Who is the Best American Idol?
Kelly Clarkson by far!!! Everybody will have a different answer to that question. Personally, I definitely think all of the girls are better. I personally don't have a favorite. I do know that my least favorite is Taylor Hicks, though. ~Nomnom~
If you look at record sales and things of that such you have to go with Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood. Not just as winners but all around record sales of all American Idol Contestants. Though I am huge fans of both Carrie and Kellie I don't think either of them are the most talented to ever be in the competition of all seasons. But that doesn't degrade what they've done with their careers or their record sales. So I think it's all your own opinion and we all can view it in our own ways. But then the record sales really don't lie, or the Grammy awards in which they both have. Answer: David Cook Definitely!