answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

Both companies have products for hip resurfacing and for total hip replacement as well. Birmingham is owned by Smith & Nephew, and Depuy is owned by Johnson & Johnson. A correct comparison would be between their hip resurfacing systems, the BHR (Birmingham Hip Resurfacing) and ASR (Articular Surface Replacement) from Depuy and they are certainly not the same, although it can be said that they are similar, both are metal on metal implants.

In rates of failures the "ASR system has a failure rate of 12% at 5 years compared to 4.3% of the BHR" - according to a study.

Also a crucial component of the ASR system, the ASR XL Acetabular System has been recalled in 2010 due to high failure rates.

Sources quoted in links section.

User Avatar

Wiki User

11y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Is a Birmingham hip replacement the same as a DePuy hip replacement?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

What are the list of symptoms for failing hip replacement that has been recalled?

Specific to the DePuy ASR hip implants the list of symptoms for a failing replacement include: * Swelling * Limited flexibility resulting in change of stride or limping * Hip and or groin pain


Depuy 's bigger than Zimmer?

DePuy and Zimmer offer many different hip implant devices of varying sizes. There is no clear answer as to which hip implant is larger. What is known is that many Zimmer and DePuy hip implant patients with Metal on Metal hip replacements have experienced hip implant failure.


How much doe a 2004 DePuy Total Hip Replacement Assembly Weigh?

Depuy make a lot of different implants, 2004 only refers to its manufacture date. Without knowing more about the case, it is impossible to guess.


What should you do if you have a DePuy hip replacement?

Contact your physician for an examination of your implant system. Describe any potential symptoms you my be experiencing such as swelling and/or discomfort.


Can you surf after a hip replacement?

You should limit yourself to swimming or stationery bikes at least at first if you need the exercise. In case of defective hip implant complications http://www.defectivehip.org/depuy/asr-recall/


How much can you expect from a recalled depuy hip settlement?

There are a number of factors that will go into determining the amount of any DePuy ASR hip replacement settlement that is awarded based on the individual circumstances of each case.Common factors that a jury may consider:The extent and duration of the injury suffered;The effect that the DePuy ASR hip injury had on the overall physical and mental health or well-being of the plaintiff;The pain and mental anguish suffered in the past and which will likely be suffered in the future;The extent of any disfigurement or scarring caused by defective DePuy ASR hip implants or their removal;The amount of any past or future medical expenses caused by DePuy metal-on-metal hip implants;Any lost wages or loss of earning capacity.


How much money are the depuy hip replacement ligitants receiving?

It depends. Many people who just filed for compensation with Depuy have not even received enough back to cover the additional medical expenses. Some of these people have had to partake in separate lawsuits related to this. That payout varies according to the case.


Where in the UK are doctors specialised on hip replacement surgery?

The McMinn Centre in Birmingham UK. Mr. McMinn has won several awards for his advancements in hip replacement surgeries. He also frequently lectures on procedures involving hip replacements.


Can you have a pelvis replacement such as a hip replacement?

No. A lot of people are confused by the term "hip replacement", since the term hip and the term pelvis often refer to the same structure. However, a "hip replacement" only involves replace of the hip joint, and very little of the pelvic structure other than that. Recall that the legs are connected to the pelvis via a ball-and-socket type joint. In a hip replacement, the worn out, natural "socket" (known as the acetabulum) is replaced with synthetic replacement, while topmost end of the thigh bone (femur) is removed to allow installation of the synthetic (usually titanium) "ball".


What are the treatments for hip dysplasia?

Hip resurfacing or total hip replacement


When did Roald Dahl get a hip replacement?

Roald Dahl had a hip replacement surgery in 1965 after a car accident in New York.


Best Hip replacement surgeons in Chennai?

Hip Replacement or hip arthroplasty is a surgical procedure to treat the damaged portion of the hip. A person who performs this procedure by making certain incisions to remove the damaged part of the hip and replacing them with prosthetic implants is a Hip Replacement surgeon.