There aren't five pieces of paper there all only 2
I think you go on Skullduggery and there is a secret island that appears on the map after all five pieces are assembled.
Five
use your map to travel to islands and solve puzzles and you should get a little map piece in each island and you could even beat captain crawfish and complete the island
Ream
five gems
There are five jewels missing
There is a secret island on Skullduggery Island, and in fact that is its name : Skullduggery. It will appear on the treasure map (and actually in the open sea) when all five pieces of the map are assembled. It is near the bottom center, between the Pirate Outpost and Golden Harbor.
after you defeat five of the criminals
you go to athena and give it to her
The code on Big Nate's Island is three nine zero five. Or I could be wrong and it is nine three zero five. Try them Both! But to open the locker You need all of the comic pieces.
You can fly with the JETPACK on Early Poptropica. You can fly after capturing five supervillains on Super Power Island. Unfortunately, these abilities work only on their respective islands.
Defeat five supervillains on super power island and answer the pay phone.