I think you give it the milk. When you give it the milk it will follow you.
Good luck!:) hope this helps!
The cat (Whiskers) belongs to the woman at Charlie's Carrot Surplus (hardware store).
Whiskers, the lost cat, is gray.
Take it back to its owner at Charlie's Carrot Surplus.
The waitress at the Carrot Diner will fill the bowl for you.
On 24 Carrot Island you don't get a wrench. But you do get a pryer thingy. You get that by returning the hardware lady's cat to her.
The cat belongs to the woman at Charlie's Carrot Surplus, and is hiding at the farmhouse. You will receive a reward for the cat's return. (see related question)
Return the missing cat to her owner at Charlie's Carrot Surplus and you will receive a crowbar, which will come in handy when you next travel to the Carrot Cake Factory.
The owner is in Charlie's Carrot Surplus store. (We do not learn if the woman is actually Charlie.) Once you return her cat, she will give you a crowbar.
You have to find the lady in Charlie's Carrot Surplus store's cat, who is in the bathtub in the abandoned house at the carrot farm. To get the cat you have to get the bowl in the house and then ask the waitress in the Carrot Diner for milk and chase the cat down to the milk.
You don't. He is just there to say "meow." (Because a cat figured so prominently in 24 Carrot island, many players have assumed that the cat has some important role on Spy island, but it does not.)
~there isno cat in early poptropica. that was your mistake!~but there is a cat in 24 carrot, spy island, and haunted house.
Take the bowl to the diner and fill it with milk.