Because, clearly, David Cook had the better voice. David A was too timid and shy, even though, yes, he had a nice-sounding voice. :)
David Cook should definitely win American Idol. He is the best and the best should win. David Archuleta is good but, to young. Sorry Archuleta fans! Go cook
Um... you mean David ARCHULETA. And he didn't win. David Cook won American Idol 7.
No David Archuleta lost to David Cook in the 2008 American Idol final.
david cook
David Archuleta ---- Definately David Archuleta! He has fans all over the world!
The vote difference between David Cook and David Archuleta was over 12 Million Votes
No, he came in second place, otherwise known as the runner up, but he is very successful.No; David Archuleta did not win American Idol. The winner of season seven title was claimed by Archuleta's "rival" David Cook.
no.
David Cook and David Archuleta had a concert together here in the Phillippines last may 16, 2009. They also guested on some variety and talk shows here before the cpncert. David Archuleta likes Phillippine Mangoes.
He was competing against David Archuleta. And David Archuleta SO should of won!!!
David Archuleta because all the girls thinks he cute and loves his voice totally he rocks hes awsome the best he never did anything bad cause he rocks
It's all a matter of opinion, but after what he has done to outdo Cook, most would say Archuleta.