answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

If what they're saying is irrelevant to the case or if they're suggesting an opinion on something that they are not an expert on, this is why you see doctors and ballistics experts etc used in cases because only an expert is allowed to state their opinion

User Avatar

Wiki User

9y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: When is testimonial evidence not reliable?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

What is civil testimonial evidence?

Testimonial Evidence is, a recounting of events/criminal activity witnessed by someone at or near the scene of the crime. Police Reorts can be used as 'Testimonial Evidence'.


What are the two common types of evidence in a civil suit?

The two common types of evidence in a civil suit are testimonial evidence, which includes witness testimony, and documentary evidence, which consists of written records, photographs, emails, contracts, or any other physical evidence that can be presented in court.


What are the different types of evidence in court?

The four general types of evidence are: -Anecdotal Evidence - Testimonial Evidence - Statistical Evidence - Analogical Evidence Links to articles which can provide you with a clearer answer and descriptions are below.


What is the difference between real evidence and demonstrative evidence?

By "real evidence" I assume you mean evidence given by a witness verbally under oath on the witness stand. That is called testimonial evidence. In any event there are two types of evidence. One is testimonial evidence and one is demonstrative evidence. Testimonial evidence is simply evidence given by a person testifying verbally under oath or affirmation. Demonstrative evidence is taken from inanimate objects that demonstrate some particular fact. In a typical Law and Order episode the witness who testifies he saw the defendant shoot the victim is providing testimonial evidence. Exhibit A, the murder weapon with the defendant's fingerprints on it is demonstrative evidence, because it demonstrates that the defendant had the weapon in his hand. Both are real evidence as the defendant will shortly be very unhappy to learn.


If a witness testifies to having heard gunshots this is an example of what type of evidence?

If the witness is testifying that HE heard the gunshots - it is called "direct evidence.' It is also a type called "testimonial" evidence as opposed to "demonstative" evidence. The testimonial evidence is that the witness testifies verbally that he heard the gun. The gun itself if entered into evidence would be demonstrative evidence.


What is the difference between testimonial and physical evidence?

Evidence in criminal law is any item or testimony that assists in the proof of a prosecution or defense. It can be a weapon, a document, forensic samples or the testimony of a witness, and both sides of a criminal case are allowed to present evidence to the court for consideration. Real evidence is physical evidence, such as a gun, a fingerprint, a photograph, or DNA machine, different from testimonial evidence because it not physical object only is the testimony of a witness.


What does your water smell like when it breaks?

According to subjective, testimonial evidence, it tends to have little or no odor.


What kind of evidence is testimony?

Testimonial evidence is evidence given by a witness of things they've experienced first-hand. The first-hand account of a witness is called their testimony.


Is non testimonial evidence admissible in court?

Yes. Examples might be the results of drug lab or DNA tests. Evidence attempting to be introduced as 'non-testimonial' faces scrutiny and challenge to determine whether it is admissible, or not under the rules of "hearsay" evidence.The US Supreme Court differentiated between "testimonial" and "non-testimonial" witness statements in Crawford v. Washington, (2004) and Davis v. Washington with Hammon v. Indiana, (2006). For more information on these cases, see Related Questions, below.


Is non-testimonial evidence admissible in court?

From "Criminal Procedure & Constitutional Protections" (Second Edition) Non Testimonial Evidence: "Evidence that does not come from the mouth of a witness and may include conduct; physical evidence that may have the operative effect of proving guilt but has not been deemed to have the same effect as speech" Examples: Blood alcohol test, physical test to identify if a suspect is intoxicated. See case Schmerber v California, 384 U.S. 757 (1966)


How reliable is DNA fingerprinting?

It is not infallable, but it is considered reliable enough to be use as evidence.


What propaganda technique is used in this example My doctor told me not to eat cotton candy?

This is an example of using an appeal to authority propaganda technique. By referencing a doctor as an authority figure, the statement implies that eating cotton candy is not advisable because someone knowledgeable in the field of health has cautioned against it.