answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

BMI can be inaccurate in some cases, because people with a lot of muscle mass will be classified as "overweight" or "obese" according to BMI, when in reality, they're actually not at all. Muscle is more compact and a lot more dense than fat is, so a 250-pound bodybuilder will obviously look (and be) healthier than a 250-pound sedentary guy.

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

BMI isn't always accurate because some people have more muscles than others. Muscle is more dense than fat, and BMI doesn't take that into account. For example, let's say we have two guys. They're both 5'11, and they both weigh 280 pounds. One is a bodybuilder - he has a lot of muscle mass, and very little fat. The other, however, never exercises and is made up of mainly fat. According to their BMIs, they're both considered obese, but which one do you think is healthier? Obviously the one with mostly muscle. That's why it's a great guideline in some cases, but most of the time, it's a far more accurate health indicator to get a body fat test done instead.

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

Wiki User

9y ago

It simply caluculates your weight and height rather than how much of that is muscle and good fat.

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

Wiki User

12y ago

Because it actually depends on what kind it talks about!

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

Wiki User

10y ago

Because Jorge Barrahona invented it.

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Why does BMI not always work?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

What is BMI and what do you use it for?

Your BMI is your body mass index you use it to work out if you are the correct weight of your height


What should a perfect BMI be for 130 pounds and are 5'4?

BMI around 24 is healthy Work yours out yourself: BMI = Weight (Kg) / Height (metres)2.


Have BMI calculations changed?

The fomular tho work out your BMI is:BMI=Weight(kilos(kg))/(height(meters)squared)


Is 9stone overweight for a 11 year old?

If you measure how tall he/she is, you can work out their 'bmi'. This tells you whether they are overweight, underweight, normal, obese etc. However, by the sound of it, no. I don't believe this weight is overweight.To work out his/her 'bmi', the formula is:Body Mass Index (BMI) = weight ÷ (height)²Obese = 30 and over Overweight = 25 and over (BMI) Underweight = 20 and Under


What are some problems with the BMI chart?

well, you can have exceptions. A BMI chart may not always be the best way to see if you are healthy etc. Best person to ask is a doctor or nurse


Is a 115 pound 13-year-old overweight?

It's mainly down to the BMI but do not be surprised if this comes out strange as it does not work always work fully/ as good as poss. on young adults/ kids! I calculated the BMI myself and it came out as 21.80 which is basically the ideal weight. Here is the chart in which you find out which category you fall into: Recommended BMI Chart Underweight BMI less than 18.5 Ideal BMI 18.5-25 Overweight BMI 25-30 Obese BMI 30-40 Very obese BMI greater than 40 So don't worry about it and make sure the BMI doesn't get too high. Hope this helps! P.S. the chart is an official chart (not something I have made up)


How does a height weight scale work?

A height weight scale bases your height and weight in order to get your bmi. your bmi tells your doctor if you are in the healthy weight range or if you need to lose


What is the healthy weight for a girl who is 5'1'' and 18 years old?

To work out your BMI you need to use your height and weight. Use the following formula. BMI = Weight(kg) divided by Height2(m2) or BMI = Weight(lb) times 703 divided by height2(in2) or BMI = Weight(lb) times 4.88 divided by Height2(ft2)


How is BMI calculated?

BMI=(weight in lbs*703)/(height in inches^2) (weight in pounds multiplied by 703) divided by (height in inches squared)


Is someone 168lbs and 5'6 considered overweight?

BMI's (Body Mass Index) are not always the best indicator of proper weight but do provide some basic guidelines for most "normal" people. Your BMI is 27.1 and falls on the overweight category of the BMI scale.BMI Categories: * Underweight =


What should a 5ft 2in womans bmi be?

BMI is weight/(height*height) in kg and metres, a good BMI for adult females is between 20 and 25. You need to work out the weight not the BMI. About 49 to 60 kg or 108 lb to 132 lb.


Im 127 pounds you are 11 you are 4.11ft tall are you fat?

According to the BMI results, you are underweight however the BMI doesn't work well with those that aren't adults.1.44*1.44 = 2.07..35/2.07.. = 16.9...BMI Categories:Underweight =