answersLogoWhite

0

Yes, the narrator says that Gandalf “had not expected this sudden assault,” but he tells the others that it “has come more swiftly than I guessed,” and knows who is leading the attack. (It’s interesting the way the narrator resolutely refuses to claim knowledge of Gandalf’s thoughts, saying things like “How much Gandalf knew cannot be said.”) So since he knew that goblins and wargs were on their way, you would think he might want to tell them earlier and suggest that they should wait on fighting each other lest they do all the goblins’ work for them, yeah? As it is, Gandalf’s “jump in front of charging dwarves” solution is very dramatic but not very sensible.

Moving back to the start of the chapter, I again thought Gandalf’s actions were suboptimal. Yes, he was able to keep Thorin from throwing Bilbo over the wall, but what if Thorin’s first reaction had been to stab Bilbo in the neck? Hard for even magic to deal with that. One possibly better option would have been for Gandalf to do the talking from the start. He might have had a better chance at snapping Thorin out of it—he certainly couldn’t do worse than Bard, who backs Thorin into a corner when he asks, “Is there then nothing for which you would yield any of your gold?”, before revealing the Arkenstone, and then fuels Thorin’s anger by not answering Thorin’s question about how they got the Arkenstone. Of course, Gandalf seems to be acting in agreement with Bard, holding up the Arkenstone right on cue, so maybe he wouldn’t have been a better choice.

User Avatar

henry Lopez

Lvl 2
4y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

Do you believes in human?

of course. who doesnt!


What religion is a person who believes in God sometimes but sometimes doesnt?

that could happen in any religon


What goes up and down a mountain but doesnt move?

sun


Who does Amanda Bynes play in race to witch mountain?

she doesnt play in that movie


Do greater Swiss mountain dogs have white legs?

I have a greater Swiss mountain dog and he doesnt have white legs but it depends on the parents


Does tom kaulitz believe in love at first sight?

Tom doesnt believe in love, he believes in lust. Sad, but true :[


What do you do if you are being called a bad name at school but no one believes you?

well if a person doesnt believe you then you should tell your best friend. If she or he doesnt belive you then just trust yourself and tell the teacher. The teacher will believe you.


Where is the Hard mountain on Pokemon diamond?

THAT MOUNTAIN DOESNT EXIST!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :) P.S. IF U WANT TO TRADE A REGI ROCK LVL 100 FOR A PICHU LVL 5 BE MY GUEST


Does Serena Williams go from door to door in the practice of her religion?

she used to but she doesnt anymore. that doesnt mean that she is against the practice. i guess her busy schedule doesnt give her the chance to. it is widely believed that when she retires from tennis she will dedicate some part of her life to going door to door preaching what she believes in.


How come Cam Mooney Doesnt run through the banner?

Because Cam Mooney is superstitious person and believes its bad luck or something like that


Who is the one who introduced idols to Islam?

nobody; Isalm doesnt have any idols. It believes in ONE GOD (same God in Christianity and Judaism) who is not a statue.


What is the difforents from a vocano and a mountain?

the difference from a volcano to a mountain is that a vocano erups but a mountain doesnt.