answersLogoWhite

0

Do you think muhammad should have named a successor?

Updated: 2/3/2021
User Avatar

Wiki User

12y ago

Best Answer

i think he should

User Avatar

Wiki User

12y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Do you think muhammad should have named a successor?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

Meaning of successor in the islanic way?

I think the successor is called a caliph which is a title taken by Islamic rulers such as the Turkish sultans that asserts religious authority to rule, derived from that of Muhammad. I hope this helps you.


What did Muhammad think wealthy town leaders should do?

Ikd


Are there any animals with no name?

No there are not any animals that have not been named. When people find them, they should be named...I think! No there are not any animals that have not been named. When people find them, they should be named...I think!


Do you think Muhammad should have named a successor why or why not?

Answer 1No,The reasons are:All sayings and practices of prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him); that is called Sunnah; are under guidance and commands of God. So, I don't agree with the question itself. Prophet Muhammad is not a normal leader or chairman to be criticized and judged by people on his sayings and doings.If prophet Muhammad named his successor, each successor will name the one following him. Islam would described as a system of dictatorship after that and would be accused of not adopting democracy. Refer to the questions below.Qur'an calls for democracy under the name of consultation "Shoura", so how do you expect prophet Muhammad will violate the Qur'an rules and commands. Qur'an says (English meaning translation):"And those who have responded to their lord and established prayer and whose affair is [determined by] consultation among themselves, and from what We have provided them, they spend." (42:38)"Answer 2The question of "should" appears at first to throw an interesting wrench into the equation. If it is excised, (i.e. Do you think that Mohammed had named a successor?), this becomes a question strictly of Sunni vs. Shiite understandings of Imamat or Leadership. The Sunni opinion is well described in Answer 1, while the Shiite opinion would be that at Ghadir, Mohammed did name 'Ali as his successor because of Divine Revelation.The changes that result from adding the "should" are slight. As Answer 1 notes, the Sunni position is that creating a direct line of succession from one leader to another would create at its best a benign dictatorship and at worst a tyrannical monarchy. Either way, there would be no democracy and the will of the people would be stifled by present authority. The Shiites do not disagree with this assertion and say that it would be quite correct and proper that there is no real democracy in Islamic leadership. However, since God has chosen these individuals and the succession is divinely made, these leaders would be perfect individuals. (The Fourteen Infallibles are the extension of this view.) Therefore, there should be no innate problem with their leadership since they are ruling as God would wish and anyone who opposes this mentality is themselves unrighteous, even if this group of unrighteous individuals is the majority. (The results of such belief are quite evident in the case of the Islamic Republic of Iran.)


Should trusts be named after the trustees?

A trust can be named almost any name the trustor can think of.


Should bob be an actual name?

well i think if you want your baby to be named bob i think it should be an accountant or have a desk job.


Who is more famous Lady Gaga or Prophet Muhammad?

Prophet Muhammad i think


What should i think of if i come accross someone named Galil?

What you should do is become friends with them so yall can be more to be honest because most people named that be fine asf and i think theres only one person named that so this is special for someone


What is the Earth's nickname?

The Blue Planet!!


What should I name my city Moonfall or Riverwood?

I think it should be named moonfall. It sounds mystifying and intriguing ;)


What webkinz do you think should named Freddy?

you should name the golden retreiver because the name will suit it


Why the name for mission carmel?

Because the founder decided it should be named that. I think.