Fourth Universalist Society of New York was created in 1838.
Lou Gehrig's ancestory is German; both of his parents were born in Germany. According to Jonathan Eig in his book Luckiest Man: "He (Lou) had not been raised on literature or even on the intellectual concepts connected with organized religion. There is no indication that he or his parents ever practiced as Lutherans."However, Gehrig was a parishioner of the Fourth Universalist Society of New York. So I presume he was a Universalist.I can't post links, but the Wikipedia article on the Fourth Universalist Society confirms this.
New York Psychoanalytic Society was created in 1911.
New-York Historical Society was created in 1804.
New York Pathological Society was created in 1844.
Japan Society - New York - was created in 1971.
Linnaean Society of New York was created in 1878.
New York Society Library was created in 1754.
Handel Society of New York was created in 1966.
New York Manumission Society was created in 1785.
New York Society of Model Engineers was created in 1926.
Community Service Society of New York was created in 1838.
New York Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children was created in 1874.