Want this question answered?
First Methodist Church of Burlington was created in 1869.
First Methodist Church of Batavia was created in 1852.
The First Methodist Episcopal Church of Pokagon was created in 1837.
First Methodist Episcopal Church of Nyack was created in 1813.
Eufaula First United Methodist Church was created in 1917.
First Methodist Episcopal Church of Rome was created in 1868.
First United Methodist Church of Columbia was created in 1873.
Salem First United Methodist Church was created in 1878.
First Methodist Episcopal Church of Parksville was created in 1898.
First Methodist Episcopal Church of Avon was created in 1879.
I was in that situation 25 years ago. Methodist churches do have some that are more evangelical than others. If you can find an evangelical Methodist church, usually smaller than the "First Methodist of the City," then that would be the best of the compromise. Not to step on any toes but my spouse found the baptist churches in our southern town to be too judgmental for her Methodist upbringing. I found the Methodist church acceptable to my divergent beliefs in Bible study and I could still believe as a conservative baptist while still a member in the Methodist church.
First Methodist Episcopal Church of Tioga Center was created in 1873.