Gerbert Rappaport's birth name is Rappaport, Herbert.
Erik Silvester's birth name is Erik Herschmann.
'They' do not rename the pope. The pope chooses if he wishes to be known by a new name but it is not a requirement. When Our Lord chose Peter as the first pope he change his name from Simon to Peter.
At the time of Pope Valentine, popes did not change their name. He received the name Valentine from his parents.
A pope does not have to change his name but most do. It is symbolic of Jesus changing the name of Simon to Peter at the time he named him as leader of his Church and the first pope.
Yes, he is not required to change his name.
Pope John Paul "Changed his name" just before the end of the Conclave of 1978, just after the Cardinals elected him pope and he accepted election. The cardinal from then on is the new pope, and the new pope, by his papal name.
William Sylvester's birth name is William R. Silvester.
A person who is elected pope (Bishop of Rome) does not have to change his name, but many have done so. It is his decision, and the new name is normally announced to the cardinals when he accepts election.
He didn't have to change his name. He could have kept his birth name but it has been the custom for well over 1000 years to take on a new name at election. Remember, Christ changed Simon's name to Peter when he appointed him as the first pope.
Pope John II who reigned from 533-535 was the first pope to change his name. His birth name was Mercurius, the name of a Roman god. That name did not seem appropriate for the leader of the Catholic Church.
Silvester? Snoopy? Any various collection of Sarahs?