Who is the strongest juggernaut the hulk colossus rogue red hulk rhino?

Answer 1

Marvel rates their characters based on a scale of 1-7 (1-poor, 7-great) in these categories : Intelligence, strength, speed, durability, energy projection, and fighting skills. For this question, we're going to focus on the strength, speed, durability, and fighting skills ratings, as well as how their powers work.

• Juggernaut :

strength : 7

durability : 7

speed : 2

fighting skills : 4

• Colossus :

strength : 6

durability : 6

speed : 2

fighting skills : 4

• Rogue :

strength : 6 (potential 7)

durability : 6 (potential 7)

speed : 3 (potential 7)

fighting skills : 3 (potential 7)

• Hulk :

strength : 7

durability : 7

speed : 3

fighting skills : 4

• Red Hulk :

strength : 7

durability : 6

speed : 3

fighting skills : 4

• Rhino :

strength : 5

durability : 5

speed :3

fighting skills : 2

It's easy to see just from the stats, and the battle history of the character, but Rhino is the least formidable of these opponents, which isn't to say that he isn't strong or formidable. I personally wouldn't want to come across any of these on a bad day. Colossus is next on the list. He tops out on strength at a level 6 with no potential of getting higher, though his durability is impressive. However, against these others, it's not enough.

In fourth place, I would rank Juggernaut. While his strength and durability are impressive, his low level of speed is a problem. His battle history isn't very impressive either, losing often unless helped by others.

Now we get down to technicalities and splitting hairs. First, there are some questions that need to be answered.

1. Is Rogue fighting with just her base powers, or with the powers of someone she absorbed (i.e. Ms. Marvel's powers)?
2. Is Rogue able to absorb Red Hulk and Hulk's powers? This question is based off of the argument that she can't because they're based in radiation, not a super power, but she has been shown on several occasions doing just that (like when she absorbed She-Hulk and Spider-Man at the same time).
3. If she CAN'T absorb their powers because of the radiation, would her powers work on them like normal humans?

For the first question, we will examine both outcomes, simply because many fans of Rogue like her better with the Ms. Marvel powers. If that's the case, I think she could beat both of them and come out on top. With Ms. Marvel's super strength, speed, durability, and flight, she could get in close enough to touch one and absorb their powers, since her draining power tends to be fast. Also, if it proves that she can't absorb their powers, just their life force, it would be a tough battle but she would lose, because she would need to hold on for an extended period of time for them to be down. However, assuming that she's starting with her base powers, and didn't absorb any of the previous opponents, she would be squished.

However, Red Hulk is much more vulnerable to certain things like psychic attacks or bladed objects. If they're fighting in an arena with no make-shift weapons, Red Hulk could pull out over Rogue. However, if Rogue had access to something blade-like, I think she could manage a win.

Hulk is in another category of difficult. He is much more impervious to harm than Red Hulk, but not invulnerable. Hulk is definitely the one to beat here, and the obvious choice for first, but I think if Rogue and Red Hulk tried to team up on Hulk and then turn on each other, Rogue would be the victor, but if this is against the rules, Hulk would be on top.

So the standings from our analysis are thus :

6th place : Rhino

5th place : Colossus

4th place : Juggernaut

3rd place : Red Hulk / Rogue

2nd place : Red Hulk / Rogue / Hulk

1st place : Rogue / Hulk