Yes of course, but your probably referring to
"If a tree falls and nobody's around to hear it, does it make a sound"
Well nobody can ever know for absolute certainty, but if we get scientific about it, then yes.
Nobody has to be around to hear the noise it makes. It will make a sound, it won't just fall and be silent, it has to make a sound. Regardless of the fact that someone was there or not.
It all determines on your definition of sound the one i use is a sensation in your organs caused by vibrations. SO if there is no one there to pick up the vibrations than the tree falling never really turns into sound it is just a vibration.
Stupid Philosophical question about Physics
ORPhilosophical question that has nothing to do with physics HummIt will make the pressure waves in the air, but is that sound if no one who understands the significance is there to hear and appreciate. OpinionI think that as I will stub my toe on the fallen log the question is moot and there is a sound.If You Are Not There To Hear It, You Wont, But If There Are People There, They Will Hear It(:
What do you think
Yes, the tree falling would still create vibrations in the air that we would classify as sound. Sound is a physical phenomenon that occurs regardless of whether it is perceived by a person.
Yes because sound waves exist even if people aren't in the area.
no.
Yes
The phrase "If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?" is a philosophical question that has been attributed to a variety of sources, including Bishop George Berkeley and George Washington Carver. It is often used to prompt discussion about the nature of reality and perception.
No because sound is something you hear and if no one hears it, there is no sound.
If a tree falls but nobody is around to hear it, the tree will not make a sound. It will make sound waves, but it isn't sound unless somebody is around to transfer the waves into actual sound.
Yes, the falling tree will generate sound waves whether or not there is anyone there to hear them. Sound is a vibration that travels through the air, and the falling tree will create these vibrations regardless of whether someone is there to perceive them.
Yes.
If a tree falls in the forest, and there's no one around, does it make a sound?
yes