answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

It depends on what the metal is going to be used for. A hot dip galvanized steel generally has a thicker zinc layer than an electrogalvanized steel which improves its properties against corrosion. On the other side, the thicker layer might make it inferior in an application in which space is limited.

User Avatar

Wiki User

10y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Is hot dip galvanizing better than electro galvanizing?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Natural Sciences

Why galvanizing is preferred over tinning?

One advantage is economic: Tin is more expensive than zinc. Another, probably more important one, is that zinc, unlike tin, is higher in the electromotive series than iron. Therefore, galvanized iron can continue to provide protection against rust, even when small holes develop in the zinc coating, because the zinc will be oxidized in preference to iron.


What is the detailed procedure of hot dip galvanizing and electro galvanizing and acid compounds used in it?

GALVANISING For use in construction at coastal areas it shall be required for galvanizing the Cross arms and Pole top brackets as following : All galvanizing shall be carried out by the hot dip process, in accordance with Specification IS 2629. However, high tensile steel nuts, bolts and spring washer shall be electro galvanized to Service Condition 4. The zinc coating shall be smooth, continuous and uniform. It shall be free from acid spot and shall not scale, blister or be removable by handling or packing. There shall be no impurities in the zinc or additives to the galvanic bath which could have a detrimental effect on the durability of the zinc coating. Before picking, all welding, drilling, cutting, grinding and other finishing operations must be completed and all grease, paints, varnish, oil, welding slag and other foreign matter completely removed. All protuberances which would affect the life of galvanizing shall also be removed. The weight of zinc deposited shall be in accordance with that stated in Standard IS 2629 and shall not less than 0.61kg/m² with a minimum thickness of 86 microns for items of thickness more than 5mm, 0.46kg/m² (64 microns) for items of thickness between 2mm and 5mm and 0.33kg/m² (47 microns) for items less than 2mm thick. Parts shall not be galvanized if their shapes are such that the pickling solutions cannot be removed with certainty or if galvanizing would be unsatisfactory or if their mechanical strength would be reduced. Surfaces in contact with oil shall not be galvanized unless they are subsequently coated with an oil resistant varnish or paint. In the event of damage to the galvanizing the method used for repair shall be subject to the approval of the Project Manager or that of his representative. Repair of galvanizing on site will generally not be permitted. The threads of all galvanized bolts and screwed rods shall be cleared of spelter by spinning or brushing. A die shall not be used for cleaning the threads unless specifically approved by the Project Manager. All nuts shall be galvanized. The threads of nuts shall be cleaned with a tap and the threads oiled. Partial immersion of the work shall not be permitted and the galvanizing tank must therefore be sufficiently large to permit galvanizing to be carried out by one immersion. After galvanizing no drilling or welding shall be performed on the galvanized parts of the equipment excepting that nuts may be threaded after galvanizing. To avoid the formation of white rust galvanized materials shall be stacked during transport and stored in such a manner as to permit adequate ventilation. Sodium dichromate treatment shall be provided to avoid formation of white rust after hot dip galvanization.


What can you use for sacrificial protection of iron nails?

A more reactive metal which is electrically connected to the nail. Typically, zinc is used to coat the iron nail (hot dip galvanizing)


What is galvanizing process?

Galvanizing is a process of coating iron with zinc to protect against rusting. The process may be electrochemical, (the origin of the name) nowadays the term is most often appled to a hot dip porcess , simply dunking a clean iron/steel piece into molten zinc pulling it out and letting it cool.


What is galvenised wire?

A wire that has been coated with zinc tends to be protected from "galvanic corrosion", meaning that it will be less likely to corrode. The wire could be "hot dip" galvanized or it could be electro-plate galvanized to be considered a galvinized wire.

Related questions

What has the author Heinz Bablik written?

Heinz Bablik has written: 'Galvanizing (hot-dip)'


At what temperature will galvanizing smoke or melt?


Why galvanizing is preferred over tinning?

One advantage is economic: Tin is more expensive than zinc. Another, probably more important one, is that zinc, unlike tin, is higher in the electromotive series than iron. Therefore, galvanized iron can continue to provide protection against rust, even when small holes develop in the zinc coating, because the zinc will be oxidized in preference to iron.


What has the author William H Spowers written?

William H. Spowers has written: 'Hot-dip galvanizing practice'


What is the melting point of galvanized steel?

Typically, galvanizing refers to hot-dip galvanizingwhich is process of submerging steel parts into molten zinc. Zinc will melt at 787.15 °F. In a galvanizing environment, most of the smoke is flux burn-off from the preparation process. Depending on the specific galvanizing company, zinc is generally maintained between 820 - 860 °F.Hot-dip Galvanizing Zinc Temperature Range820 - 860 °F (449 - 460 °C)Zinc Melting Point787.15 °F (419.53 °C)


What is the difference between cold rolled galvanized and hot dipped galvanized steel?

Hot-dip galvanized pipe is made by reacting the iron substrate with molten metal to form an alloy layer, thus combining the substrate with the coating. Hot-dip galvanizing requires pickling of the steel pipe to remove iron oxide from the surface of the pipe. After pickling, it is washed in an aqueous solution of zinc chloride or ammonium chloride or a mixture of ammonium chloride and zinc chloride and then sent to a hot dip galvanizing bath. Hot dip galvanizing has the advantages of strong adhesion, uniform coating and long service life. Cold galvanizing is what we call electro-galvanizing. The amount of galvanization is very small, and the corrosion resistance of cold galvanized pipe itself is very different from that of hot galvanized pipe, so many construction projects do not use cold galvanized pipe. At present, the Ministry of Construction has officially stated that technically backward cold galvanized pipes need to be eliminated, and cold galvanized pipes will not be allowed to be used as water and gas pipes in the future. Shanghai Changzheng's cold rolled steel sheets are of superior quality and are the choice of most people. Buy steel plates from Shanghai Changzheng.


What is galvanizing made from?

Iron with a zinc coating. Galvanizing is the application of a zinc coating over a metal (usually steel) to inhibit corrosion. The process is simple. In this case, manufacture your part (either forge or cast the iron) and then hot dip it in molten zinc to coat it and produce your galvanized iron part.


What is the detailed procedure of hot dip galvanizing and electro galvanizing and acid compounds used in it?

GALVANISING For use in construction at coastal areas it shall be required for galvanizing the Cross arms and Pole top brackets as following : All galvanizing shall be carried out by the hot dip process, in accordance with Specification IS 2629. However, high tensile steel nuts, bolts and spring washer shall be electro galvanized to Service Condition 4. The zinc coating shall be smooth, continuous and uniform. It shall be free from acid spot and shall not scale, blister or be removable by handling or packing. There shall be no impurities in the zinc or additives to the galvanic bath which could have a detrimental effect on the durability of the zinc coating. Before picking, all welding, drilling, cutting, grinding and other finishing operations must be completed and all grease, paints, varnish, oil, welding slag and other foreign matter completely removed. All protuberances which would affect the life of galvanizing shall also be removed. The weight of zinc deposited shall be in accordance with that stated in Standard IS 2629 and shall not less than 0.61kg/m² with a minimum thickness of 86 microns for items of thickness more than 5mm, 0.46kg/m² (64 microns) for items of thickness between 2mm and 5mm and 0.33kg/m² (47 microns) for items less than 2mm thick. Parts shall not be galvanized if their shapes are such that the pickling solutions cannot be removed with certainty or if galvanizing would be unsatisfactory or if their mechanical strength would be reduced. Surfaces in contact with oil shall not be galvanized unless they are subsequently coated with an oil resistant varnish or paint. In the event of damage to the galvanizing the method used for repair shall be subject to the approval of the Project Manager or that of his representative. Repair of galvanizing on site will generally not be permitted. The threads of all galvanized bolts and screwed rods shall be cleared of spelter by spinning or brushing. A die shall not be used for cleaning the threads unless specifically approved by the Project Manager. All nuts shall be galvanized. The threads of nuts shall be cleaned with a tap and the threads oiled. Partial immersion of the work shall not be permitted and the galvanizing tank must therefore be sufficiently large to permit galvanizing to be carried out by one immersion. After galvanizing no drilling or welding shall be performed on the galvanized parts of the equipment excepting that nuts may be threaded after galvanizing. To avoid the formation of white rust galvanized materials shall be stacked during transport and stored in such a manner as to permit adequate ventilation. Sodium dichromate treatment shall be provided to avoid formation of white rust after hot dip galvanization.


What can you use for sacrificial protection of iron nails?

A more reactive metal which is electrically connected to the nail. Typically, zinc is used to coat the iron nail (hot dip galvanizing)


What is the definition of galvanizing?

Its the process of hot dip coating steel or iron with zinc. This stops moisture from rusting the base metal. For more information on galvinizing, see the related link.


What is galvanizing process?

Galvanizing is a process of coating iron with zinc to protect against rusting. The process may be electrochemical, (the origin of the name) nowadays the term is most often appled to a hot dip porcess , simply dunking a clean iron/steel piece into molten zinc pulling it out and letting it cool.


Are pouches better for your gums than long cut?

yes the dip is not directly touching your lips...but it is not as affective