no one noticed hollyleaf.she could of easily slipped away.
Ashfur's murderer is Hollyleaf. Leafpool found a tuft of Hollyleaf's fur snagged in Ashfur's claws.
Ashfur tries to murder Squirrleflight, Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather because when Brambleclaw and Squirrleflight got in a fight Squirrleflight grew close to Ashfur. So when Squirrleflight and Brambleclaw make up and become mates Ashfur get furious. So when the clan believes Squirrleflight had Brambleclaw's kits. Ashfur blocks the only way out of camp when Squirrleflight and her kits are still in camp when there is a fire. Squirrleflight tells Ashfur that they aren't her kits but she doesn't tell whoes kits they are. In the book Sunrise Hollyleaf murders Ashfur before a gathering because he was going to announce that Hollyleaf and her littermates weren't Squirrleflight's kits. So when Leafpool tells Hollyleaf she knows that she killed Ashfur Hollyleaf runs away to the underground tunnels. they collapse on her and she died. Some people believe she is still alive. (Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather work out that Leafpool is their mother. While Jayfeather was dreaming StarClan came to him and gave him a crow feather. Jayfeather tells his littermates that Crowfeather from WindClan is their father. Hollyleaf announces at a gathering that Leafpool and Crowfeather are her real parents. Crowfeather gets furious with Leafpool and Leafpool backs down from her position as a medicine cat.)
No, Ashfur would never try to kill Squirrelfight. He loved her but tried to kill Hollyleaf, jayfeather, and Lionblaze to get revenge on her. Then she revealed they were not her children and he didn't kill them.
Hollyleaf
Hollyleaf
no one
No, Hollyleaf did.
No, Hollyleaf does. It may seem like Squirrelflight did but she didn't 'cause Hollyleaf admits that she did kill Ashfur in Sunrise.
Hollyleaf was the cat who killed Ashfur. She did so to protect her siblings and keep their secret from being exposed.
Ashfur threatened to burn Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather (as everyone believed were Squirrelflight's kits at the time) so that Squirrelflight, the cat he once loved, would feel the pain he felt when she chose another tom, Brambleclaw, over Ashfur to be her mate. To save the kits, Squirrelflight screamed out the truth..."They are not my kits!" Hollyleaf and her littermates were startled, and Squirrelflight explained, "I am not their true mother!" Ashfur's eyes gleamed. He thought of another plan to hurt Squirrelflight. Hollyleaf knew that at the Gathering that night, Ashfur would reveal the secret that Squirrelflight had burst out. Even though Hollyleaf felt like Squirrelflight was a traitor, a filthy liar, she knew that this secret could not be revealed. So before the Gathering began, Firestar the ThunderClan leader, called his cats together to travel to the Gathering. "Where's Ashfur? And Squirrelflight? I don't see them." Squirrelflight was found, but Ashfur was missing. They looked and found Thornclaw bent over a limp cat's body. Thornclaw stared at Firestar. "It's Ashfur!" He cried. Everyone sat vigil for Ashfur that night, though Lionblaze and Jayfeather felt a bit relieved that their secret would remain hidden. Firestar declared that even though Ashfur was found near the WindClan border, there was no scent of a WindClan cat on him. He declared that a cat from ThunderClan, or maybe a loner had killed him. But deep in Hollyleaf's heart, she knew she had killed him, and for the good of her Clan. Later, she found out that Leafpool was her mother, and Crowfeather, a WindClan tom, was her Father. Since the warrior code meant so much to Hollyleaf, she couldn't stand being Half-Clan and being the daughter of a medicine cat. She blurted out the truth of Ashfur's murderer to her brothers then ran down a tunnel to escape........ Unfortunately, she didn't escape the way she wanted to. The tunnel collapsed and Hollyleaf was never heard of again. To keep her safe, Lionblaze and Jayfeather never revealed the secret of Ashfur's murdering to anyone. Instead, they said she chased a mouse down the tunnel to hunt, but died hunting for her clan. At least now, she would be known as a noble warrior, not one that killed her own Clanmate.
Ashfur-Revenge
It depends on what you think evil is. Hollyleaf does kill Ashfur though.