0
In the book the Giver did the committee made a good choice in their selection of Jonas?
Wiki User
∙ 9y ago
he was selected to receive and keep the memories so that the citizens wouldn't have to carry the bad memories.
Era Boyer
In the book "The Giver," the committee's choice of selecting Jonas as the Receiver of Memories was controversial and had both positive and negative consequences. Some may argue that the selection was not a good choice due to the emotional burden and risks it placed on Jonas. However, others may believe that it was necessary for the preservation of memories and knowledge in their society.
Wiki User
∙ 9y agoOne Perspective:
Yes it was meant to be and this job suits him.
Another Perspective:
The argument could be made that no, they did not make a good decision. Like the previous selection, Rosemary, ten years before Jonas, Jonas is becoming less controlled or controllable. Combined with the Community's decision to rescind the Receiver of Memories' choice for voluntary release, Jonas' selection becomes a huge mistake for the Community. With only five weeks receiving memories, Rosemary's release created chaos as the memories she had received flooded back into the Community. Jonas' much longer training period means even more memories will return after he and Gabriel leave and presumably die on their journey.
This is speculation, but perhaps Lowry is enforcing the Santyana quote, "Those who forget history are doomed to repeat it." By giving up their collective memories of the past, the Community is locking themselves into a path toward eventual failure.
Wiki User
∙ 7y agowhat was jonas selected to do? the giver
Anonymous
Anonymous
He was chosen to be the Receiver of Memories, because of his intelligence, integrity, courage, and ability to acquire wisdom.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What does Jonas wonder about when he is not with The Giver?
Jonas wonders about his family, his friends, and the outside world when he is not with The Giver. He grapples with the lack of freedom and choice in his society, and questions the values and rules that have been imposed upon him.
What The Giver will be about what?
"The Giver" is a dystopian novel by Lois Lowry that follows a young boy named Jonas who learns about the secrets of his community, where emotions and memories are suppressed. Through his training with the Giver, Jonas begins to question the society's rules and explore the depths of human experience.
How does the giver treat Jonas in the book the giver?
The giver treats Jonas with love and care. Once Jonas learned about love, The Giver tells Jonas that they have a great bond and that he loves him dearly.
What are six events that happened during the celebration of release of giver?
The ceremonial naming and age assignments of the children. Jonas's selection as the Receiver of Memory. Jonas's training with the Giver and the memories he receives. Jonas's realization of the truth about the community. Jonas's escape with the baby Gabriel. The community's response and the implications of Jonas's departure.
In the giver why did Jonas say that it was good that there were no choice?
Jonas says that it is good that there are no choices because people could make a wrong choice, which might lead to sadness, fear, hate, chaos, etc.
What happened when Jonas number was called in chapter 7 in the giver?
When Jonas's number was called in chapter 7 of "The Giver," it marked the beginning of his training as the new Receiver of Memories. This selection sets him apart from his peers and initiates his journey of gaining knowledge and understanding from the Giver. It is a significant event that will change Jonas's life and perception of the world around him.
Who were the in the characters in The Giver?
The main characters in "The Giver" by Lois Lowry are Jonas, the Receiver of Memory; The Giver, the mentor training Jonas; and Fiona and Asher, Jonas' friends in the community.
Why did The Giver apologize to Jonas after sharing the memory of war in the book The Giver?
Because when the Giver shares memories which are painful to Jonas, it hurts Jonas physically.
What is the Main Character of The Giver by Lois Lowry?
The main character in "The Giver" by Lois Lowry is a boy named Jonas. He is chosen to be the Receiver of Memories in his community and learns about the true history of the society and the role of the Giver.
In the giver according to the giver why does Jonas have to receive and store memories of pain?
The Giver believes that Jonas needs to experience pain to understand true happiness and make meaningful connections with others. By experiencing pain, Jonas gains wisdom and empathy, which are crucial for him to appreciate the beauty of life and make choices that challenge the status quo in his community.
The giver What is Jonas' s number?
In the book "The Giver," Jonas is assigned the number 11.
Name the major characters in The Giver?
The major characters in "The Giver" are Jonas, The Giver, Fiona, Asher, and Jonas's family members such as his father and mother. Each character plays a significant role in the story's development and themes.
