answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

Historians know about the Xia dynasty because of stories. Archaeologists have not yet found evidence of this dynasty, so many believe that it never existed. Chinese people honor these stories, though.

User Avatar

Wiki User

14y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

Wiki User

11y ago

western historians deny its existence because they want to see text from that era to prove they could record their history; today, people can only find Xia dynasty from later historical records and limited archaeological discoveries.

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

Wiki User

11y ago

because people told stories about how the first dynasty was the XIA DYNASTY

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Why historians are not sure if xia dynasty existed?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about General History

What was the third dynasty of china?

It is hard to say because there is slim evidence that there that around 2000 B.C., a dynasty called the Xia (pronounced Syah) existed. Some historians do not believe this dynasty was ever real and only a myth. I think the Xia dynasty was real so speaking from my point of view, the Qin (pronounced Chin) dynasty was the fourth. But if you don't think the Xia dynasty existed than the Han dynasty is the fourth.


What is the first Chinese Dynasty with written records?

According to some of the earliest records of the Shang, the first dynasty was the Xia dynasty. But some historians believe this dynasty is a myth. I think the Xia dynasty really was an existent dynasty however so I would say it is the earliest. It started at about 2000 B.C. and ended at about 1600 B.C.


Which legendary dynasty was started by Yu?

The Xia dynasty was started by Yu the Great.


How do historians know about the xia dynasty?

"For many years, the Xia Dynasty was thought to be a part of a myth that the Chinese tell as part of their history. The Xia Dynasty was in oral histories, but no archaeological evidence was found of it until 1959. Excavations at Erlitous, in the city of Yanshi, uncovered what was most likely a capital of the Xia Dynasty. The site showed that the people were direct ancestors of the Lungshan and were predecessors of the Shang. Radiocarbon dates from this site indicate that they existed from 2100 to 1800 B.C. Despite this new archaeological evidence of the Xia, they are not universally accepted as a true dynasty. "The Xia were agrarian people, with bronze weapons and pottery. The ruling families used elaborate and dramatic rituals to confirm their power to govern. The rulers often acted as shamans, communicating with spirits for help and guidance."


Who was the leader of the xia dynasty?

King yu was the first King/Empoeror of the xia Dynasty

Related questions

What was the third dynasty of china?

It is hard to say because there is slim evidence that there that around 2000 B.C., a dynasty called the Xia (pronounced Syah) existed. Some historians do not believe this dynasty was ever real and only a myth. I think the Xia dynasty was real so speaking from my point of view, the Qin (pronounced Chin) dynasty was the fourth. But if you don't think the Xia dynasty existed than the Han dynasty is the fourth.


What is the first Chinese Dynasty with written records?

According to some of the earliest records of the Shang, the first dynasty was the Xia dynasty. But some historians believe this dynasty is a myth. I think the Xia dynasty really was an existent dynasty however so I would say it is the earliest. It started at about 2000 B.C. and ended at about 1600 B.C.


Why were the archaeaological discoveries at erltitou and anyang important and how did they change western historians views of the xia and shang dynasties?

NOT true. The Shang Dynasty (1600-1046 BC) came immediately after the Xia Dynasty


Historians of china have traditionally dated the beginning of chinease civilization to be?

founding of the xia dynasty ,about which little is known.


Historians of china have traditionally dated the beginning of chinease civilzation to be?

founding of the xia dynasty ,about which little is known.


Which legendary first dynasty left no written records behind?

No written records have been found from the Xia dynasty and there is dispute as to whether this legendary dynasty existed.


Which legendary dynasty was started by Yu?

The Xia dynasty was started by Yu the Great.


Historians of china have traditionally dated the beginning of Chinese civilization to be?

C. the founding of the Xia dynasty, about which little is known. :)


How do historians know about the xia dynasty?

"For many years, the Xia Dynasty was thought to be a part of a myth that the Chinese tell as part of their history. The Xia Dynasty was in oral histories, but no archaeological evidence was found of it until 1959. Excavations at Erlitous, in the city of Yanshi, uncovered what was most likely a capital of the Xia Dynasty. The site showed that the people were direct ancestors of the Lungshan and were predecessors of the Shang. Radiocarbon dates from this site indicate that they existed from 2100 to 1800 B.C. Despite this new archaeological evidence of the Xia, they are not universally accepted as a true dynasty. "The Xia were agrarian people, with bronze weapons and pottery. The ruling families used elaborate and dramatic rituals to confirm their power to govern. The rulers often acted as shamans, communicating with spirits for help and guidance."


Who was the leader of the xia dynasty?

King yu was the first King/Empoeror of the xia Dynasty


The Shang Dynasty followed which dynasty?

The Shang dynasty came after the Xia dynasty. The Xia dynasty was once thought to be a myth but then they found evidence to support that it really did exist.


When did the xia dynasty rule china?

The Xia dynasty lasted from ca. 2070 BC-ca. 1600 BC.