answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

Dennis R MacDonald (The Homeric Epics and the Gospel of Mark) believes that Mark's Gospel is impressive for the apparent number of direct and indirect borrowings from Homer. One or two could be a coincidence, while several would be significant evidence of a relationship, but MacDonald presents numerous examples.

Mark's story of the voyage across the Sea of Galilee and the demonic possession of the swine of the Gadarenes is a particular case wherein MacDonald demonstrates many parallels with Homer. Circe had turned a large number of Odysseus' men into swine, while Jesus cast the many demons into swine, a totally superfluous step in destroying them. When Odysseus was on his boat and leaving, he told Polyphemus to tell everyone what the great Odysseus had done to him, and similarly when Jesus was on his boat and leaving, he told the demoniac to tell everyone what 'the Lord' had done to him. Finally, the giant asked Odysseus to return, but Odysseus refused the request and sailed away with his crew, just as the healed man asked Jesus to allow him to go with him on the ship, but Jesus refused the request and sailed away with his disciples.

Looking a MacDonald's fuller comparison of the two accounts, there is very good reason to believe that the story in Mark's Gospel, and copied in the other gospels, really was inspired by Homer's account. Both stories end with the hero refusing the former wild man's request, and sailing away.

User Avatar

Bill Klocko

Lvl 10
1y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

AnswerBot

6mo ago

There could be several reasons for this. One possibility is that Jesus wanted the healed man to share his testimony with his community, demonstrating the power of God's transformation in his life. Another reason could be that Jesus wanted the man to prioritize his own healing and growth before committing to discipleship. Additionally, Jesus may have had specific plans for the man's mission in that particular region.

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Why do you think Jesus did not permit the man he healed from demons to accompany him on his journey?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

In Georgia is it legal to drive alone in a car with a learner's permit?

NO! A licensed driver must accompany you.


Can you drive with an adult if they are 21 or older?

yes if you have some sort of drivers permit and they have one as well. Generally it is required that a legally licensed adult accompany the person who is driving with a learner's permit.


Can you drive in Alabama with a Georgia learners permit?

If your current address is still Georgia and you have someone who is the proper age (18?) in Georgia to accompany you as you practice driving...


Can a stepparent take a stepchild to get their learners permit in Pennsylvania?

In Pennsylvania, a stepparent can take a stepchild to get their learner's permit if they have written permission from the biological or legal parent. The written consent must specify that the stepparent has the authority to accompany the stepchild for obtaining the permit. Both the stepparent and the biological or legal parent should carry identification when going for the learner's permit.


Do you have to have your parents with you when you do to get your lerners permit at the dmv?

You are not required to learn how to drive from your parents; any licensed driver can legally teach you to drive and can accompany you when you are driving with a learner's permit. And you can pick up the permit by yourself (if you don't have to drive to get there).


What age do you have to be to get your drivers license in Illinois?

At age 15 one can obtain a 'learners permit' which requires an adult age 21 or more to accompany the driver. A full license can be obtained at age 18.


Who must accompany a driver age 16 possessing a temporary permit?

A Licensed driver, 21 years of age or older. If the permitted driver is 18 years of age or older, the accompanied driver must be 18.


What can demons do to you?

If you are a student of Christianity and scripture, they can do literally nothing that you do not permit them to do. They allegedly can try to influence you, but if you have done what you should do, and do not give them leeway to act, they can do nothing.


What must you do in stations or in trains?

You must buy a valid train ticket (or Permit to Travel) for the whole journey you are making before you get on a train at any rail station.


Can you carry a handgun without a permit in Arkansas?

You need to consult with a lawyer for a legally correct and current answer.


Can a nys permit driver be issued a ticket even if they were driving with an out of state ohio license driver?

Not enough information is disclosed about the circumstances. What was the age of the Ohio driver? Were they legally old enough to accompany you? Are out of state licensees permitted to be your 'co-pilot' in NY state?


Can your parents be your drivers ed teaching?

I don't know about being your "teacher," since almost all states license Certified Driving Instructors. However, if you're driving on a learners permit, your parents certainly can accompany you and serve as the on-board licensed driver to satisfy the letter of the law.