0
It depends on the severity. You should never spank a child hard, if at all. The only time you really should ever spank a child is if they are doing something that could hurt them and you have already told them not to. Otherwise, try something else.
Wiki User
∙ 12y ago
Wiki User
∙ 14y agoCalls for an opinion. Here's both sides:
1. No. In moderation it can be all right. Children at a very young age are not going to understand a lecture or explanation on why stoves are hot, or stealing cookies is bad. A quick sharp reminder of a slap on the hand or spank on the bottom can impart this lesson in terms the child understands.
It should not leave a bruise, and once punished, there should be as much love and affection after wards as always. Once the child is old enough, say between 5 and 7 of age, explanations and loss of privileges can be given instead of spankings.
2. Yes. It is physically abusive in all forms. You should use a "time out". Physically confine the child in a chair or corner for a minute per year of age. This will let him know that he did wrong, without teaching him that physical force is good.
(And I'm biased towards the first one, for the "time out" actually involves physical force, too, which parents learn the first time they try to make a four year old boy stand in a corner for four minutes!)
Spanking is abusive and unnecessary for effective discipline.
Time outs or taking away some toys are more appropriate for younger children.
When dealing with older children and teens, a good parent can and does discipline his/her child by grounding them from social events like sporting events, parties and movies, taking away their cell phones, and making sure they only use their computers for actual homework, not for social networks like Facebook, My Space, message boards. Television priveliges and iPods can also be withheld for a period of time.
Extra chores can also be given since no one, child or adult likes to do more work. All or part of their child's allowance can be withheld for a period of time.
Spanking only teaches who is bigger or stronger.
Wiki User
∙ 12y agoNo, as long as the teenager is not injured.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Is it okay for the babysitter to be allowed to watch the children get a spanking?
If they are the ones doing the spanking (from permission of a parent) it is fine otherwise you probably don't want to watch the child being spanked First and foremost spanking is child abuse, There is no rationale for a child to be disciplined this way. Sitters should never, ever spank a child under any circumstances, It is child abuse.
What are the specific guidelines of spanking a child in South Carolina?
There are no specific laws concerning "spanking". However, any physical act either by use of an instrument or not that leaves bruises, abrasions, and so forth is considered physical abuse and if reported is subject to investigation by child protective services.
Is it right for a father to spank a teenage daughter?
Spanking is legal but bare bottom on a 14yo is inappropriate and crossing the line. I assume you want to teach your child right from wrong and not humiliate her. By this age they definitely have a personal space that should be respected and especially naked. They are not little children anymore. I can't find anything about a specific law being against it and it also might differ depending on where you live but that does not mean a judge wont find it wrong.
Can you go to jail for spanking your teen?
why would you beat your child anyways. but yes you can be arrested for beating your child but on if they consider it child abuse. which in North Carolina is if you beat you child with anything besides our hand and it leaves a mark or bruise for more than twenty- four hours.
Is it illegal to hit your child in wyoming?
A parent has the right to discipline their child, which includes corporal punishment (spanking/hitting). A child, however, is legally protected from cruel and unusual punishment from the parent. Generally speaking, if the parent is leaving a serious bruise, the child is being subjected to excessive punishment that constitutes "child abuse". Any further specification is a personal opinion.
What is the Florida law on spanking children?
Florida restricts all spanking as child abuse. Florida law states that any act that can physically or mentally hurt a child is considered child abuse and you can be charged with a felony for it.
What are the titles of some parenting videos about the pros and cons of spanking?
Online there are the videos called "Pros and Cons of Spanking Your Child", "Spanking Your Kids: Discipline or Abuse", and "Spanking And Child Discipline-The Pros And Cons".
Is punching your child in the stomach a spanking?
NO! It's child abuse for which you can be arrested and your child removed from your custody.
That kids are allowed to be hit?
if it is diciplenary by the child's parents yes(like spanking), but if it is parental abuse or abuse from any other person it is considered child abuse
Spanking is hated because people think it is a form of abuse.?
Sure people think it is but it makes your child ack better. If you get a spanking for lying ur brain tells you not to do it again
Can a step parent get in trouble for spanking their stepchild?
Yes, it is possible for a parent to be arrested on a charge of child abuse for spanking their child.
How do you make a child listen to you without abusing them?
Spanking is abuse. If you have to use a belt. Its not abusive its just a way to get your childrens attention.
What are the legal issues for child abuse?
Legal issues regarding child abuse generally revolve around what counts as child abuse and what doesn't. For example, some people consider spanking child abuse while others consider it an acceptable form of punishment. Constitutional protections of the parent-child relationship and privacy in the home must also be legally balanced with the welfare of the child.
Why do some people think spanking is abuse?
When a child is spanked he/she is getting hit and that makes it abusive. The child learns that hitting is a solution to problems. There are other ways to displine a child.
Does spanking influence aggressive behavior?
No, it normally doesn't. Some believe it to be this way since they mix spanking with abuse, but a child who has been spanked usually grows up to be no more violent than those who may have only been grounded as a child.
Is spanking your child with a belt legal in Washington?
By law, hitting a child with an object such as a belt is considered whipping and thus is considered child abuse, which is illegal. Depending on the severity the sentence length and punishments differ, however, it is common for the child to be removed from their parent. So yes, spanking with a belt is illegal in Washington
What is an example of controversial topics that have to do with developmental psychology?
One example of a controversial topic in developmental psychology is the nature vs. nurture debate, which examines the extent to which genetics and environmental factors influence development. Another example is the impact of early childhood experiences, such as attachment styles or parenting styles, on later psychological functioning and wellbeing.
