answersLogoWhite

0

Macbeth did not have a confrontation with the Thane of Cawdor. The general Ross is talking about in Act 1 Scene 2 is someone else. Ross says, "Norway himself, assisted by that most disloyal traitor, the Thane of Cawdor, began a dismal conflict, till that Bellona's bridegroom, lapp'd in proof, confronted him with self-comparisons, point against point rebellious, arm 'gainst arm, curbing his lavish spirit, and, to conclude, the victory fell on us." Macbeth is not mentioned. For good reason, because "Bellona's bridegroom" is someone else. We know that for a number of reasons.

First, the battle described by the bloody sergeant took place at Forres. Macbeth defeated Macdonwald at this battle. The battle Ross is talking about took place at Fife, which is about 140 miles away by modern roads. Ross has come from the end of the battle at Fife as fast as he can to Forres to bring the news to the king. It is unthinkable that Macbeth could have made the same trip (which would take about 14 hours by horseback) and have arrived at the beginning of a battle in Forres many hours before Ross.

Second, Macbeth does not know that Cawdor is a traitor until Ross tells him as much in Act 1 Scene 4. When the witches call him Thane of Cawdor, Macbeth says, "The Thane of Cawdor lives, a prosperous gentleman," and when Ross tells him he is the Thane of Cawdor, he says, "The Thane of Cawdor lives; why do you dress me in borrowed robes?" If Macbeth had captured Cawdor it would be ridiculous to describe him as a "prosperous gentleman" and not know why Cawdor is about to be stripped of his title.

Third, not only does Macbeth's reaction show that he has no idea of Cawdor's treachery, but Ross's reaction to him shows that Ross knows that Macbeth knows nothing of Cawdor's treachery. When Macbeth says that Cawdor is still alive, Ross says, "Who was the thane lives yet, but under heavy judgement bears that life which he deserves to lose. Whether he was combined with those of Norway, or did line the rebel with hidden help and vantage, or that with both he labour'd in his country's wreck, I know not. But treasons capital, confess'd and proved, have overthrown him." Would Ross have made this explanation if Macbeth had confronted the Thane of Cawdor in any way at all? Of course not! It would be ridiculous. It would be like telling Elliot Ness the news that someone has captured Al Capone for doing something illegal. If Macbeth had defeated Cawdor, and Ross had reported the same to Duncan, Ross would not have to make any explanation at all to Macbeth. He would instead have been asking Macbeth for details of Cawdor's treachery.

Finally, after the sergeant has told us all about what a great general Macbeth is, and how good at splitting people from the nave to the chaps, what would be the point of having another character say exactly the same thing about him? This would be to gild refined gold or to paint the lily. It would be superfluous. The mature Shakespeare does not write superfluous lines. Ross's report is included in the scene for quite another purpose than to heap further praise upon Macbeth (without ever naming him). Duncan must hear about Cawdor's treachery so that he can give the title to Macbeth. Ross's story of the defeat of the Norwegians at Fife, including the treachery of Cawdor, brings that news to Duncan. It is irrelevant who won the battle at Fife, so he is called "Bellona's bridegroom".

User Avatar

Wiki User

11y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

What was the title that duncan gave to Macbeth?

Some people might think that Duncan gives this title to Macbeth because Macbeth was instrumental in capturing the traitor Thane of Cawdor. But this is wrong. The Thane of Ross brings the news to Duncan of Cawdor's treachery but does not name Macbeth as the man that captures him. Ross is then told to find Macbeth and tell him that he is now the Thane of Cawdor. When Ross tells him this, Macbeth is astonished: he says "The thane of Cawdor lives--a prosperous gentleman! Why do you dress me in borrowed robes?" He would not have been astonished had he been the man to capture Cawdor. What is more, Ross is not surprised that he is astonished, because Ross knows that Macbeth has not yet heard of Cawdor's treachery. It is possible that Duncan misunderstood Ross's report and believed that Macbeth could simultaneously be in Forres (in northern Scotland) and Fife (in southern Scotland) fighting two different battles at the same time. If he was that much of a dimwit about the geography of the country he was supposed to be king of, then he might have rewarded Macbeth for something he did not do. It is far more likely that Macbeth receives the title either because Duncan wants to reward the brave and victorious Macbeth who defeated Macdonweald, or that his choice of Macbeth as the recipient is entirely arbitrary.


What is significant about Macbeth receiving the title of 'thane of cawdor'?

Well the three witches tell him that he will be thane of cawdor and king someday but he doesn't really believe them. So after receiving the news that he is thane of cawdor he starts to think that maybe the witches were telling the truth and he will be king. This then leads to him killing the King so that he can become King like the witches told him.


What do the witches tell Macbeth he will be?

King of Scotland the witches also say that he will become the thane of cawdor


What do Ross and Angus tell Macbeth in Act 1?

They tell him that he has been made Thane of Cawdor. They don't know that the witches have just finished poredicting this.


What three things does Macbeth tell lady Macbeth in his letter?

He told her about the three prophecies that he has been told by the witches. Thane of Cawdor, Thane of Glamis, and King of Scotland.


Does duncan make banquo thane of glamis?

No, Macbeth was already Thane of Glamis.Quote from original Mabeth scene 3."FIRST WITCH.All hail, Macbeth! hail to thee, Thane of Glamis!SECOND WITCH.All hail, Macbeth! hail to thee, Thane of Cawdor!THIRD WITCH.All hail, Macbeth! that shalt be king hereafter!""MACBETH.Stay, you imperfect speakers, tell me more:By Sinel's death I know I am Thane of Glamis;But how of Cawdor? The Thane of Cawdor lives...":)


What does Macbeth decide to do with the information that angus and ross tell him?

The information they bring (in Act 1 scene 3) is that Macbeth has been made Thane of Cawdor. What Macbeth does with this information is to pass it on to his wife.


What war crime was the Thane of Cawdor guilty of in Macbeth Act l?

Macbeth and his wife plotted to Kill King Duncan, Thane of Cawdor. Lady Macbeth could not complete the action because of the King's resemblance to her father, so Macbeth plunged a dagger in his heart. Macbeth also murdered his friend Banquo because he feared that Banquo would tell someone about Macbeth possibly becoming the King of Cawdor. The witches said that his sons would be king, so this was the beginning of Macbeths elimination process to ensure his taking of the crown. In act four, Macbeth hires the three best murderers to kill Macduff's wife and son. He does this beause he discovered That Macduff had fled to King Duncan's son in England. Macbeth is suspicious that his downfall might be coming.


Who tells Macbeth the news of his promotion?

Ross. He is often a messenger in Macbeth. He brings the news from Fife to Forres of a battle down south. He brings Lady Macduff the news that she should try to flee and also to Macduff that his wife and children have been killed.


What are the three prophecies given to Macbeth?

The 3 Witches recount to Macbeth three prophecies:Thane of Glamis(he already is)Thane of CordorKing here afterProphecies to Banquo:1.Macbeth is great, but you are greater2.You will be happier than Macbeth3.You won't be king, but your children will be.


How important are the 3 witches in building up Macbeth as the tragic hero?

The witches don't make Macbeth perform any dark acts, such as killing King Duncan; they just put the idea in his head. The witches tell Macbeth he is the Thane of Cawdor (which he doesn't know yet) and also tell him that he will be king. Once Macbeth finds out he is in fact the Thane of Cawdor, he begins to believe the witches' prophecies. Lady Macbeth convinces him that the only way Macbeth can be king is by killing King Duncan, and he does so. The witches' role in making Macbeth a tragic hero is to serve a catalyst for Macbeth's dark thoughts.


How do the three witches gain Macbeth's trust?

I have only recently started learning about macbeth, but i think that the three witches gain his trust by when they tell him that he is to become the thane of cawdor, he almost immediatley becomes thane. so he believes that they are actually telling the truth- hope this helps x