Cuyler was in the former Central New York Military Tract. The town was first settled around 1794. The town was formed from part of the Town of Truxton in 1858. In 1865, the population of the town was 1,447.
The town in New York that the New York Inn is located in Manhattan. New York Inn is a walking distance to many sight attractions in NY. This Inn is surrounded by the Rockfeller centre, to enjoy ice skating activity. There is also Broadway Theatre and Madison Square.