No he cannot, this was confirmed by Rockstar.
John Westland Marston died in 1890.
John Marston was born on October 7, 1576.
John Marston was born on October 7, 1576.
John Marston - poet - was born in 1576.
John Westland Marston died in 1890.
John Westland Marston was born in 1819.
John Marston - cricketer - died in 1938.
John Marston - cricketer - was born in 1893.
No. It is scripted into the game that John Marston dies and you continue to play as his son, Jack.
Rob Wheithoff is the voice of the main character, John Marston.
John Marston - sailor - died on 1885-04-17.
John Marston - sailor - was born on 1795-06-12.