GTA4 definitely.
From a personal point of view: Red Dead Redemption is a terrific game, well worth buying; but GTA IV is better, in my opinion.
no GTA 4 is the best game ever until RED DEAD REDEMPTION.
red dead for funny glitches involving story and a stereo typicall Irish man called Irish GTA for swearing rudeness repetative game play and an Irish man called paky DONT ASK
red dead redemption is much better
Red Dead Redemption uses the Rockstar Advanced Game Engine (RAGE), which is the same engine used in GTA IV and Max Payne 3.
The game is new and that gives you a better chance to get to know the game. Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2 was released over 6 months ago and the people who play it also had the experience of the earlier versions of Call of Duty. Red Dead Redemption is very highly rated and shows every sign of being a top selling game. Whether it better is more of an opinion and is not important in answering the question is it worth buying.
Most people would agree that red dead redemption is the better game on most accounts
i have both and i believe red dead redemption is a lot better as on mafia a lot of the missions are very similar whereas there is a lot more variety in red dead redemption. also red dead redemption has a much better and interactive environment
The answer here is completely dependent on your game style, but I would say Red Dead Redemption.
I believe that red dead redempion is better because it has a amazing campaign and you can do everything you wont
It's a matter of opinion.Red Dead has Zombies.GTA 4 has fast cars.Personally, I'm saving up for GTA 4.
If you like huge free-roaming rpg and third person shooter games then this is probably the best and is better that gta