", 1884, Journal of Speculative Philosophy.
• "Some Neglected Points in the Theory of Socialism", 1891, Annals of AAPSS.
• "Bohm-Bawerk's Definition of Capital and the Source of Wages" , 1892, QJE.
• "The Overproduction Fallacy", 1892, QJE.
• "The Food Supply and the Price of Wheat", 1893, JPE.
• "The Army of the Commonweal", 1894, JPE.
• "The Economic Theory of Women's Dress", 1894, Popular Science Monthly.
• "Review of Karl Marx's Poverty of Philosophy", 1896, JPE.
• "Review of Werner Sombart's Sozialismus", 1897, JPE.
• "Review of Gustav Schmoller's Über einige Grundfragen der Sozialpolitik", 1898, JPE.
• "Review of Turgot's Reflections", 1898, JPE.
• "Why is Economics Not an Evolutionary Science?" , 1898, QJE.
• "The Beginnings of Ownership" , 1898, American Journal of Sociology.
• "The Instinct of Workmanship and the Irksomeness of Labor" , 1898, American Journal of Sociology.
• "The Barbarian Status of Women" , 1898, American Journal of Sociology.
• "The Preconceptions of Economic Science", (1899,1900), QJE. Part 1, Part 2, Part 3.
• "Industrial and Pecuniary Employments", 1901, Publications of the AEA. JSTOR
• "Gustav Schmoller's Economics", 1901, QJE.
• "Arts and Crafts", 1902, JPE.
• "Review of Werner Sombart's Der moderne Kapitalismus", 1903, JPE.
• "Review of J.A. Hobson's Imperialism", 1903, JPE.
• "An Early Experiment in Trusts", 1904, JPE.
• "Review of Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations", 1904, JPE.
• "Credit and Prices", 1905, JPE. JSTOR
• "The Place of Science in Modern Civilization", 1906, American J of Sociology. JSTOR
• "Professor Clark's Economics", 1906, QJE.
• "The Socialist Economics of Karl Marx and His Followers", (1906,1907), QJE.
• "Fisher's Capital and Income" , 1907, Political Science Quarterly.
• "The Evolution of the Scientific Point of View", 1908, University of California Chronicle.
• "On the Nature of Capital", 1908, QJE. JSTOR
• "Fisher's Rate of Interest" , 1909, Political Science Quarterly.
• "The Limitations of Marginal Utility" , 1909, JPE.
• "Christian Morals and the Competitive System", 1910, International J of Ethics. JSTOR
• "The Mutation Theory and the Blond Race", 1913, Journal of Race Development.
• "The Blond Race and the Aryan Culture", 1913, Univ of Missouri Bulletin
• "The Opportunity of Japan", 1915, Journal of Race Development.
• "On the General Principles of a Policy of Reconstruction", 1918, J of the National Institute of Social Sciences.
• "Passing of National Frontiers", 1918, Dial.
• "Menial Servants during the Period of War", 1918, Public.
• "Farm Labor for the Period of War", 1918, Public.
• "The War and Higher Learning", 1918, Dial.
• "The Modern Point of View and the New Order", 1918, Dial.
• "The Intellectual Pre-Eminence of Jews in Modern Europe", 1919, Political Science Quarterly. JSTOR
• "On the Nature and Uses of Sabotage", 1919, Dial.
• "Bolshevism is a Menace to the Vested Interests", 1919, Dial.
• "Peace", 1919, Dial.
• "The Captains of Finance and the Engineers", 1919, Dial.
• "The Industrial System and the Captains of Industry", 1919, Dial.
• The Place of Science in Modern Civilization and other essays, 1919., also at Google Books
• "Review of J.M.Keynes's Economic Consequences of the Peace , 1920, Political Science Quarterly. JSTOR
• "Economic theory in the Calculable Future", 1925, AER. JSTOR
• "Introduction" in The Laxdaela Saga, 1925.

Secondary sources

• Adorno, Theodor W. 1967. "Prisms." The MIT Press: Cambridge, MA.
• Banta, Martha. Taylored Lives: Narrative Production in the Age of Taylor, Veblen, and Ford. 1993. 431 pp.
• Bartley, Russel H. 1997. "In Search of Thorstein Veblen: Further Inquiries into His Life and Work." International Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society.11(January):129-173.
• Brette, Olivier. "Thorstein Veblen's Theory of Institutional Change: Beyond Technological Determinism." European Journal of the History of Economic Thought 2003 10(3): 455-477. Issn: 0967-2567 Fulltext: Ebsco
• Diggins, John Patrick. Thorstein Veblen (2nd ed. 1999) excerpt and text search; the first edition was titled The Bard of Savagery: Thorstein Veblen and Modern Social Theory. (1978),
• Dorfman, Joseph. Thorstein Veblen and His America (1934), the standard biography, though it exaggerates Veblen's isolation
• Dowd, Douglas Fitzgerald. Thorstein Veblen (2000) excerpt and text search
• Dugger, William M. 2006. "Veblen's Radical Theory of Social Evolution." Journal of Economic Issues.40(September):651-72.
• Eby, Clare Virginia. "Thorstein Veblen and the Rhetoric of Authority." American Quarterly 1994 46(2): 139-173. Issn: 0003-0678 Fulltext: in Jstor
• Edgell, Stephen. Veblen in Perspective: His Life and Thought. M. E. Sharpe, 2001. 207 pp.
• Eff, E. Anthon. 1989. "History of Thought as Ceremonial Genealogy: The Neglected Influence of Herbert Spencer on Thorstein Veblen." Journal of Economic Issues. 23 (September): 689-716.
• Hodgson, Geoffrey M. 1998. "On the Evolution of Thorstein Veblen's Evolutionary Economics" in Cambridge Journal of Economics. 22(4):415-431.
• Hodgson, Geoffrey M. 2004 The Evolution of Institutional Economics: Agency, Structure and Darwinism in American Institutionalism. Routledge: London and New York.
• Jorgensen, Elizabeth Watkins and Henry Irvin Jorgensen. 1999, Thorstein Veblen: Victorian Firebrand, M.E. Sharpe. ISBN 0-7656-0258-X
• Knoedler, Janet T. 1997. "Veblen and Technical Efficiency." Journal of Economic Issues. 31(?):???-???.
• Knoedler, Janet and Mayhew, Anne. "Thorstein Veblen and the Engineers: a Reinterpretation." History of Political Economy 1999 31(2): 255-272. Issn: 0018-2702
• McCormick, Ken. 2006. "Veblen in Plain English," Cambria Press. ISBN 0-9773567-6-0
• Maynard, Raymond Anthony. "Thorstein Veblen on Culture, Biology, and Evolution." PhD dissertation U. of Tennessee 2000. 290 pp. DAI 2000 61(6A): 2407-A. DA9973476 Fulltext: ProQuest Dissertations & Theses
• Riesman, David. 1960. Thorstein Veblen: A Critical Interpretation. Charles Scribner's Sons.
• Shannon, Christopher Conspicuous Criticism: Tradition, the Individual and Culture in American Social Thought, from Veblen to Mills (1996) 211 pp.
• Thomas, Marty Jean. "Thorstein Veblen's Theory of Leisure as Interpreted by Veblen Scholars." PhD dissertation Pennsylvania State U. 1999. 183 pp. DAI 2000 61(1): 393-A. DA9960667 Fulltext: ProQuest Dissertations & Theses
• Tilman, Rick. 1992. Thorstein Veblen and His Critics, 1891-1963. Princeton University Press. ISBN 0-691-04286-1
• Tilman, Rick. 1996. The Intellectual Legacy of Thorstein Veblen: Unresolved Issues.Greenwood Press. ISBN 0-313-29946-3.
• Vian, Francesca Lidia, "Ithaca transfer: Veblen and the historical profession," History of European Ideas, 35,1 (2009), 38-61.
• Wood, John Cunningham, ed. Thorstein Veblen: Critical Assessments (1991) excerpts and text search
• Yonay, Yuval P. The Struggle over the Soul of Economics: Institutionalist and Neoclassical Economists in America Between the Wars. Princeton U. Press, 1998. 290 pp.

External links

• Veblen’s works, including The Theory of the Leisure Class, The Theory of Business Enterprise, and many of his best articles are available from these sites:
  • Veblen page at Archive for the History of Economic Thought, McMaster University
    • T.Veblen: Why is Economics Not an Evolutionary Science?
    • T.Veblen: The Beginning of Ownership
    • T.Veblen: Theory of Business Enterprise
    • T.Veblen: The Engineers and the price system
• Association for Evolutionary Economics at www.orgs.bucknell.edu and
• http://cepa.newschool.edu/het.
• Works by Thorstein Veblen at Project Gutenberg
  • Project Gutenberg e-text of The Theory of the Leisure Class
  • Project Gutenberg e-text of An Inquiry into the Nature of Peace and the Terms of its Perpetuation
• Theory of the Leisure Class from American Studies at the University of Virginia
• searchable facsimile An inquiry into the nature of peace and the terms of its perpetuation. Publisher: New York, B.W. Huebsch, 1919
• searchable facsimile The place of science in modern civilisation and other essays. Publisher: New York, B.W. Huebsch, 1919
• searchable facsimile The Vested Interests and the Common Man ("The modern point of view and the new order"). Publisher: New York, B.W. Huebsch, 1919
• e-texts -- The Veblenite -- (Complete Works, as far as not copyright-protected, biography, bibliography and related materials)
  • Books and Translations [2]
  • Essays in Economics [3]
  • War Essays, Memoranda, Suggestions [4]
  • Miscellaneous Papers, Reviews [5]
• Thorstein Veblen on the propaganda of the faith
• Thorstein Veblen: The Intellectual Pre-eminence of Jews in Modern Europe
• The Veblen Farmstead where Thorstein Veblen grew up is listed as a National Historical Landmark
• Veblen's summer cabin on Washington Island Wisconsin, where he did much of his writing, is being restored.
• Thorstein Veblen's Web by Harrison Mujica-Jenkins at latephilosophers.com