0
What are some of the major influences that affect court Decisions?
Wiki User
∙ 9y ago
Ideally, Supreme Court decisions are meant to be made without external influences, with the justices relying only on what the authors of the laws and Constitution in question intended. However, they are human, and their lives and experiences have shaped their perceptions. Whether this is a negative thing is up for debate.
Wiki User
∙ 9y ago
Wiki User
∙ 11y agoThere are many, and some are more quantifiable than others.
Firstly, there are past precedents and the doctrine of stare decisis. Judges must conform to the decisions made in courts that are higher than them. Stare decisis means that like cases must be governed alike.
Secondly, there is framer's intent and legislative intent. Framer's intent is used for constitutional documents and legislative intent for statutes. These methods mean that the original intent of the person who created the legislation is taken into consideration when interpreting the law.
Next, there is the living tree doctrine for constitutional interpretation and textualism for statutes. The living tree doctrine is meant to represent a constantly evolving body of law. Laws are always interpreted in a modern context. Textualism means reading the law in its plainest language. The idea is that the legislative intent is embedded in the law and this is the best way to get at it. So laws are always interpreted literally, unless that would result in absurdity.
Then, there might be personal attributes of judges that affect decision making. It makes sense that each individual has a unique set of characteristics gleaned from a unique set of experiences and makes decisions accordingly. However, it can be said that gender has an impact on how certain cases are decided. The implications of this are up for debate, but the facts are solid. In this category there are also things like political affiliation, caste, religion, and ethnicity.
Public opinion (through the media especially) and the opinion of the legal community may also sway judicial decision making.
Wiki User
∙ 9y agoThe court decisions are affected majorly by the testimony of a witness. As well as the evidence that is put before them.
Wiki User
∙ 9y agoCourt decisions are affected by a number of factors. The jury, the interpretation of the judge and the evidence presented are all examples.
Wiki User
∙ 12y agoStaute Law and Precedents
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What are the major influences that affect the courts decision?
usually people dont let this get in the way, but sometimes emotion has a little something to do with court decisions.
What ways does the government not affect what you do?
They do not affect childrens lives much, especially because they are not that familiar with the system of government. They do not affect schools in the way that they make major decisions. They do not influence our personal and financial decisions, apart from the share market and industry. They cannot influence our voting decisions, such as what party and candidate we vote for. Government influences more major decisions in general, and do not interfere with our personal lives.
What 3 major areas of policy did the warren court decisions affect?
the three were the civil rights , due Process , and freedom of religion and freedom of speach
What are 2 major external influences on supreme court judicial decision making?
Public Opinion is a huge one. Since the eye of the people is so close on the Supreme Court given the consequences of its decisions, there is evidence that the Supreme Court is affected by the will of the people. Also, amicus briefs can influence Supreme Court votes.
What Supreme Court do?
the supreme court makes rulings that have been surpassed by the smaller courts. This being decisions such as gay marriage rights and other major decisions.
Which US Presidents made major Supreme Court decisions?
William Howard Taft (1921-1930) was the only former US President (1909-1913) to serve on the Supreme Court, so he's the only one who had an opportunity to make major decisions. The President has no role in the operation of the Supreme Court beyond appointing justices to vacancies. He (or she) doesn't participate in the Court's decisions.
What is the guiding force behind all supreme court decisions?
The guiding force in the US for US Supreme Court decisions is the US Constitution. The Supreme Court is one of the three major parts of the Federal government. Through the Congress, the Executive branch and the Court, a balance of power was created.
What is one of the major roles the Supreme Court played in the federal judiciary?
evaluate the decisions of lower federal court
How does Katniss' hatred of the Capitol affect her decisions in the Hunger Games?
Her dislike of the Capitol and the Games affects her decisions in 2 major ways. The first is dressing Rue in flowers. The second is nearly commiting suicide with Peeta.
Who was Henry david Thoreau's major influences?
ME
Major shifts in the supreme court's position have usually been due to what?
Major shifts in opinions result from Presidents appointing justices whose ideology and approach to constitutional interpretation differs from the majority on the court. The Supreme Court's decisions generally reflect the ideology of the majority, and this changes over time.
What are major influences on the region's climate of russia?
The Arctic and North Atlantic oceans are two factors which affect the climate in European Europe. A climate controller for Europe is the jet streams.
