answersLogoWhite

0

Should Herod have kept the oath he made to his daughter?

Updated: 8/16/2019
User Avatar

Wiki User

8y ago

Best Answer

According to the Gospels, Herod Antipas had John the Baptist beheaded at the capricious request of his daughter, during the time of Jesus in Galilee.

However, the Jewish historian Josephus said that Herod Antipas had the Baptist killed in quite different circumstances, because he disapproved of Antipas' marriage to his own brother's wife, who divorced her husband in order to marry Herod Antipas. The relevant text from Book 18 of Antiquities of the Jews: "Now many people came in crowds to him, for they were greatly moved by his words. Herod, who feared that the great influence John had over the masses might put them into his power and enable him to raise a rebellion (for they seemed ready to do anything he should advise), thought it best to put him to death. In this way, he might prevent any mischief John might cause, and not bring himself into difficulties by sparing a man who might make him repent of it when it would be too late. Accordingly John was sent as a prisoner, out of Herod's suspicious temper, to Macherus, the castle I already mentioned, and was put to death."

So, according to Josephus, Herod Antipas made no oath or promise to his daughter, who was not actually involved in the execution of John the Baptist.

User Avatar

Wiki User

8y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Should Herod have kept the oath he made to his daughter?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

Where should flu shots be kept?

Vaccine should always be kept in refrigerators unless the one who made it says otherwise.


Who made the computer in stormbreaker?

Herod Sayle


Should a husband love his daughter more than his wife?

A husband should love his daughter just as much as his wife. After all his daughter was made from his wife. That goes with sons too.


What is a sentence for temples?

A sentence for temples could be............ King Herod made the people of Israel pay heavy taxes so he can build buildings such as pyramids and temples


What did herod as a king?

he is known for the additions he made to the Jewish Temple


Why did Cleopatra go to jerusalum?

Cleopatra more than likely went to Jerusalem to gloat. She was an enemy of Herod and wanted Antony to give her Herod's kingdom. Antony refused, but did give her a great deal of Herod's income especially the income from his balsam groves. On her way home from Antioch, she made a tour of all her new possessions, stopping at Jerusalem to gloat over her "victory" over Herod and also to renew her friendship with Herod's wife and mother-in-law.Cleopatra more than likely went to Jerusalem to gloat. She was an enemy of Herod and wanted Antony to give her Herod's kingdom. Antony refused, but did give her a great deal of Herod's income especially the income from his balsam groves. On her way home from Antioch, she made a tour of all her new possessions, stopping at Jerusalem to gloat over her "victory" over Herod and also to renew her friendship with Herod's wife and mother-in-law.Cleopatra more than likely went to Jerusalem to gloat. She was an enemy of Herod and wanted Antony to give her Herod's kingdom. Antony refused, but did give her a great deal of Herod's income especially the income from his balsam groves. On her way home from Antioch, she made a tour of all her new possessions, stopping at Jerusalem to gloat over her "victory" over Herod and also to renew her friendship with Herod's wife and mother-in-law.Cleopatra more than likely went to Jerusalem to gloat. She was an enemy of Herod and wanted Antony to give her Herod's kingdom. Antony refused, but did give her a great deal of Herod's income especially the income from his balsam groves. On her way home from Antioch, she made a tour of all her new possessions, stopping at Jerusalem to gloat over her "victory" over Herod and also to renew her friendship with Herod's wife and mother-in-law.Cleopatra more than likely went to Jerusalem to gloat. She was an enemy of Herod and wanted Antony to give her Herod's kingdom. Antony refused, but did give her a great deal of Herod's income especially the income from his balsam groves. On her way home from Antioch, she made a tour of all her new possessions, stopping at Jerusalem to gloat over her "victory" over Herod and also to renew her friendship with Herod's wife and mother-in-law.Cleopatra more than likely went to Jerusalem to gloat. She was an enemy of Herod and wanted Antony to give her Herod's kingdom. Antony refused, but did give her a great deal of Herod's income especially the income from his balsam groves. On her way home from Antioch, she made a tour of all her new possessions, stopping at Jerusalem to gloat over her "victory" over Herod and also to renew her friendship with Herod's wife and mother-in-law.Cleopatra more than likely went to Jerusalem to gloat. She was an enemy of Herod and wanted Antony to give her Herod's kingdom. Antony refused, but did give her a great deal of Herod's income especially the income from his balsam groves. On her way home from Antioch, she made a tour of all her new possessions, stopping at Jerusalem to gloat over her "victory" over Herod and also to renew her friendship with Herod's wife and mother-in-law.Cleopatra more than likely went to Jerusalem to gloat. She was an enemy of Herod and wanted Antony to give her Herod's kingdom. Antony refused, but did give her a great deal of Herod's income especially the income from his balsam groves. On her way home from Antioch, she made a tour of all her new possessions, stopping at Jerusalem to gloat over her "victory" over Herod and also to renew her friendship with Herod's wife and mother-in-law.Cleopatra more than likely went to Jerusalem to gloat. She was an enemy of Herod and wanted Antony to give her Herod's kingdom. Antony refused, but did give her a great deal of Herod's income especially the income from his balsam groves. On her way home from Antioch, she made a tour of all her new possessions, stopping at Jerusalem to gloat over her "victory" over Herod and also to renew her friendship with Herod's wife and mother-in-law.


Why did Salome want John's head on a platter?

Salome requested John the Baptist's head on a platter as a reward because her mother Herodias harbored a grudge against him for criticizing her marriage to Herod. Salome's request was prompted by her mother's desire for revenge and was granted by Herod to fulfill the promise he had made to Salome.


What was king Herod's nationality?

King Herod was born in 73 BCE in Judea. Herod's mother was an ethnic Arab and his father was an Edomite. When Rome made Herod a client king, many Jews resented it. Although Herod was raised as a Jew, his alliance with Rome led many of his Jewish subjects despise him. Many Jews considered Herod an "outsider" and a "half Jew".


How did the maker of bratz come across the name Yasmin?

The man who created bratz (but only kept the original idea of bratz because of his daughter saying she liked them, as appose to him thinking they were aliens) has a daughter named Jasmin. He made a brat (Yasmin) look kind of like his daughter and decided to name her Yasmin after his own daughter Jasmin.


Why was king herod a good king?

he is known for the additions he made to the Jewish temple in Jerusalem. he made temple most awe-inspiring buildings in the Roman world.


What is the treatment for digeorge syndrome?

Children with DiGeorge syndrome should be kept on low-phosphorus diets and kept away from crowds or other sources of infection. They should not be immunized with vaccines made from live viruses or given corticosteroids.


Can child support end if your daughter was pregnant and aborted the child?

What she did with her pregnancy has no influence on the child support you pay for her. Even if she would have kept the child it would not have made any difference. pregnancy does not emancipate anyone. You are still obligated to support your daughter until she is 18yo.