answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

Both groups included large numbers of members from the third estate.

User Avatar

Helga Cruickshank

Lvl 13
βˆ™ 2y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: How is national Assembly similar to the estates general?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about General History

Why did king Philip iv organize the estates general?

When Philip IV of France needed help in his struggle with the pope in 1302, he called together representatives of the nobles, of the clergy, and of the townspeople of France the three estates, or classes in order to gain their aid. Although there had been meetings of similar groups in the preceding ten years, this date may be taken as the first meeting of the Estates-General of France. In the beginning it corresponded roughly to the Parliament of England, which was then less than 50 years old. The French monarchy was more firmly fixed in power by the unfailing succession of the Capetian line, and the Estates-General never gained the right to make laws as the English Parliament did. During the Hundred Years' War, from 1337 to 1453, the Estates-General could frequently force the king to do as it wished by refusing him money to carry on the struggle, but it sometimes lost public respect by favoring civil strife or by allying itself with the English invaders. In 1439, near the close of the war, it granted a land tax, the taille, from which the nobles were exempted. Since there was no opposition when the king chose to consider such grants to be permanent, the king became independent. He had plenty of revenue, he had a standing army, he dominated the clergy and dispensed favors to the nobles, and so had little need of the Estates-General. For 174 years, beginning in 1614, the representatives of the three estates were not summoned to consider the affairs of the kingdom. In 1788, however, the treasury was empty, and Louis XVI was forced to call this almost forgotten body together again. When it met on May 5, 1789, the representatives of the third estate, equal in numbers to the other two, refused to vote according to the old method by which each estate cast one vote. They insisted on voting as individuals and declared themselves the National Assembly. On June 20, 1789, they took the famous "Tennis Court" oath not to disperse until they had given France a constitution. This bold attitude showed clearly that a revolution was at hand (see French Revolution). The name estates-general was not uncommon in medieval Europe. In Spain there were four estates, or classes, in the assembly. In The Netherlands the name States-General is still applied to the legislative body of that kingdom. It is composed of two houses the upper, elected by the provincial assemblies, and the lower, chosen by the people. Excerpted from Compton's Interactive Encyclopedia (1996). Compton's New Media. http://www2.fultonschools.org/teacher/bell/French%20History%20Reading/estates.pdf


What countries a has classes called estates?

The term "estates" is most frequently applied to the class distinctions of the kingdom of France, beginning in the Middle Ages. Similar stratification occurred during the histories of Sweden and Finland.


What is the new york state assembly similar to?

The New York State Assembly is similar to the lower house of the legislative branch in other states, such as the State House of Representatives. It is responsible for creating and passing laws, as well as representing and advocating for the interests of their constituents.


What system did slaves organize into work crews who specialized tasks?

Slaves organized into something that was similar to an assembly line. They did this long before the assembly lines were used to create vehicles.


Did the national constitution of 1791 abolish the monarchy?

No, the national constitution of 1791 did not abolish the monarchy. It established a constitutional monarchy in France, limiting the powers of the king and granting significant power to the Legislative Assembly. However, the events of the French Revolution eventually led to the abolition of the monarchy in 1792.

Related questions

Who is French Estates General most similar to?

English house of Commons


What is the french estates general much similar to?

English House of Commons (C) F e2020, you burnout.


How are the us congress and Ohio general assembly similar?

they are al around different


What type of government body is similar to the General Assembly in the United Nations?

Any Legislative branch - a Parliament, Senate...


How is the general assembly different from the US congress?

Congress is for the entire U.S., while the VA General Assembly is for only one state. The VA General Assembly oversees the state budget while Cogress oversees the federal budget The VA General Assembly meets annually, while Congress meets throughout the year The VA General Assembly redistricts the state’s congressional and state legislative districts, while Congress does not


What is the state of the address?

When the governor of a state addresses the general assembly of that state concerning the economic and social status of the state. It is similar to the President of the United States addressing the U.S. congress.


Why did king Philip iv organize the estates general?

When Philip IV of France needed help in his struggle with the pope in 1302, he called together representatives of the nobles, of the clergy, and of the townspeople of France the three estates, or classes in order to gain their aid. Although there had been meetings of similar groups in the preceding ten years, this date may be taken as the first meeting of the Estates-General of France. In the beginning it corresponded roughly to the Parliament of England, which was then less than 50 years old. The French monarchy was more firmly fixed in power by the unfailing succession of the Capetian line, and the Estates-General never gained the right to make laws as the English Parliament did. During the Hundred Years' War, from 1337 to 1453, the Estates-General could frequently force the king to do as it wished by refusing him money to carry on the struggle, but it sometimes lost public respect by favoring civil strife or by allying itself with the English invaders. In 1439, near the close of the war, it granted a land tax, the taille, from which the nobles were exempted. Since there was no opposition when the king chose to consider such grants to be permanent, the king became independent. He had plenty of revenue, he had a standing army, he dominated the clergy and dispensed favors to the nobles, and so had little need of the Estates-General. For 174 years, beginning in 1614, the representatives of the three estates were not summoned to consider the affairs of the kingdom. In 1788, however, the treasury was empty, and Louis XVI was forced to call this almost forgotten body together again. When it met on May 5, 1789, the representatives of the third estate, equal in numbers to the other two, refused to vote according to the old method by which each estate cast one vote. They insisted on voting as individuals and declared themselves the National Assembly. On June 20, 1789, they took the famous "Tennis Court" oath not to disperse until they had given France a constitution. This bold attitude showed clearly that a revolution was at hand (see French Revolution). The name estates-general was not uncommon in medieval Europe. In Spain there were four estates, or classes, in the assembly. In The Netherlands the name States-General is still applied to the legislative body of that kingdom. It is composed of two houses the upper, elected by the provincial assemblies, and the lower, chosen by the people. Excerpted from Compton's Interactive Encyclopedia (1996). Compton's New Media. http://www2.fultonschools.org/teacher/bell/French%20History%20Reading/estates.pdf


What is the state of state address?

When the governor of a state addresses the general assembly of that state concerning the economic and social status of the state. It is similar to the President of the United States addressing the U.S. congress.


What countries a has classes called estates?

The term "estates" is most frequently applied to the class distinctions of the kingdom of France, beginning in the Middle Ages. Similar stratification occurred during the histories of Sweden and Finland.


How was the estates general similar to parliament?

Members of the third estate played a major role in both groups


What is a similar meaning of agora?

An assembly; hence, the place of assembly, especially the market place, in an ancient Greek city.


Which pair of triangles must be similar?

Pairs of triangles, in general, do not have to be similar.