Germany in WW2
Adjectives and Articles

What is Holocaust denial?

Top Answer
User Avatar
Wiki User
Answered 2010-06-29 20:10:43

The idea or belief that the Holocaust never took place, or that certain facts surrounding the Holocaust have been fabricated or greatly exaggerated.

Some further pointsIn addition to outright denial of the Holocaust, the following are also widely considered forms of Holocaust denial:

1. Claims that the number of victims was much smaller than the widely accepted figure of about six million.

2. Claims that the Holocaust was carried out purely on the initiative of Himmler and the SS without Hitler's approval or knowledge.

The first of these is an attempt to address what we historically accept as truth, with the facts that have surfaced and contradict this number. The second is an attempt to present it as mismanaged group of renegades.

Still More Points

1. Multiple chemical analysis's have shown low levels of cyanide residues in the gas chambers. These are compared against delousing facilities which used the same gas to kill lice. They are also compared against barracks. [[CITATION NEEDED]]

2. There are claims about the two most famous gas chambers in the Auschwitz Birkenau camp that the Zyklon B gas pellets were introduced through holes in the roof of the gas chamber. When first examined there were no holes in the roof. The Allies eventually knocked holes in the roof, but these are clearly not in the correct place because the rebar was still in tact. Attempts at scanning the roofs with a Ground Penetrating Radar have been refused by the Curators and other hostile parties.

Another interesting point is that the Nazis demolished these buildings, along with many others, with explosives. If these holes had existed, a structural engineer pointed out, they would have left fractures starting at the holes. [[CITATION NEEDED]]

3. The very creator of the same Birkenau gas chambers was tried and found not guilty. He points out that not only were these buildings not built as gas chambers they were incapable of ever becoming gas chambers.

4. The Auschwitz Stammlager Gas Chamber was built after the war by the Polish military. There are pictures in existence of it's construction and can be found in a few books.

5. The camp death books do not suggest that anything near 6 million people, let alone Jewish people, died.

6. There are conflicting pre and post war head counts of the Jews. This is important because the pre and post war head counts are the only source of the 6 million figure. There are not 6 million names or bodies or ashes to back the 6 million.

7. Several holocaust historians have written "Scholarly" works that detail how many died in each camp. The problem is that none of them actually agree with each other.

So either they are making the numbers up, or they all have different data.

8. It's claimed that as many 1/3 of the dead were, at one point, buried in Treblinka. A ground penetrating radar and core samples all show that no such grave ever existed in that area.

9. Holocaust survivors often tell tales that do not match evidence or are even in tune with reality. One of the more popular tales is of a woman who claims she survived by living with wolves. Another is of the married couple who went on national television to tell how they met in one camp, later discovered to be frauds. These are only two of the most popular and obvious tale tellers.

10. Mathematical analysis of the cremation process, what was available to the Nazis, and time do not suggest that they could have disposed of so many dead bodies through cremation.

There are many more arguments used by deniers, some of them very strong and logical, but until a bipartisan and more professional research effort is carried out it's unlikely we will ever know if they are right or wrong.

User Avatar

Your Answer

Still Have Questions?

Related Questions

What are the arguments for and against the Holocaust denial?

There is no rational justification for Holocaust denial.

What has the author John C Zimmerman written?

John C. Zimmerman has written: 'Holocaust denial' -- subject(s): History and criticism, Holocaust denial, Holocaust denial literature

Where has laws against Holocaust denial?

In places such as Germany and Israel, Holocaust Denial is illegal. Please See Related Links below.

What do Muslims believe about the Holocaust?

Holocaust denial is popular among many in the Middle East.

Where is the Holocaust denial active today?

Holocaust denial is most active in United States, because of freedom of speech (First Amendment) Despite what people may think, Holocaust denial and swastikas are illegal in Germany and those who disobey this law are often fined and temporarily imprisoned.

What is denial and example of denial?

Denial - outright rejection. --- Note that denial is also used in the sense of dogmatic refusal to believe (something). Well known examples include Holocaust denial and climate change denial.

Should holocaust denial be considered hate speech?


Why is Holocaust denial illegal?

In the vast majority of countries, including the US and UK, there is no law against Holocaust denial. In Germany, Austria and some other countries, public denial of the Holocaust is banned on the grounds that it is tantamount to an attempt to rehabilitate the Nazis (with a view to restoring them) and on the grounds that it is a form of Jew-baiting. Please see the link.

Is the word holocaust denial a noun or adjective or verb?

Holocaust in this term is used as an adjective describing the noun denial.A noun functioning as an adjective to describe another noun, called an attributive noun.

What has been done to support the Holocaust denial?

America fought Germany for the end of the Holocaust, you can learn more if you research more about the Holocaust end and WW2.

Why is there Holocaust denial?

While the key reasons for Holocaust denial are varied, the three main reasons given stem from (1) a desire to rehabilitate the Nazis, (2) antisemitism, or (3) the belief that facts surrounding the Holocaust have been fabricated or drastically exaggerated.Also, to be clear, Holocaust denial is a politically-motivated viewpoint; it is not an academic historical subject. That is, Holocaust denial is not a valid "alternate" interpretation of history, and has no place in historical studies. Historians reject the "study" of Holocaust denial as invalid (in the same way that they reject the "study" of dinosaurs living side-by-side with humans, in that neither has any basis in fact).Holocaust denial is rooted in certain beliefs which are political in nature - that is, Holocaust denial is a socio-political phenomena, and as such part of sociology and political science, NOT history. The distinction is important, as history deals with the interpretation of established factual events, while sociology and political science deal with human ideas and psychology of large groups, and are not concerned with the veracity of those idea's underlying assumptions.

Who denied the Holocaust deniers?

Deborah Lipstadt and Richard J. Evans, among others, have written about (and against) Holocaust denial.

Should people be prosecuted for not believing the Holocaust?

No.There is a lot of misunderstanding about laws against Holocaust denial. In countries that have such laws (for example, Germany) there is no requirement for "believing in the Holocaust". The prohibition or ban is on publicly denying it. The laws do not say "Thou shalt believe in the Holocaust".Nevertheless, this is a restriction on freedom of speech ...Incidentally, contrary to a widespread misconception, Britain has no law against Holocaust denial.

When did the Holocaust denial start?

Holocaust denial began while it was happening, early 40s. The Allies did not believe it until they saw it for themselves. Knowing future generations would be in doubt, they tried to film and document as much as possible.

What happens in certain countries if you deny the Holocaust?

There are about 15 countries in Europe (including Germany, France, Austria and Switzerland) which have penalties for public Holocaust denial.

How did the US feel about the Holocaust?

Mostly denial until after the war and U.S. troops found evidence.

How did Holocaust denial start?

The Nazi regime itself took steps to hush up the holocaust. The extermination was supposed to be kept secret ... The extermination camps at Belzec and Treblinka were destroyed in 1943 ... When Soviet forces approached Auschwitz, the gas chambers were blown up and records destroyed - by the Nazis. A few mavericks and cranks denied the Holocaust in the 1960s but gained little attention. Holocaust denial on a large scale started in the 1970s. It went hand in hand with claims that Zionists had exaggerated the Holocaust in order to win sympathy internationally for the creation of the state of Israel in 1948. This made Holocaust denial popular in much of the Middle East.

Who is profiting from the denial of Holocaust?

You as a tax payer! There is very little profit to be made from exposing the truth of the Holocaust. The motive is to stop the endless funding (and wars) for Israel and their war crimes.

Is it illegal to talk about the Holocaust in Germany?

No. Holocaust denial in public, however, is forbidden by law and carries a maximum penalty of 3 years in prison. However, prosecutions are very rare.

Is it wrong to give a Jewish girl a book about the holocaust?

No. It is perfectly alright to give a Jewish girl a book about the Holocaust, provided it is an accurate book about the Holocaust (as opposed to a Holocaust Denial book). However, bear in mind that the Holocaust is a depressing topic and so it might be less than optimal to give a Holocaust book as a present on a special occasion.

How do people feel about the Holocaust Denial?

Ludicrous but understandable. We should all be ashamed it happened because humans were capable of it but if denial ever becomes common belief of the majority we may be doomed to repeat it

Is it illegal to deny the Holocaust in Germany?

Yes it is, as well as 12 other countries. (Note that this relates to public denial).

Does Israel censor the internet?

Israel censors Holocaust-denial websites. This is the extent of it, after a failed law change attempt.

What has the author Werner Cohn written?

Werner Cohn has written: 'Partners in hate' -- subject(s): Holocaust denial

Why do some historians have different ideas about what happened to the Jews?

It is about valuing one source, or type of source over another. They more have different ideas over why things happened, there is almost complete agreement over what happened. If the question refers specifically to the Holocaust, there is a need to separate out those historians who disagree over the interpretation of the actual evidence and those who ignore large parts of evidence because of their political agendas. Failure to recognize the magnitude or scope of the Holocaust is commonly called Holocaust Denial. Typically any number less than 4.5 million Jews as the death toll in the Holocaust (usually less than 1 million) is indicative of Holocaust Denial. The most common reason for Holocaust Denial is in order to delegitimize the State of Israel. In their view, the only reason why Israel is a legitimate country is because of the Holocaust and therefore if the Holocaust is shown to be false, Israel's raison d'etre melts away. (The argument is flawed since Zionism existed before the Holocaust and also helped numerous Jews in the Arab World who were not part of the Holocaust.) The other group that routinely engages in Holocaust Denial are Anti-Semites who see the Holocaust as a means for Jews to gain sympathy.

Still have questions?