The coconut milk is from the vendor on Main Street. The other two items (the bone and the key ingredient) are in the underground ruins.
(see related question)
To get the ingredients on shark tooth island,you must open the door in the cave,get the 2 ingredients and go back to the native islander and give him the stuff
you give a poison coconut to the shark after you got all the ingredients.
There is no honey on Shark Tooth Island. The three ingredients you need are coconut milk, a creature bone, and the green Key Ingredient. (see related question)
click on the hawiian picking out earwax
The mission on Shark Tooth Island is to rescue the boy who is stranded in an island in Booga Bay (far right of the island) by the giant shark Booga. The solution is to gather the ingredients for a sleeping potion, to be mixed by the island's medicine man. (see related question)
All you have to do is go to the medicine man, and just talk to him. Then he will know that you will have all of the ingredients.
You wear a grass skirt from a stall
Shark tooth island is when you have to to save people from a giant shark
It doesn't get full. You collect three ingredients and mix them to make a sleeping potion for the shark. (see related question)
Gather the ingredients to mix a sleeping potion, which you use on the giant shark named Booga which is terrorizing the waters around Shark Tooth Island. Professor Hammerhead, a shark researcher, has been trapped on a small island by the shark. Use his research to enter the underground ruins and discover the secret to saving him.
There are no mermaids in Shark Tooth island, you do go into the ocean
You collect three ingredients, mix a sleeping potion, and put him to sleep. (for the solution, see the related question)