You can propose to Toby while he's walking from his home to On the Hook
on a sunny morning. Other times and places may be possible, but this has
been confirmed to work.
Renee will marry the male MC or Toby.
In Maple Lake District near Toby's house.
Here is the list of rival couples in Harvest Moon: Tree of Tranquility. Jin can marry Anissa Toby can marry Renee Julius can marry Candace Chase can marry Maya Calvin can marry Phoebe
If your asking about Rock Lobster you can get them on Gull Island. (Then you give the rock lobster to Toby so you can marry him)
Darens is by toby's house it by a little lake in maple district its a star shaped flower thats blue
He will ask for a Rock Lobster. You can catch it fishing off Gull Island in Winter and Spring.
When you complete all his heart events Hamilton will apear, talk to you about the blue bird and feather, and after a few weeks you will get a cutscene.
You go to the beach by the Tailors and you get a cutscene with Toby. He says he had an exta fishing rod and gives it to you. I'm not sure when, All I know is it was to be sunny.
just give Toby alot of fish or dishes that have fish in it daily then he'll ask you to find this rocky lobster. This lobster is hard to find because it's on gull islands you have to make the first rainbow to get there.
you have to be in a particular date time and place these i do not no as im playing a girl and am married to toby.
He likes Lavenders, Pansies, Cosmos, and Snowdrop Flowers.
Gill will only marry the female main character. He will never marry anyone else. Julius, Chase, Jin, Toby, and Calvin can marry a different girl but Owen, Luke, and Gill do not have anyone else that they will marry.