as long as its a random, clear way of choosing a card... it can be done that way.
example: you choose the card
example two: your opponent shuffles the cards in their hand, not (into the deck) (without looking).. and they pick a card...
the text never states who picks it so you can use either one of these examples
i used the text of the "spirit reaper" card i have #PGD-026
Yes, in Magic: The Gathering (MTG), players can choose to discard cards at will during certain phases of the game, such as during their own discard phase or as a cost for certain card abilities.
They choose you randomly.
In Magic: The Gathering, the discard a card mechanic requires a player to choose and remove a card from their hand, placing it into their graveyard. This can disrupt an opponent's strategy by removing key cards from their hand. It also adds a strategic element for the player using the mechanic, as they must decide which card to discard based on the current game situation. Overall, the discard a card mechanic can influence gameplay by limiting options for both players and shaping the flow of the game.
They choose it randomly
um...
You cannot simply choose to discard a card from hand, voluntarily, or send cards from the field. You can only do so when allowed to do so for a cost, or instructed to by an effect or game mechanic.
if you choose turtwig as your starter than your opponent will have chimchar if you chose piplup then your opponent will have turtwig and if you chose chimchar than your opponent will have piplup.
There are but you can't choose your server it gets randomly choosen.
You can't. The arena is chosen randomly
15
If you foul, your opponent can make you retake a shot. You cannot choose to retake a shot yourself if you miss or don't like your shot.If you foul, your opponent can make you retake a shot. You cannot choose to retake a shot yourself if you miss or don't like your shot.If you foul, your opponent can make you retake a shot. You cannot choose to retake a shot yourself if you miss or don't like your shot.If you foul, your opponent can make you retake a shot. You cannot choose to retake a shot yourself if you miss or don't like your shot.If you foul, your opponent can make you retake a shot. You cannot choose to retake a shot yourself if you miss or don't like your shot.If you foul, your opponent can make you retake a shot. You cannot choose to retake a shot yourself if you miss or don't like your shot.If you foul, your opponent can make you retake a shot. You cannot choose to retake a shot yourself if you miss or don't like your shot.If you foul, your opponent can make you retake a shot. You cannot choose to retake a shot yourself if you miss or don't like your shot.If you foul, your opponent can make you retake a shot. You cannot choose to retake a shot yourself if you miss or don't like your shot.If you foul, your opponent can make you retake a shot. You cannot choose to retake a shot yourself if you miss or don't like your shot.If you foul, your opponent can make you retake a shot. You cannot choose to retake a shot yourself if you miss or don't like your shot.
The mechanic of discarding cards in Magic: The Gathering affects gameplay strategies by allowing players to control their hand size, manipulate their resources, and disrupt their opponent's plans. Players must carefully choose which cards to discard to maximize their chances of winning.