New York Mutuals was created in 1857.
New York Mutuals ended in 1876.
George Fair debuted on July 29, 1876, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn); he played his final game on July 29, 1876, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn).
John Hatfield debuted on May 18, 1871, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn); he played his final game on May 5, 1876, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn).
Alfred Metcalfe debuted on May 27, 1875, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn); he played his final game on June 17, 1875, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn).
Charlie Mills debuted on May 18, 1871, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn); he played his final game on September 28, 1872, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn).
Jim Shanley debuted on May 3, 1876, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn); he played his final game on May 4, 1876, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn).
Charlie Smith debuted on May 18, 1871, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn); he played his final game on August 1, 1871, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn).
Pete Treacey debuted on August 5, 1876, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn); he played his final game on August 7, 1876, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn).
Bob Valentine debuted on May 20, 1876, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn); he played his final game on May 20, 1876, playing for the New York Mutuals at Union Grounds (Brooklyn).
In 1876, Davy Force played in 1 game for the New York Mutuals. He had 3 at bats, getting 0 hits, for a .000 batting average, with 0 runs batted in. He was walked 0 times. He struck out 0 times.
In 1876, Nealy Phelps played in 1 game for the New York Mutuals. He had 3 at bats, getting 0 hits, for a .000 batting average, with 0 runs batted in. He was walked 0 times. He struck out 1 times.
Bob Ferguson played in just one game at pitcher for the New York Mutuals in 1871 and did not start. He made no putouts, had no assists, and committed no errors, equivalent to 0 errors per game (estimate based on total games played in). He had no double plays.