Evaluating Arguments Quiz
Results Reporter Out of 7 questions, you answered 7 correctly with a final grade of 100% 7 correct (100%)
0 incorrect (0%)
0 unanswered (0%) 
Your Results:The correct answer for each question is indicated by a

.

1 CORRECT

It's no use going on about whether this law is just. It was passed democratically.
A)
Valid
B)
Strong
C)
Can't be made either valid or strong Feedback: The correct answer is B. The assumed premise, Most laws that were passed democratically are just, makes the argument strong. The premise needed for a valid argument, "All democratically passed laws are just," is not as plausible.

2 CORRECT

How can you be so critical of
Pride and Prejudice? You never read it.
A)
Valid
B)
Strong
C)
Can't be made either valid or strong Feedback: The correct answer is A. The assumed premise, You are not justified in being critical of any book you have not read, is plausible and makes the argument valid.

3 CORRECT

I wouldn't call her reliable. She was late with her last rent check.
A)
Valid
B)
Strong
C)
Can't be made either valid or strong Feedback: No assumed premise can make the argument either strong or valid. The weakest possible assumption, "If she was late with her rent check last month, she probably isn't reliable," is far too implausible.

4 CORRECT

It's not safe to let Dave drive you home. He just had a furious argument with his boss.
A)
Valid
B)
Strong
C)
Can't be made either valid or strong Feedback: The correct answer is B. The assumed premise, When Dave has just had a furious argument, it's usually not safe to let him drive, makes this a strong argument. It isn't plausible to assume (as you'd have to for a valid argument) that Dave is an unsafe driver every time he's had a furious argument.

5 CORRECT

Look, it's snowing. The air will be warmer today.
A)
Valid
B)
Strong
C)
Can't be made either valid or strong Feedback: The correct answer is B. The assumed premise, When it is snowing, the air becomes warmer, makes this a strong argument.

6 CORRECT

We didn't miss the bus. It isn't 8:04 yet.
A)
Valid
B)
Strong
C)
Can't be made either valid or strong Feedback: The correct answer is B. The assumed premise, If it isn't 8:04, the bus probably has not come yet, makes the argument strong.

7 CORRECT

That isn't art. A child could do it.
A)
Valid
B)
Strong
C)
Can't be made either valid or strong Feedback: No assumed premise can make the argument either strong or valid. The weakest possibility, "Very few children could make art," is too vague to be plausible.