Baseball History

Who is the second best fielding first baseman of all-time?

Answer

Wiki User
02/13/2008

This would depend on how many games your going by. Here's a list of the top 1st baseman that played at least 100 games at that position:

CAREER

1B

GAMES >= 100

FIELDING PERCENTAGE PCT G

1 Herbert Perry 1.000 114

2 Ruben Amaro .997 169

3 Travis Lee .997 1018

4 Denis Menke .997 162

5 Scot Thompson .997 136

6 Nomar Garciaparra .996 118

7 John Boccabella .996 142

8 Joe Hague .996 232

9 Brad Wilkerson .996 161

10 Jim Holt .996 177

T11 Doug Mientkiewicz .996 849

T11 Mark Teixeira .996 572

13 Steve Garvey .996 2059

14 Dick Williams .996 188

15 Scott Spiezio .996 460

16 Ron Coomer .996 408

17 Don Mattingly .996 1634

18 Mike Aldrete .996 286

19 Todd Helton .996 1384

20 Kevin Youkilis .996 136

21 Wes Parker .996 1108

22 Mike Laga .996 123

23 Roberto Petagine .996 133

24 Tom Hutton .995 499

25 J.T. Snow .995 1656

26 Jeff King .995 488

27 Darin Erstad .995 581

28 David Segui .995 1121

29 Pete Ward .995 113

30 John Olerud .995 2053

31 Shawn Green .995 125

32 Sean Casey .995 1137

33 Rico Brogna .995 817

34 Bobby Tolan .995 130

35 Davey Johnson .995 123

36 Don Pavletich .995 159

37 Tino Martinez .995 1869

38 Dan Driessen .995 1375

39 Rocky Nelson .995 386

40 Mike Squires .995 688

41 Jim Spencer .995 1221

42 Paul Konerko .995 1073

43 Carney Lansford .995 124

44 Mike Hegan .995 553

45 Del Unser .995 168

46 Frank McCormick .995 1448

47 Adam LaRoche .995 365

48 B.J. Surhoff .995 158

49 John Kruk .995 678

50 Mark Grace .995 2162

51 Dick Phillips .995 135

52 Don Money .995 108

53 John Mabry .994 451

54 Wil Cordero .994 265

55 Todd Benzinger .994 622

56 Wally Joyner .994 1913

57 Steve Cox .994 216

58 Jim Marshall .994 202

59 Rafael Palmeiro .994 2139

60 Pete Runnels .994 644

61 Rick Leach .994 213

62 Dane Iorg .994 114

63 Keith Hernandez .994 2014

64 Dan Johnson .994 186

65 Carl Yastrzemski .994 765

66 Vic Power .994 1304

67 Kent Hrbek .994 1609

68 Derrek Lee .994 1205

69 Lance Berkman .994 215

70 Nick Swisher .994 114

71 Bob Horner .994 330

72 Ed Goodson .994 176

73 Bob Robertson .994 602

74 Pete Rose .994 939

75 Bill Sweeney .994 255

76 Joe Adcock .994 1501

77 John Wathan .994 196

78 Gregg Jefferies .994 380

79 Charlie Hayes .994 132

80 Brook Jacoby .994 153

81 Justin Morneau .994 359

82 Lew Fonseca .994 375

83 Greg Brock .994 942

84 Dalton Jones .994 158

85 Pete O'Brien .994 1377

86 Mike Jorgensen .994 1052

87 Ernie Banks .994 1259

88 Robin Ventura .994 162

89 Archi Cianfrocco .994 235

90 Chris Shelton .994 207

91 John Mayberry .994 1478

92 Eduardo Perez .994 296

93 Paul Sorrento .994 806

94 Kevin Seitzer .994 241

95 Tommy Gregg .994 103

96 Lee May .994 1507

97 Ed Kranepool .994 1304

98 Mike Rocco .994 431

99 Jim Thome .994 1100

100 Hal Morris .994 982

101 Richie Sexson .994 990

102 Kevin Millar .994 523

103 Adrian Gonzalez .994 176

104 Danny Cater .994 731

105 Dave Magadan .994 593

106 Bill Freehan .994 157

107 Scott Stahoviak .994 268

108 Leon Durham .994 618

109 Tom Paciorek .994 396

110 Jim Fregosi .994 190

111 Nick Esasky .993 478

112 Richie Hebner .993 415

113 Mike Ivie .993 602

114 Olmedo Saenz .993 228

115 Mark McGwire .993 1764

116 Albert Pujols .993 577

117 Greg Norton .993 191

118 Broderick Perkins .993 306

119 Jeff Bagwell .993 2111

120 Mike Blowers .993 108

121 Tim Corcoran .993 183

122 Jim Traber .993 155

123 Chris Chambliss .993 1962

124 Lyle Overbay .993 532

125 John Jaha .993 519

126 Jason Phillips .993 149

127 Carlos Pena .993 460

128 George Brett .993 461

129 Joe Judge .993 2084

130 Joe Pepitone .993 953

131 Joe Cunningham .993 607

132 Mark Loretta .993 171

133 Pat Putnam .993 508

134 Gene Tenace .993 625

135 Daryle Ward .993 241

136 Joe Torre .993 787

137 Eric Karros .993 1698

138 Ted Kluszewski .993 1481

139 Scott Hatteberg .993 551

140 Eddie Murray .993 2413

141 Chuck Stevens .993 209

142 Greg Colbrunn .993 739

143 Greg Walker .993 689

144 George Hendrick .993 121

145 Frank Torre .993 564

146 Deron Johnson .993 880

147 Eddie Waitkus .993 1049

148 Tony Solaita .993 281

149 Craig Wilson .993 262

150 Tony Clark .993 1081

151 Ron Jackson .993 552

152 Cliff Johnson .993 189

153 Charlie Grimm .993 2131

154 Julio Becquer .993 240

155 Robb Quinlan .993 109

156 Mike Lum .993 284

157 Tony Lupien .993 602

158 Walter Holke .993 1193

159 Roger Repoz .993 107

160 Joe Stripp .993 163

161 Norm Zauchin .993 307

162 Dave Stapleton .993 318

163 Ricky Jordan .993 510

164 Elbie Fletcher .993 1380

165 Stuffy McInnis .993 1995

166 Will Clark .992 1889

167 Gil Hodges .992 1908

168 Andre Thornton .992 729

169 Tony Perez .992 1778

170 Hee Seop Choi .992 286

171 Hank Arft .992 260

172 Bill Robinson .992 201

173 Eric Hinske .992 116

174 Zeke Bonura .992 900

175 Bill White .992 1477

176 Jason Thompson .992 1314

177 Jack Burns .992 879

178 Ray Knight .992 339

179 Rich Reese .992 640

180 Enos Cabell .992 655

181 Gene Larkin .992 293

182 Bob Burda .992 106

183 George McQuinn .992 1529

184 Darrell Evans .992 856

185 Julio Franco .992 492

186 Kerby Farrell .992 166

187 Bill Skowron .992 1463

188 Joe Lis .992 204

189 Tony Muser .992 505

190 Randall Simon .992 338

191 Jeff Conine .992 935

192 Jason Giambi .992 1040

193 Norm Cash .992 1943

T194 Alvin Davis .992 887

T194 Prince Fielder .992 159

196 Dick Nen .992 264

197 George Kelly .992 1373

198 Mike Marshall .992 180

199 Kevin Young .992 1049

200 Marv Blaylock .992 213

201 Bill Terry .992 1579

202 Wes Helms .992 236

203 Art Mahan .992 145

204 Randy Milligan .992 587

205 Ron Jackson .992 148

206 Bud Clancy .992 466

207 Willie Montanez .992 1164

208 Jose Offerman .992 260

209 Ripper Collins .992 894

210 Oscar Grimes .992 113

211 Ross Gload .992 121

212 Norm Siebern .992 827

213 Fred McGriff .992 2239

214 Matt Stairs .992 242

215 John Vander Wal .992 178

216 Mike Schmidt .992 157

217 Phil Todt .992 904

218 Carlos Delgado .992 1450

219 Jim Hickman .992 309

220 Stan Musial .992 1016

221 Terry Francona .992 304

222 Ben Broussard .992 479

223 Chick Gandil .992 1138

224 Dave Bergman .992 866

225 Ryan Howard .992 251

226 Gus Suhr .992 1406

227 Ed Stevens .992 345

228 Johnny Mize .992 1667

229 Sid Bream .992 954

230 Bill Buckner .992 1555

231 Jimmie Foxx .992 1919

232 Lee Stevens .992 777

233 Phil Nevin .992 336

234 Joe Kuhel .992 2057

235 Cecil Cooper .992 1475

236 Steve Bilko .992 479

237 Wally Pipp .992 1819

238 Shea Hillenbrand .992 365

239 Mike Stanley .992 302

240 Bruce Bochte .992 1008

241 Harley Boss .992 134

242 Ryan McGuire .992 177

243 Nick Johnson .992 502

244 Ed Kirkpatrick .992 149

245 Walt Dropo .992 1174

246 Warren Cromartie .992 263

247 Ryan Klesko .992 647

248 Harmon Killebrew .992 969

249 Cecil Fielder .992 905

250 Glenn Davis .991 870

251 Fritz Mollwitz .991 496

252 Brian Hunter .991 481

253 Bob Watson .991 1088

254 Harry Spilman .991 157

255 Jim Leyritz .991 149

256 John Milner .991 547

257 Jake Daubert .991 2002

258 Willie Stargell .991 848

259 Felipe Alou .991 468

260 Earl Sheely .991 1220

261 Denny Walling .991 273

262 Earl Williams .991 327

263 Norm Larker .991 483

264 Willie Aikens .991 547

265 Nate Colbert .991 890

266 Harry Simpson .991 211

267 Mike Jacobs .991 152

268 Boog Powell .991 1479

269 Ray Sanders .991 596

270 Lloyd McClendon .991 101

271 Andres Galarraga .991 2106

272 Hugh Bradley .991 225

273 Roy Sievers .991 888

274 Chuck Harrison .991 279

275 Mark Johnson .991 278

276 Chuck Hinton .991 160

277 Gail Hopkins .991 293

278 Rod Carew .991 1184

279 Raul Ibanez .991 135

280 Mark Carreon .991 191

281 Babe Borton .991 270

282 Bob Boyd .991 475

283 Nap Reyes .991 107

284 Ron Fairly .991 1218

285 Todd Zeile .991 466

286 Hank Greenberg .991 1138

287 Steve Lyons .991 115

288 Bob Oliver .991 423

289 Al Kaline .991 135

290 Mike Hargrove .991 1377

291 Carmelo Martinez .991 319

292 Lou Gehrig .991 2142

293 Ken Harvey .991 180

294 Mickey Mantle .991 262

295 Pete LaCock .991 447

296 Bert Haas .991 311

297 Hal Trosky .991 1321

298 Mike Epstein .991 823

299 Billy Goodman .991 406

300 Kevin Jordan .991 111

301 Keith Moreland .991 160

302 Dan Meyer .991 469

303 Frank Thomas .991 973

304 Tookie Gilbert .991 155

305 Tom McCraw .991 911

306 Dolph Camilli .990 1476

T307 Lance Niekro .990 135

T307 Lou Guisto .990 130

309 Don Mincher .990 1138

310 Joe Rudi .990 249

311 Johnny McCarthy .990 383

312 Dave Hansen .990 142

313 Von Hayes .990 401

314 Orlando Merced .990 418

315 Aubrey Huff .990 152

316 Pancho Herrera .990 260

317 Gordy Coleman .990 659

318 Rusty Staub .990 426

319 Paul Molitor .990 197

320 Dick Kryhoski .990 467

321 Bobby Bonilla .990 125

322 Lou Finney .990 415

323 Ed Konetchy .990 2073

324 Jeff Kent .990 116

325 Rudy York .990 1261

326 Joe Hauser .990 547

327 Mickey Vernon .990 2237

328 Chico Salmon .990 130

329 Joe Collins .990 715

330 George Scott .990 1773

331 Frank Brower .990 158

332 Tommie Aaron .990 232

333 Babe Dahlgren .990 1031

334 Carlos Quintana .990 340

335 Jim Gentile .990 854

336 Chuck Kress .990 129

337 Tommy Henrich .990 189

338 Willie Upshaw .990 1094

339 Phil Weintraub .990 293

340 Matt Franco .990 140

341 Ken Harrelson .990 469

342 Phil Cavarretta .990 1254

343 Johnny Sturm .990 124

344 Mike Sweeney .990 547

345 Dick Siebert .990 949

346 Bob Hamelin .990 138

347 Fred Whitfield .990 588

348 Dave Hostetler .990 131

349 Jackie Robinson .990 197

350 Chubby Dean .990 157

351 Gary Redus .990 237

352 Barbaro Garbey .990 109

353 Wayne Gross .990 151

354 Buck Jordan .990 648

355 Mark Sweeney .990 211

356 Les Fleming .990 325

357 David Green .990 198

358 Mike Lamb .990 203

359 Jack Clark .990 580

360 Eddie Robinson .990 1125

361 Dave McCarty .990 368

362 Brian Daubach .990 379

363 Marty Keough .990 130

364 Preston Ward .990 438

365 Tony Horton .990 555

T366 Gary Gaetti .990 138

T366 Orlando Cepeda .990 1683

368 Cliff Floyd .990 116

369 Hank Aaron .990 210

370 Hughie Miller .990 136

371 George Crowe .990 407

372 Billy Sullivan .990 127

373 Larry Biittner .990 381

374 Ray Schmandt .990 235

375 Hal Breeden .990 168

376 Al Oliver .990 733

377 Dick Gernert .990 604

378 Len Matuszek .990 155

379 Eddie Williams .989 167

380 Max West .989 161

381 Sam Leslie .989 589

382 Joe Harris .989 522

383 Steve Balboni .989 630

384 Jake Jones .989 211

385 Bill Glynn .989 264

386 Dan Pasqua .989 147

387 Wally Judnich .989 149

388 Harry Agganis .989 139

389 Kent Hadley .989 121

390 Frank Tepedino .989 134

391 David Ortiz .989 232

392 Babe Young .989 545

393 John Ellis .989 304

394 John Briggs .989 176

395 Doc Johnston .989 1023

T396 Kurt Bevacqua .989 129

T396 John Wockenfuss .989 184

398 Tito Francona .989 475

399 J.R. Phillips .989 134

400 Whitey Lockman .989 771

401 Dave Revering .989 454

402 Franklin Stubbs .989 522

403 Ray Webster .989 168

404 Russ Morman .989 129

405 Tony Bartirome .989 118

406 Howie Schultz .989 450

407 Tim Harkness .989 199

408 Brad Fullmer .989 293

409 Mickey Hatcher .989 149

410 Vic Wertz .989 715

411 Ham Hyatt .989 124

412 Dick Allen .989 807

413 Earl Torgeson .989 1416

414 Lamar Johnson .989 422

415 Ben Houser .989 129

416 Ray Grimes .989 426

417 Lu Blue .989 1571

418 Daryl Sconiers .989 119

419 Dan Briggs .989 152

420 Dan McGann .989 1376

421 Curt Blefary .989 253

422 Art Howe .988 130

423 Jim Bottomley .988 1885

424 Dale Alexander .988 617

425 Dale Long .988 819

426 Pat Tabler .988 444

427 Butch Schmidt .988 296

428 Dutch Schliebner .988 146

429 Dave Nilsson .988 166

430 Mo Vaughn .988 1305

T431 Craig Kusick .988 238

T431 Jimmy Dykes .988 148

433 Bob Bailey .988 138

434 Erubiel Durazo .988 236

435 Les Scarsella .988 197

436 Harry Davis .988 296

437 Joe Carter .988 308

438 Dee Fondy .988 874

439 Charlie Mullen .988 194

440 Harry Bright .988 137

441 Ray Boone .988 285

442 Dmitri Young .988 285

443 Doug Ault .988 183

444 Gene Paulette .988 377

445 George Grantham .988 502

446 Lee Thomas .988 425

447 Lou Limmer .988 137

448 Robert Fick .988 229

T449 Art Shires .988 254

T449 Roy Leslie .988 154

451 Pedro Guerrero .988 573

452 Ed Bouchee .988 611

453 Gerald Perry .988 656

454 Ivy Griffin .988 171

455 Dots Miller .988 737

456 Conor Jackson .988 149

457 Del Bissonette .988 598

458 Donn Clendenon .988 1200

459 Mike Fiore .988 151

460 Nick Etten .988 903

461 Andy Phillips .988 113

462 Gus Triandos .988 168

463 Ken Phelps .988 131

464 Roy Cullenbine .988 208

465 Nap Lajoie .988 286

466 Sam Vico .987 195

467 Willie McCovey .987 2045

468 Catfish Metkovich .987 289

469 Bobo Osborne .987 159

470 Wayne Belardi .987 149

471 Bob Chance .987 153

472 Frank Chance .987 997

473 Dave Collins .987 125

474 Jiggs Donahue .987 745

475 Don Hurst .987 863

476 Don Kolloway .987 314

477 John Ganzel .987 725

478 Marv Throneberry .987 307

479 Matty Alou .987 168

480 Danny Heep .987 131

481 Ferris Fain .987 1116

482 George Sisler .987 1971

483 Johnny Neun .987 231

484 Bob Skinner .987 151

485 Bunny Brief .987 146

486 John Leary .987 183

487 Hap Myers .987 353

488 Eddie Mathews .987 112

489 Jim Poole .987 255

490 Orestes Destrade .987 200

491 John Hummel .987 160

492 Ray Barker .987 124

493 Willard Brown .987 240

494 Bud Sharpe .987 118

495 Nippy Jones .987 333

496 Doc Hoblitzell .987 1284

497 George Burns .987 1660

498 Gordon Goldsberry .987 158

499 Mickey Tettleton .986 125

500 Dick Burrus .986 441