0
They are both equally good, it just depends on your preference of legendary Pokemon. If you want to catch Lugia first, then you would choose SoulSilver, but if you want to catch Ho-oh first, you would choose HeartGold (you can catch both legendary Pokemon in both games, just at different times and different levels).
Some people prefer to buy the version that corresponded to the version they had when they were younger, i.e., if they had the original Silver version, they would get SoulSilver.
Another deciding factor for some players is the availability of certain Pokemon in-game. There are many version-exclusive Pokemon in each game that requires you to trade from the opposite version of the game.
In SoulSilver, version-specific Pokemon include Meowth, Kabuto and Groudon while HeartGold offers Growlithe, Omanyte and Kyogre in their place. Numerically, HeartGold offers more version-exclusive Pokemon than SoulSilver due to fourth generation evolutions and pre-evolutions added to two of the original Silver version Pokemon (Mantine and Gligar earned Mantyke and Gliscor, respectively).
What else can I help you with?
What game is Pokemon Tyranitar in?
heartgold & soulsilver.
How do you become a Gym Leader in Pokemon HeartGold SoulSilver?
You CAN NOT become a Gym Leader in Pokemon HeartGold and SoulSilver or ANY MAIN SERIES POKEMON GAME.
What Pokemon game is Charizard in?
heartgold & soulsilver,i guess.
Can you get Pokemon SoulSilver and HeartGold in English?
Of course you can. Heartgold and Soulsilver will come out in many countries and you will get the game in the language you speak in
Should you get Pokemon SoulSilver?
Pokemon soulsilver and Pokemon heartgold are basically the same game just different versions but i do recommend buying Pokemon soulsilver
What Pokemon appear exclusively in each version of HeartGold and SoulSilver that the other game won't have?
Pokemon Heartgold will have Ho-oh, which Soulsilver doesn't. On the other hand, Soulsilver has Lugia.
Trade Pokemon HeartGold and SoulSilver?
yes if it a ds game
Is a new Pokemon game for DS coming out?
yes Pokemon heartgold and soulsilver
What is the next Pokemon game after heartgold and soulsilver?
Pokemon ranger tracks of light
What is the best Pokemon game to train your Pokemon in?
soulsilver and heartgold, it has the most trainers
How do you get Dialga on Pokemon HeartGold soulsilver?
You cant, you have to trade him from a Pokemon Diamond game.
Is there going to be a Pokemon coarl?
no there is not a Pokemon coal the next Pokemon game is Pokemon heartgold and soulsilver
