0
Compare the story of the conquest of Canaan in Joshua with the story told in Judges?
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
First of all, the primary problem with Joshua's conquest story is that few of the cities described show any signs of having been occupied at the time the Israelites appeared in the country. Joshua is described in the Book of Joshua as a military genius who led the Hebrews into the Promised Land. Certainly, the tactic used to entice the king of Ai to leave the city undefended, is an example of military genius - except that there was no city of Ai at that time. And, as Avner says of Jericho, "We have a story that was added later."
There are also internal inconsistencies in the Book of Joshua. Joshua 10:33 says that King Horam of Gezer came up to help Lachish; and Joshua struck him and his people, leaving him no survivors, then Joshua 16:10 talks about 'the Canaanites who lived in Gezer'.
The Books of Joshua are totally inconsistent in some areas when they describe the glorious conquests of the past. Joshua 10:36-37 reports that Joshua went up with all Israel to Hebron, took it and killed every person in it, leaving no one remaining, but Judges 1:10 also claims that Judah went against the Canaanites who lived in Hebron.
Joshua 10:38-39 reports the conquest of Debir, when they 'utterly destroyed every person in it' and left no one remaining, but Judges 1:11-13 reports that Debir was not even captured until after Joshua was dead.
There is no archaeological record to support the existence of the biblical patriarchs or even the period of the Judges. There is every reason to believe that both accounts, written many centuries after the events they claim to describe, are merely intended to provide a glorious past for a minor nation of the Levant region.
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What period follows the Pentateuch?
Immediately following the Pentateuch is the partial conquest of Canaan, as described in the book of Joshua. The period of the Judges follows after this.
What people came after Moses in the Bible?
Joshua, the Judges, Samuel, King Saul, King David. For a full timeline, see the attached Related Link.
What Books in the Bible can you find the conquest of Canaan?
The conquest of Canaan is primarily described in the books of Joshua and Judges in the Bible. These books detail the Israelites' military campaigns led by Joshua to capture the land of Canaan, as well as the subsequent period of settlement and conflict under the leadership of various judges.
During the 200 years after returning to canaan the isrealites were led by?
Joshua, and then the Judges. Total: about 385 years.
What contribution did the Jews make in the Book of Joshua?
There were two early Hebrew kingdoms, Israel in the north, and Judah in the south. The Book of Joshua is the epic story of the conquest of Canaan, told from the viewpoint of Israel. In this story, Caleb and the people of Judah only played a minor role. Chapter 1 of the Book of Judges is the story of the conquest of Canaan told from the viewpoint of the people of Judah, who later became known as the Jews, although this story is in a much briefer form than the Book of Joshua. In this account, the tribe of Judah was given the lead role in the conquest, and the legendary military hero Caleb was the leader of the conquest. So, the tribe of Judah, the ancestors of the Jewish people, was portrayed as playing a minor role in the Book of Joshua.
Is Barack in the book of judges?
No, Barack is not mentioned in the Book of Judges in the Bible. The Book of Judges primarily focuses on the period of time between the conquest of Canaan and the establishment of the monarchy in ancient Israel.
What book tells the story of the Israelites conquering Canaan?
The Book of Joshua talks of the conquest of the land of the Canaanites by the Israelites under the leadership of Joshua. The Book of Judges contains a fragmentary account of the conquest of the same cities by the tribe of Judah under the leadership of Caleb, because the Lord said that the people of Judah would conquer the Canaanites. There seem to have been two early traditions about the conquest of Canaan, the Joshua one passed on in the northern kingdom of Israel and the Caleb one passed on in the southern kingdom of Judah. Probably only a small part of the Judahite tradition has been preserved.
Who led the Israelites in conquering Canaan?
The Book of Joshua presents the perspective of the northern kingdom of Israel, of the legendary conquest of the Promised Land by its hero Joshua. Caleb is mentioned, but only in a minor role, and the Book of Joshua is an epic tale of the conquest of Canaan by Joshua.The Book of Judges, chapter 1, gives the perspective of the southern kingdom of Judah, of the same conquest by its hero Caleb. Joshua is mentioned soon after Caleb completes his conquest, but this passage is only a duplicate of a similar passage from the Book of Joshua.Both books are now known to have been written during the seventh century BCE, some time after the destruction of Israel by the Assyrians, by an anonymous source referred to as the Deuteronomist. Attempting to keep alive the traditions of Israel, the Deuteronomist typically retained enough of the traditions of both kingdoms to be credible from both perspectives, in spite of some unavoidable contradictions. A descendant of a refugee from Israel would be gratified to find the Israelite story of the glorious military conquest in the Book of Joshua, and be no more than a little puzzled by the brief account in Judges. A native Judahite could read the Book of Exodus followed immediately by the account in the Book of Judges and be similarly gratified.
What is the book judges?
The period beginning after the conquest of the Land of Israel and Joshua's death until the birth of Samuel, who appointed the first king.
Where was the Book of Joshua composed?
Approximately eighty per cent of scholars are said to agree that that the Conquest of the Land did not take place as described in Joshua, so there is a near-consensus that the book could not have been written as an accurate history by a participant in that history.Instead, scholars believe that the Book of Joshua was written by the 'D' (Deuteronomist) source as part of the Deuteronomic history - which includes the Books of Joshua, Judges, 1 and 2 Samuel and 1 and 2 Kings, and covers the assumed conquest of Canaan through to the end of the kingdom of Judah and the beginning of the Babylonian Exile. TheDeuteronomist composed the history in Jerusalem during the reign of King Josiah.
When was Joshua Judges Ruth created?
Joshua Judges Ruth was created on 1992-03-31.
What book comes after Joshua?
The book that comes after Joshua in the Old Testament is the Book of Judges. It tells the story of the Israelites' struggle for survival after Joshua's leadership.
