One summer I was living in Pittsburgh, PA and a friend of mine was in Cleveland OH. We decided to meet in the middle and ended up meeting in a town called Lordstown, OH. Pretty much exactly half way, though Youngstown is pretty close too and more of a substantial city.
The exact halfway point is the corner of Ecorse Road and Middlebelt, but that is on a straight line between Wyandotte and Canton.
Firestone Park, OH
Ashland, OH and Wooster, OH
Pittsburg
OHIO
Wooster
Pineton, Pennsylvania is halfway between Ohio and Asbury
The City of Cleveland is most likely the 1/2 way point. Probably somewhere around the end of I-490 and E55th street.
Sugar Grove, Ohio is the halfway point.
Dayton Ohio
Silver Springs, OH is the halfway point.
There is approximately 2,327 miles between these two cities. Halfway would be 1,164 miles, in the Badlands of South Dakota, near Scenic, SD.